Footystats Diary, footy's best kept secret

Footy's best kept secret ...

Defending the premiership


<>

Martin Windsor-Black
Defending the premiership
The task of starting a new season
Records show 34 premiers have lost their opening round match in the next season and on three occasions (all three times involving Carlton and Fitzroy) have started the next season with a draw.

Since the national competition started in 1987, the detail on how the Premiers performed at the start of the next season ...

 

PREMIERS

Where Opening round next season
1986 – Hawthorn
1987 – Carlton
1988 – Hawthorn
1989 – Hawthorn
1990 – Collingwood
1991 – Hawthorn
1992 – West Coast
1993 – Essendon
1994 – West Coast
1995 – Carlton
1996 – North Melb
1997 – Adelaide
1998 – Adelaide
1999 – Kangaroos
2000 – Essendon
2001 – Brisbane
2002 – Brisbane
2003 – Brisbane
2004 – Port Adel
2005 – Sydney
2006 – West Coast
2007 – Geelong
2008 – Hawthorn
2009 – Geelong
1987-PP
1988-PP
1989-P
1990-P
1991-P
1992-P
1993-S
1994-MCG
1995-WCA
1996-MCG
1997-MCG(n)
1998-PP
1999-FP(n)
2000-MCG(n)
2001-MCG(n)
2002-SCG
2003-BCG(n)
2004-BCG(n)
2005-S(n)
2006-Dok(n)
2007-Hom(n)
2008-FP(n)
2009-MCG(n)
2010-MCG(n)
Haw 22.17-149 d Car 15.14-104
Car 18.18-126 d Haw 15.21-111
Collingwood 13.15-93 d Haw 11.17-83
Haw 28.24-192 d Gee 11.11-77
Col 21.20-146 d Fsc 11.10-76
Haw 21.15-141 d Gee 18.13-121
WC 17.21-123 d Ess 17.8-110
Ess 12.10-82 d WC 11.13-79
WC 18.13-121 d StK 11.9-75
Car 16.13-109 d Col 12.15-87
Melbourne 10.10-70 d NM 7.13-55
Carlton 10.13-73 d Ade 9.9-63
West.B'dogs 13.13-91 d Ade 12.6-78
West Coast 24.10-154 v Kan 16.15-111
Ess 23.8-146 d Kan 9.7-61
Bri 17.8-110 d Syd 12.15-87
Bri 14.20-104 d Ess 8.13-61
Bri 11.14-80 d Syd 11.12-78
Fremantle 13.10-88 d PA 7.11-53
Essendon 17.6-108 d Syd 12.9-81
WCE 11.8-74 d Syd 10.13-73
PA 14.12-96 v Gee 15.15-105
Geelong
15.21-111 v Haw 16.7-103
Geelong v Essendon

 

113 Premiers from 1897 and 2009
74 have won their first match the following season
 35 have lost their first match the following season
  3 have drawn their first match the following season

The 34 premiers who have lost their opening round match ...

1901-R1-CO — Gee 2.11-23 v Mel 3.3-21
1902-R1-EM — Ess 5.9-39 v Fit 7.10-52
1903-R1-PP — Car 9.4-58 v Col 5.7-37
1907-R1-PP — Car 4.6-30 v StK 8.8-56
1909-R1-PP — Car 3.14-32 v Uni 6.11-47
1913-R1-EM — Ess 9.13-67 v Car 11.17-83
1916-R1-PP — Car 7.18-60 v Fit 9.10-64
1919-R1-AP — SM 6.13-49 v Col 9.8-62
1920-R1-VP — Col 5.6-36 v Ess 7.12-54
1921-R1-PR — Rch 7.11-53 v Car 8.14-62
1924-R1-WH — Ess 8.15-63 v Col 12.7-79
1938-R1-CO — Gee 17.13-115 v Mel 20.12-132
1940-R1-WH — Ess 18.17-125 v Mel 16.12-108
1941-R1-MCG — Mel 13.12-90 v Fit 17.12-114
1942-R1-WH — Ess 25.14-164 v Mel 16.14-110
1949-R1-KP — Gee 21.19-145 v Mel 12.11-83
1957-R1-BS — Fit 7.11-53 v Mel 6.14-50
1959-R1-VP — Col 7.18-60 v SM 14.17-101
1962-R1-WO — Fsc 12.8-80 v Haw 6.11-47
1970-R1-MCG — Rch 14.12-96 v Fit 16.20-116
1971-R1-AS — NM 18.16-124 v Car 14.14-98
1974-R1-MCG — Rch 12.16-88 v Haw 15.14-104
1976-R1-AS — NM 9.10-64 v Mel 11.21-87
1977-R1-PP — Haw 13.14-92 v NM 23.14-152
1979-R1-M — StK 19.14-128 v Haw 14.19-103
1981-R1-P — Car 22.12-144 v Rch 12.10-82
1989-R1-P — Col 13.15-93 v Haw 11.17-83
1997-R1-MCG(n) — NM 7.13-55 v Mel 10.10-70
1998-R1-PP — Car 10.13-73 v Ade 9.9-63
1999-R1-FP(n) — Ade 12.6-78 v WB 13.13-91
2000-R1-MCG(n) — Kan 16.15-111 v WC 24.10-154
2005-R1-S(n) — Fre 13.10-88 v PA 7.11-53
2006-R1-Dok(n) — Ess 17.6-108 v Syd 12.9-81
2009-R1-MCG(n) — Gee 15.21-111 v Haw 16.7-103


The 3 premiers which have drawn their opening round match ...
1915-R1-PP — Car 5.11-41 v Fit 6.5-41
1917-R1-BS — Fit 6.9-45 v Car 6.9-45
1982-R1-PP — Car 16.17-113 v Fit 17.11-113
– amazingly all 3 involved Carlton and Fitzroy!

 

Starting in 2007 the draw ensures the previous grand finalists face each other in Round 1 of the new season.

 

Back to the Diary