Footystats Diary, footy's best kept secret, Match Review, 2007-R25


Masthead1.gif (6053 bytes)
Footy's best kept secret ...

2007, Match Review — Round 25
1st and 2nd Preliminary Finals


Ladder after Round 22
Stats Update of every round, 2007



2007, ROUND 25, WEEK 3
PRELIMINARY FINALS
Friday-Saturday, September 21-22

Cats beat Pies by a whisker in desperate battle
Port annihilate Kangas at Footy Park

THE STATS THAT MATTER ...
MILESTONES OF PRELIMINARY FINALS —
l
150th JOEL COREY (Geelong 2000-07) ... 100th DEAN BROGAN (Port Adelaide 2001-07) ... Geelong played their 250th match at the MCG ... the North Melbourne-Kangaroos played their 66th final, and the first at an interstate venue – their first final was at Princes Park in 1945 ...

l North Melbourne champion GLENN ARCHER played his 311th and final League game; Port and Kanga players formed a guard of honour for the Shinboner of the Century after the match and the famous #11 was accorded a warm standing ovation by the Port Adelaide faithful.

Highest Score:

20.13-133, PORT ADEL v Kangaroos
Biggest Margin: 87pts, PORT ADEL v Kangaroos
Best in Goals: 3, Steve JOHNSON (Gee)
3, Mathew STOKES (Gee)
3, Travis CLOKE (Col)
3, Brett EBERT (PA)
3, Daniel MOTLOP (PA)
3, Warren TREDREA (PA)
Lowest Score: 5.16-46, KANGAROOS v Port Adelaide
Best Quarters: 1st 6.0-36 PA v Kan
2nd 4.2-26 COL v Gee
3rd 8.7-55 PA v Kan
4th 4.1-25 GEE v Col
COL v Gee

Official AFL attendances for 2007, Finals, Week 3 —

98,002 Geelong v Collingwood (MCG)
43,950 Port Adelaide v Kangaroos (Football Park)
141,955 Total for Finals, Week 2 — (2006: 111,887)
6,810.688 Progressive after 2007 Finals, Week 2
6,952,643 Progressive at Finals, Week 3 – (2006: 6,638,803)

FROM THE PRELIMINARY FINALS

GEELONG v COLLINGWOOD
l
Geelong played their 250th match at the MCG – it was Collingwood's 450th ...
l the match produced the fourth final this year where the margin was less than a kick at full-time, including Collingwood's extra-time win in the epic semi-final a week ago against West Coast ...
l it was the 20th time the two had opposed each other in a final – both have now won ten times ...
l the crowd of 98,002 was the largest to see Geelong and Collingwood play – previous highest was 91,715 in the 1967 First Semi-Final at the MCG ...
l at the 213th meeting no new match records were observed ...
l the Cats won their way into their first Grand Final in 12 years – chasing its first premiership in 44 years ...
l 98,002 is the biggest crowd since the MCG was redeveloped and the biggest for a preliminary final since 1973 ...
l a trio of Macs controlled the match when STEPHEN McBURNEY, SCOTT McLAREN and SHANE McINERNEY were the appointed field umpires – and we haven't found when or if this has occurred before ...
l many angry MCC members who had paid $93 a seat were locked out when gates to the Members Reserve were closed at 7.10pm when capacity was reached ...
l 150th JOEL COREY (Geelong 2000-07) ...

PORT ADELAIDE v KANGAROOS
l after the Roos led 3.1 to 3.0 in the 18th minute of Q1, Port for the balance kicked 17.13 to 2.15 – the Kangas 3rd goal came in the 17th minute of Q1, their 4th goal was 29½ minutes into Q3 (during which time Port kicked 13 unanswered goals) ...
l Port Adelaide's 8.7-55 is the second-highest score kicked in Q3 in preliminary finals – only 10.1-61 by Carlton v Collingwood in 1932 is greater – it is also a new Q3 high by Port against the North Kangaroos ...
l Port won twice in-a-row over the Kangas for the first time – they also won the Round 2 encounter at Football Park ...
l the 87-point margin was the same result as the 2005-1EF when Port 26.8-174 beat the Kangaroos 11.11-77 ...
l 5.16-46 by the Kangas is the lowest score of 18 meetings versus Port ...
l no other new match records were noted ...
l 100th DEAN BROGAN (Port Adelaide 2001-07) ...
l the North Melbourne-Kangaroos played their 66th final, and the first at an interstate venue – their first final was at Princes Park in 1945 ...
l North Melbourne champion GLENN ARCHER played his 311th and final League game; Port and Kanga players formed a guard of honour for the Shinboner of the Century after the match and the famous #11 was accorded a warm standing ovation by the Port Adelaide faithful.

uuuu

Both grand finalists missing the next year
The Grand Final will take place without both Sydney and West Coast who played off each other in 2005 and 2006.

Grand Finalists to miss finals the following season are –
1962 – Essendon-Carlton – both did not make the 1963 finals ...
1961 – Hawthorn-Footscray – both did not make the 1962 finals ...
1945 – Carlton-South Melb – both did not make the 1946 finals
1944 – Fitzroy-Richmond – both did not make the 1945 finals

uuuu
 

Bruce Kennedy
Kangaroos: Biggest defeat aggregate in finals
The performance in this year's finals by the North Melbourne-Kangaroos outstrips any that can be found in the record books.

The Shinboners already figure in three of the five 100+ point defeats experienced in finals and in 2007 have achieved the biggest margin aggregate of defeats by a club in any finals series.

The parallels for comparison –
When-where Scores Marg Agg
1934-2SF-MCG Rch 19.20-134 v Geelong 7.8-50 84 +
1934-PF-MCG Geelong 7.6-48 v SM 15.18-108 60 144
       
1987-QF-P Haw 23.18-156 v Sydney 8.9-57 99 +
1987-1SF-MCG Sydney 10.13-73 v Mel 21.23-149 76 175
       
1996-1QF-S WCE 18.17-125 v Carlton 10.10-70 55 +
1996-2SF(n)-BCG Bri 26.14-170 v Carlton 10.13-73 97 152
       
2000-1QF-MCG Ess 31.12-198 v Kangaroos 11.7-73 125 +
2000-2PF(n)-MCG Mel 23.18-156 v Kangaroos 17.4-106 50 175
       
2007-1QF-MCG Gee 23.18-156 v Kangaroos 8.2-50 106 +
2007-1PF-FP PA 20.13-133 v Kangaroos 5.16-46 87 193

u

uuuu
 

Statistics for Footystats are enhanced by software from
Eric Sorensen's *Footy Works* (v 1.5.4)

uuuu



*

 


To gain a place in the Grand Final, Geelong and Collingwood fought each to a standstill in a gripping last quarter on Friday night before a huge crowd of 98,002 at the MCG – the biggest preliminary final attendance since 1973.

ABC News reported: In a pulsating and tightly-contested match that defied the predictions of many pundits, the never-say-die Magpies pressed the Cats right until the final siren but could not produce the winning play as Geelong clinched a thrilling finals victory.

Paul Gough observed for Sportal: Geelong will now get the chance to end its premiership drought – stretching back to 1963. The Cats' have famously lost five grand finals since their last flag success nearly half a century ago – including four in seven seasons between 1989 and 1995 – but they proved they have the character as well as the talent to break the drought.

Right from the moment skipper Tom Harley dropped two easy marks in the opening two minutes, the Cats looked nervous as the burden of favouritism appeared to weigh heavily on them.

ABC News summarised: The Cats looked strong throughout the contest but never managed to put the resilient Magpies away, the Nathan Buckley-led side courageously clawing their way back into the match after twice trailing by three goals. Despite this the Pies managed to snatch the lead midway through the third quarter, an advantage that would be shortlived as goals from Cameron Ling and Cameron Mooney propelled the Cats back in front before the final term.

Travis Cloke typified the stubborn and unrelenting mindset of his side when he kicked a major to open the last quarter, but consecutive goals from Mooney, Steve Johnson and Paul Chapman looked to have put the competition favourites into an unassailable lead and into next week's decider.

But last-ditch efforts from Cloke and Alan Didak once again resuscitated the match as a contest and gave the Pies a faint hope of overturning the Cats at the death, before Gary Ablett sealed the result with a major to cap the see-sawing affair.

Ablett popped up with a big play at a crucial time in the match as he has done throughout the entire season, his mercurial performance a testament to a stellar season that garnered him selection in the All-Australian squad.

Sportal concluded: Ablett's superb snap on the run gave the Cats an 11-point lead with just over seven minutes left. It would turn out to be the winning goal as the Pies got one back, through Paul Medhurst with a minute remaining, but it was not enough to prevent the Cats' from overcoming by far the biggest hurdle in their premiership tilt to date.

But the young Pies – with seven players less than 21 in their line-up – can hold their heads high but while the likes of young gun Cloke (three goals) will get another chance at premiership glory, this loss could signal the end of the glittering careers of Collingwood veterans Buckley and Scott Burns.

2007 — 1st PRELIMINARY FINAL — GAME 1
Geelong v Collingwood
Friday (n), September 21, 2007
MCG, 7.50pm AEST, crowd: 98,002
Conditions: Good
Weather: 13C, clearing after a day of showers
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
GEE 4.4-28 (11) 7.6-48 (5) 9.13-67 (5) 13.14-92 (5)
COL 2.5-17 6.7-43 9.8-62 13.9-87
Goals: Geelong: Steve Johnson 3, Mathew Stokes 3, Cameron Mooney 2, Gary Ablett, Paul Chapman, James Kelly, Brad Ottens, Max Rooke. Collingwood: Travis Cloke 3, Alan Didak 2, Paul Medhurst 2, Sean Rusling 2, Scott Burns, Leon Davis, Shane O'Bree, Anthony Rocca.
Best: Geelong: Brad Ottens, Gary Ablett, Matthew Scarlett, James Kelly, Jimmy Bartel, Joel Corey, Mathew Stokes. Collingwood: Travis Cloke, Heath Shaw, Nathan Buckley, Dane Swan, Martin Clarke, Shane Wakelin.
Umpires: Stephen McBurney, Scott McLaren, Shane McInerney.

 

Port Adelaide humiliated the North Melbourne-Kangaroos by 87 points in the late-Saturday early-evening preliminary final played in front of 43,953 fans at Football Park. It was a masterful, embarrassing thrashing that puts Port into its second grand final in four seasons.

Ashley Porter noted in The Age: It was an amazing, club record-breaking win, and the difference between these sides was so vast that it was difficult to assess whether Port was that good, or the Kangas were so abysmal. Probably both, but whatever, it was a dreadfully one-sided final. Rarely has a side kicked so badly for goal in a final that the Kangaroos, but by far the most damning observation was that they virtually gave up the chase midway through the third quarter when Port cracked a 10-goal lead.

Alan Shiell pertinently noted for Sportal: Roos veteran Glenn Archer deserved a more fitting send-off in his 311th and last AFL appearance. The Roos and Port players formed a guard of honour to applaud the Shinboner of the Century – and the crowd joined in with a standing ovation.

Troy Chaplin led a star-studded Port cast with a strong, rebounding display at centre half-back, Chad Cornes was effective everywhere and forwards Daniel Motlop, Brett Ebert and Warren Tredrea kicked three goals each to capitalise on the good work further afield – where Tom Logan, David Rodan and Jacob Surjan, among others, were always busy.

Daniel Harris, Adam Simpson and Jess Sinclair were the Roos' leading possession winners but most of the time it didn't really matter.

Probably the only negative for Port was the loss nine minutes into the second quarter of veteran defender Michael Wilson who snapped an Achilles in his left foot certainly ending his season and possibly the career of the 30-year-old.

2007 — 2nd PRELIMINARY FINAL — GAME 2
Port Adelaide v Kangaroos
Saturday, September 22, 2007
Football Park, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 43,953
Conditions: Very good; gusty NE breeze to southern goal
Weather: 26C, warm, fine and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
PA 6.0-36 (16) 9.3-57 (32) 17.10-112 (78) 20.13-133 (87)
KAN 3.2-20 3.7-25 4.10-34 5.16-46
Goals: Port: Daniel Motlop 3, Brett Ebert 3, Warren Tredrea 3, David Rodan 2, Tom Logan 2, Steven Salopek 2, Kane Cornes, Danyle Pearce, Travis Boak, Chad Cornes, Justin Westhoff. Kangaroos: Shannon Grant 2, Aaron Edwards, Daniel Harris, Ed Lower.
Best: Port: Troy Chaplin, Chad Cornes, Tom Logan, Brendon Lade, Jacob Surjan, Warren Tredrea, Danyle Pearce. Kangaroos: Adam Simpson, Daniel Harris, Jess Sinclair, Brent Harvey.
Umpires: Michael Vozzo, Hayden Kennedy, Brett Rosebury.

 


 
2007 Ladder after Round 22

    W L D F A % Pts
1 Geelong 18 4 2542 1664 152.8 72
2 Port Adelaide 15 7 2314 2038 113.5 60
3 West Coast 15 7 2162 1935 111.7 60
4 Kangaroos 14 8 2183 1998 109.3 56
5 Hawthorn 13 9 2097 1855 113.0 52
6 Collingwood 13 9 2011 1992 101.0 52
7 Sydney 12 9 1 2031 1698 119.6 50
8 Adelaide 12 10 1881 1712 109.9 48
9 St Kilda 11 10 1 1874 1941 96.5 46
10 Brisbane 9 11 2 1986 1885 105.4 40
11 Fremantle 10 12 2254 2198 102.5 40
12 Essendon 10 12 2184 2394 91.2 40
13 West.B'dogs 9 12 1 2111 2469 85.5 38
14 Melbourne 5 17 1890 2418 78.2 20
15 Carlton 4 18 2167 2911 74.4 16
16 Richmond 3 18 1 1958 2537 77.2 14


 

FOR THE RECORD

COL HUTCHINSON's
Approaching Milestones
2007, Preliminary Finals
Friday-Saturday, September 21-22
(subject to selection, injury or suspension)
CAREER MATCHES
150 – JOEL COREY (Geelong 2000-07)
ü
100 – DEAN BROGAN (Port Adelaide 2001-07)
ü
CAREER GOALS
400 – ANTHONY ROCCA (Col 384, Syd 11), 395 goals, 229 games
MATCHES AT VENUES
250 – Geelong has played 249 League matches at the MCG
ü
FINALS MATCHES
  66 – The North Melbourne-Kangaroos have played 65 finals since their first at Princes Park in 1945. The 66th will be their first final at an interstate venue 
ü

<>

 

<>

2007, Week 3, Finals

GEELONG 13.14-92 (S.Johnson 3, Stokes 3, Mooney 2) best, Ottens, G.Ablett, Scarlett, COLLINGWOOD 13.9-87 (Cloke 3, Didak 2, Medhurst 2, Rusling 2) best, Cloke, H.Shaw, Buckley.
Friday night at MCG: 98,002.

PORT ADELAIDE 20.13-133 (Motlop 3, Ebert 3, Tredrea 3) best, Chaplin, C.Cornes, Logan, KANGAROOS 5.16-46 (Grant 2) best, Simpson, Harris, Sinclair.
Saturday at Football Park: 43,953.

uuuu

<>

 

*

Consecutive Matches
2007, Week 3, Finals

191 – Adam GOODES (Syd) from 1999-R22 – 2+22+23+22+24+24+26+25+23
144 Matthew PAVLICH (Fre) from 2001-R15 – 8+22+23+22+22+25+22
140 Brett KIRK (Syd) from 2002-R15 – 8+24+24+26+25+23
102 Nick DAL SANTO (StK) from 2003-R15 – 8+25+24+23+22
104 Kane CORNES (PA) from 2003-R17 – 9+25+24+22+24
 

u

 


In the Goals, 2007 Games Goals PF Total
Score
Jonathan BROWN (Brisbane) 22 77 > 77.38-500
Lance FRANKLIN (Hawthorn) 22 73 > 73.62-500
Matthew PAVLICH (Fremantle) 22 72 > 72.48-480
Matthew LLOYD (Essendon) 19 62 > 62.31-403
Cameron MOONEY (Geelong) 24 62 2.2 62.37-409
Scott LUCAS (Essendon) 22 61 > 61.28-394
Brendan FEVOLA (Carlton) 19 59 > 59.41-395
Fraser GEHRIG (St Kilda) 20 59 > 59.35-389
Brad JOHNSON (West.B'dogs) 21 59 > 59.26-380
Brett EBERT (Port Adelaide) 23 56 3.1 56.26-362
Anthony ROCCA (Collingwood) 23 55 1.1 55.37-367
Matthew RICHARDSON (Richmond) 22 53 > 53.40-358
Quinten LYNCH (West Coast) 24 52 . 52.46-358
Scott WELSH (Adelaide) 21 49 > 49.20-314
Corey JONES (Kangaroos) 23 46 inj 46.31-307
Steve JOHNSON (Geelong) 19 45 3.0 45.31-301
Barry HALL (Sydney) 20 44 > 44.30-294
Daniel MOTLOP (Port Adelaide) 17 44 3.1 44.17-281
Nick RIEWOLDT (St Kilda) 20 42 > 42.26-278
Russell ROBERTSON (Melbourne) 15 42 > 42.26-278
Michael O'LOUGHLIN (Sydney) 23 40 > 40.14-254
Jarryd ROUGHEAD (Hawthorn) 22 40 1.1 40.36-276
Travis CLOKE (Collingwood) 25 39 3.1 39.39-273
Brad FISHER (Carlton) 20 39 > 39.15-249
Shannon GRANT (Kangaroos) 25 39 2.1 39.21-255
Drew PETRIE (Kangaroos) 25 38 0.0 38.16-244
Shaun BURGOYNE (Port Adelaide) 24 37 0.0 37.23-245
Kayne PETTIFER (Richmond) 22 37 > 37.21-243
         

After 22 rounds

2007

 

2006

 

2005

 

2004

Brown (Bri) 77   Fevola (Car) 84   Gehrig (StK) 74   Gehrig (StK) 90
Pavlich (Fre) 72   Johnson (WB) 70   Hall (Syd) 72   Lloyd (Ess) 89
Franklin (Haw) 63   Gehrig (StK) 68   Robertson (M) 69   Tredrea (PA) 75
Lloyd (Ess) 62   Hall (Syd) 67   Richardson (R) 65   Hall (Syd) 70
Lucas (Ess) 61   Lucas (Ess) 67   Williams (Haw) 63   Neitz (Mel) 69
      Pavlich (Fre) 63   Pavlich (Fre) 61   Fevola (Car) 66
3 x 59     Neitz (Mel) 61   Tredrea (PA) 61   Richardson (R) 65

 

 

EVERY ROUND, EVERY GAME OF SEASON 2007

MATCH REVIEW ARCHIVE
Round One, Round Two, Round Three, Round Four, Round Five,
Round Six, Round SevenRound Eight, Round Nine, Round 10,
Round 11, Round 12, Round 13, Round 14, Round 15, Round 16,
Round 17, Round 18, Round 19, Round 20, Round 21, Round 22,
Elim & Qual, Semi-Finals,


CLUB-BY-CLUB PERFORMANCE, SEASON 2007
REGULARLY UPDATED
Adelaide, Brisbane, Carlton, Collingwood, Essendon, Fremantle, Geelong, Hawthorn,
Kangaroos, Melbourne, Port Adelaide, Richmond, St Kilda, Sydney, West Coast, Western Bulldogs
also
Consecutive Wins and Losses at all venues


 
Travellin' 2007
1 R1(n)-S Port Adelaide v Fre WON 1/1
2 R1(n)-BCG Hawthorn v Bri Lost 1/2
3 R1(n)-Hom West Coast v Syd WON 2/3
4 R1-FP Essendon v Ade WON 3/4
5 R2(n)-BCG St Kilda v Bri Lost 3/5
6 R2-MCG Sydney v Rch WON 4/6
7 R2(n)-S Collingwood v WCE Lost 4/7
8 R2-FP Kangaroos v PA Lost 4/8
9 R2-Dok Fremantle v Ess Lost 4/9
10 R2(n)-MCG Adelaide v WB WON 5/10
11 R3-SCG Brisbane v Syd Lost 5/11
12 R4-MCG Port Adelaide v Col WON 6/12
13 R4(n)-C Kangaroos v Bri WON 7/13
14 R4(n)-FP Sydney v Ade Lost 7/14
15 R4-YPL Geelong v Haw Lost 7/15
16 R4-MCG Fremantle v Mel WON 8/16
17 R4-S Carlton v WCE Lost 8/17
18 R5(n)-FP St Kilda v PA Lost 8/18
19 R5-MCG West Coast v Rch WON 9/19
20 R5(n)-Dok Brisbane v Car WON 10/20
21 R5-S Adelaide v Fre WON 11/21
22 R6-S West.B'dogs v WCE Lost 11/22
23 R6(n)-Dok Sydney v Kan Lost 11/23
24 R6(n)-FP Collingwood v Ade WON 12/24
25 R6-BCG Fremantle v Bri Lost 12/25
26 R6-MCG Port Adelaide v Mel WON 13/26
27 R7-FP Richmond v PA Lost 13/27
28 R7(n)-BCG Adelaide v Bri WON 14/28
29 R7(n)-Dok Sydney v StK Lost 14/29
30 R7-KP West Coast v Gee Lost 14/30
31 R7-S Hawthorn v Fre Lost 14/31