Footystats Diary, footy's best kept secret, Match Review, 2007-R6


Masthead1.gif (6053 bytes)
Footy's best kept secret ...

2007, Match Review — Round 6


Ladder after Round 6
Stats Update of every round, 2007



2007, ROUND 6,
Friday-Saturday-Sunday, May 4-5-6

Strong finish gives Saints good win over Blues
Hawks rip the through the Bombers
West Coast hold off gritty Bulldogs
Kangaroos win third straight and stun tardy Swans
Fresh Magpies beat Adelaide in hard slog
Lions score runaway win over Dockers
Port beat Demons in tight finish
Richmond suffers its greatest defeat
Geelong on a rampage decimate the Tigers

THE STATS THAT MATTER ...
l
Richmond suffered its greatest League defeat of 1,989 games since 1908 – the margin of 157 points exceeded the 9.14-68 v 32.17-209 defeat of 141 points from North Melbourne in 1990-R2 at the MCG ...
l 35.12-222 is the best Geelong score of 179 games against the Tigers and the third-highest all-time score by the club in 2,145 League matches since 1897 ...
l Geelong kicked new highest scores against Richmond for Q1, Q2 and Q3 ...
l Geelong recorded a new AFL high 3rd quarter score of 29.9-183 replacing 27.17-179 by Brisbane in 1993-R8 against Sydney at the Gabba – 144pts was also established as the 2nd-highest all-time three-quarter-time margin in League football behind 161pts by Brisbane in 1993 versus Sydney ...

MILESTONES OF ROUND 6

l
200th SIMON GOODWIN (Adelaide) 1997-2007 ... 150th NICK DAVIS, 79 Syd 2003-07; 71 Col 1999-2002 ... 100th RYAN HARGRAVE (West.B'dogs) 2002-07 ... KAYNE PETTIFER (Richmond) played his 50th consecutive game since 2005-R1 ... SHANE TUCK (Richmond) played his 50th consecutive game since 2005-R1 ... DARREN JOLLY (Sydney) played his 50th consecutive game since 2005-R8 ... ALASTAIR CLARKSON (Hawthorn) coached his 50th match since 2005-R1 ... TERRY WALLACE coached Richmond for the 50th time since 2005-R1; also 148 WB 1996-2002 ... Adelaide lost its 200th AFL match ...

Highest Score:

35.12-222, GEELONG v Richmond
Biggest Margin: 157pts, GEELONG v Richmond
Best in Goals: 9.2, Lance FRANKLIN (Haw) v Ess
6.3, Fraser GEHRIG (StK) v Car
6.2, Brendan FEVOLA (Car) v StK
Lowest Score: 9.8-62, WEST.B'DOGS v West Coast
9.8-62, ADELAIDE v Collingwood
Best Quarters: 1st 10.2-62 GEE v Rch
2nd 10.4-64 GEE v Rch
3rd 9.3-57 GEE v Rch
4th 6.4-40 SYD v Kan

Official AFL attendances for 2007, Round 6

45,513 St Kilda v Carlton (Docklands)
52,047 Essendon v Hawthorn (MCG)
40,668 West Coast v West.B'dogs (Subiaco)
27,045 Kangaroos v Sydney (Docklands)
43,915 Adelaide v Collingwood (Football Park)
27,175 Brisbane v Fremantle (BCG)
16,266 Melbourne v Port Adelaide (MCG)
34,584 Richmond v Geelong (Docklands)
287,213 Total for Round 6 — (2006: 340,193)
1,811,445 Progressive at R6 – (2006: 1,753,462)

FROM THE ROUND

ST KILDA v CARLTON
l The Saints extended their run to eight successive wins against Carlton – its longest run of success in 201 games versus the Blues since 1897 ...
l ABC Radio noted nine posters for the game (and confirmed by Champion Data) which is near the record of 11 experienced in the 1936 match Footscray against Carlton at the Western Oval –

11 1936-R5-WO Footscray 6, Carlton 5
10 1924-R4-PR
1937-R16-VP
Richmond 7, Fitzroy 3
Collingwood 4, Melbourne 6

9 

1920-R17-CO South Melb 8, Geelong 1
2007-R6(n)-Dok St Kilda 6, Carlton 3
8 2006-2PF-FP Adelaide 4, West Coast 4

7

1936-R5-AS Melbourne 5, North Melb 2
1987-R8 or R22** Fitzroy 5, Sydney 2
2004-R15(n)-Dok Geelong 5, Collingwood 2
2006-R6-Dok Kangaroos 4, Hawthorn 3
2006-R15(n)-MCG Melbourne 6, Richmond 1
2007-R6(n)-FP Collingwood 7, Adelaide 0

6

1914-R10-EM Essendon 3, Geelong 3 (all in first half)
1919-R4-PP Carlton 6, Geelong 0
1928-R6-CO
1942-R2 or 14-PR**
Fitzroy 5, Geelong 0
Richmond 5, Melbourne 0

ESSENDON v HAWTHORN
l 20.11-131 is Hawthorn's highest score against Essendon for 15 years since 32.24-216 in 1992-R20 at the MCG ...
l four straight wins over the Dons is the best by Hawthorn since six on-the-trot in 1987-89 ...
l LANCE FRANKLIN (Haw) kicked a career-best 9.2 – the best effort by a Hawk versus the Bombers since JASON DUNSTALL booted nine in 1998-R10 at Waverley ...
l ALASTAIR CLARKSON (Hawthorn) coached his 50th match since 2005-R1 ...
l no other new match records were noted ...

WEST COAST v WEST.B'DOGS
l the Eagles with six-straight enjoy the same start as they had in 1991 and 2005 – both grand final seasons; overall West Coast have won nine on-the-trot as they last lost a match on September 9 last year when they went down to Sydney in the First Qualifying Final at Subiaco, 85-84 ...
l no new match records were noted ...
l 100th RYAN HARGRAVE (West.B'dogs) 2002-07 ...

KANGAROOS v SYDNEY
l After 14 matches at either the SCG or Manuka the Kangaroos and Swans met in Melbourne for the first time since 1998-R8 when at the MCG, Sydney with 14.11-95 (same score as Saturday) lost by 10 points to North Melbourne 15.15-105 ...
l GRAEME BOND on 3AW noted the Kangas are the only side to have won the first quarter of all six opening matches this season ...
l SHANNON GRANT passed 300 career goals in game 261 from matches with North-Kangas and Sydney (1995-2007) ...
l GLENN ARCHER reached 294 club matches for the North Melbourne Kangaroos, the equal of KEITH GREIG (1971-85) and second only to the 306 games by WAYNE SCHIMMELBUSCH (1973-87) ...
l 150th NICK DAVIS, 79 Syd 2003-07; 71 Col 1999-2002 ... DARREN JOLLY (Sydney) played his 50th consecutive game since 2005-R8 ...
l no other new match records were noted ...

ADELAIDE v COLLINGWOOD
l Champion Data confirmed Collingwood hit the post an extraordinary SEVEN times – the last occasion seven was recorded was by Richmond against Fitzroy in the 1924-R4 match at Punt Road.
The record by a club is EIGHT, by South Melbourne in a 1920 match at Corio Oval against Geelong ... (see chart above) ...

l
Adelaide lost its 200th AFL match ...
l
200th SIMON GOODWIN (Adelaide) 1997-2007 ...

BRISBANE v FREMANTLE
l from seven visits the Dockers remain winless at the Gabba ...
l no new match records were noted ...

MELBOURNE v PORT ADELAIDE
l at their seventh visit Port Adelaide beat Melbourne at the MCG for the first time ...
l Melbourne with six defeats are in their worst start to a season since 1995 ...
l only 16,266 attended – however small, it was greater than the 12,410 that watched the pair at headquarters in 2003-R7 ...
l no other new match records were noted ...

RICHMOND v GEELONG
l Richmond suffered its greatest League defeat of 1,989 games since 1908 – the margin of 157 points exceeded the 9.14-68 v 32.17-209 defeat of 141 points from North Melbourne in 1990-R2 at the MCG ...
l 35.12-222 is the best Geelong score of 179 games against the Tigers and the third-highest all-time score by the club in 2,145 League matches since 1897 ...
l Geelong kicked new highest scores against Richmond for Q1, Q2 and Q3 ...
l Geelong recorded a new AFL high 3rd quarter score of 29.9-183 replacing 27.17-179 by Brisbane in 1993-R8 against Sydney at the Gabba – 144pts was also established as the 2nd-highest all-time three-quarter-time margin in League football behind 161pts by Brisbane in 1993 versus Sydney ...
l Geelong had 15 goalkickers, one short of the League record of 16 held by Essendon, Hawthorn and West Coast – it was a second time for the Cats – they had 15 versus the Bulldogs in 1999-R2 played at Princes Park ...
l Richmond suffered their 7th-straight loss – they also lost in R22 last year ...
l the Tigers equalled their worst start to a season from 1962 which was part of a 14-game losing streak including the last eight games of 1961 ...
l KAYNE PETTIFER (Richmond) played his 50th consecutive game since 2005-R1 ... SHANE TUCK (Richmond) played his 50th consecutive game since 2005-R1 ... TERRY WALLACE coached Richmond for the 50th time since 2005-R1; also 148 WB 1996-2002 ...

uuuu

Statistics for Footystats are enhanced by software from
Eric Sorensen's *Footy Works* (v 1.5.4)

uuuu



*

 


Though boosted by an outstanding six-goal effort by Brendan Fevola, Carlton still didn't have enough in reserve to beat St Kilda who had Fraser Gehrig bag half-a-dozen for his side in an entertaining match under the closed roof at Docklands on Friday night.

Sam Lienert reported on the AFL website that an undermanned St Kilda used extreme flooding tactics to frustrate a dangerous Carlton attack and lined up with as many as nine players in defence at times.

Andrew Wu noted for Sportal: The Blues were most dangerous in the third quarter when their forwards were allowed to play man-on-man, even if this meant they lined up with nine men inside their attacking 50, slamming five unanswered goals to reduce a 34-point deficit to just four shortly before three-quarter time. However, Gehrig booted two of his six goals just prior to the final change and were able to stem the Carlton charge.

Chip Le Grand assessed the match in The Australian: With the best of Carlton absorbed, St Kilda finished stronger. The final margin was an emphatic 43 points.

Ironically, the stand-out performance of the night was Fevola's. In a match tailor-made for Fevola to experience the kind of brain-fade that has marred his career, he competed relentlessly against James Gwilt and his many helpers to boot six goals and keep Carlton in the match. His most fitting goal was his last, Double-teamed by Gwilt and Jason Gram, Fevola out-bodied one and out-reached the other to mark three deep.

For St Kilda, the clear head and clean hands of Nick Dal Santo provided the difference between the two teams in the midfield, along with Steven Baker's typically brutal stopping job on Carlton's Marc Murphy. Baker's only concern is the clumsy contact he made with Jordan Russell in the opening quarter, when he flattened him with a raised forearm.

Note: The AFL Tribunal on Tuesday night dealt with two charges involving Baker. He was suspended for two matches; one for striking Murphy, one for rough conduct on Russell.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 1
St Kilda v Carlton
Friday (n), May 4, 2007
Docklands, 7.40pm AEST; Roof closed, crowd: 45,513
Conditions: Good – slight dew on surface from humidity
Weather: 18C, fine but cool
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
STK 4.3-27 (10) 8.8-56 (21) 13.11-89 (15) 18.17-125 (43)
CAR 2.5-17 4.11-35 10.14-74 11.16-82
Goals: St Kilda: Fraser Gehrig 6.3, Stephen Milne 3, Sam Gilbert 2, Jason Gram 2, Nick Dal Santo, Aaron Fiora, Robert Harvey, Justin Koschitzke, Nick Riewoldt. Carlton: Brendan Fevola 6.2, Lance Whitnall 3, Eddie Betts, Andrew Walker.
Best: St Kilda: Nick Dal Santo, Fraser Gehrig, Robert Harvey, Justin Koschitzke, Luke Ball, Leigh Montagna. Carlton: Brendan Fevola, Heath Scotland, Andrew Walker, Jarrad Waite, Lance Whitnall, Andrew Carrazzo.
Umpires: Brett Rosebury, Brett Allen, Scott Jeffery.
Reports:
Steven Baker (StK) cited with striking Marc Murphy (Car) during Q1. An early plea would draw a one-match suspension.
Steven Baker (StK) cited with rough conduct against Jordan Russell (Car) during Q4. An early plea would draw a one-match suspension.
St Kilda sought the adjudication of the Tribunal on both charges. On Tuesday the Tribunal found Baker guilty on both charges. He was however spared a third week of suspension by the ruling of Tribunal chairman David Jones. Instead of combining the points from both guilty verdicts, which would have given Baker a three-match suspension, the St Kilda was allowed to carry forward 155 demerit points towards his next appearance at the Tribunal, or effectively taking a one match suspended sentence.

 

In the Saturday afternoon match at the MCG Hawthorn were spurred on with a career-best nine goals from Lance 'Buddy' Franklin, including five in a sensational 15-minute burst in the second quarter, which enabled the Hawks to comfortably beat Essendon by 35 points.

Ben Dixon and Tim Boyle both added three goals in supporting roles up forward, while Shane Crawford reprised some of his very best form with 27 touches in midfield. He had no shortage of helpers around the ball, with Brad Sewell, Sam Mitchell and Jordan Lewis all picking up more than 20 touches.

Angus Morgan noted for Sportal: Not as eye-catching but just as effective was Campbell Brown who conceded 15cm to Scott Lucas and held the Bombers forward, of whom much was expected in the absence of Matthew Lloyd, to just 10 possessions and one goal.

For the Bombers, Jason Johnson's first match for 2007 was a beauty, and he enjoyed good support from Mark McVeigh and Brent Stanton.

Emma Quayle for The Age noted Hawthorn was good not only at setting the pace, but making sure the Bombers were never really able to think clearly. The Hawks played with quicker wits than the Bombers, picking when they planned to handball and to whom. More than once, an Essendon player tried to flick the ball over to someone running past, only for it to be chopped off by a jumping Hawthorn player.

The Bombers' best chance came during the third term. They got to within three points after a snap from Brent Stanton, and later to within four, after the Lucas goal. Two pieces of play suggested the Hawks were still thinking ahead of them: twice. Essendon players took shots at goal, only to find a Hawthorn player standing alone on the goal line.

Sunday was about Buddy being brilliant, and creating goals from nowhere. But it also suggested opportunities are easier to make the most of when you create plenty of them, and control the events surrounding them for as long as you possibly can.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 2
Essendon v Hawthorn
Saturday, May 5, 2007
MCG, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 52,047
Conditions: Slippery early after early afternoon rain
Weather: 21C; grey, overcast turning to some sunshine; late gloom
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
ESS 4.2-26 (4) 8.3-51 11.3-69 15.6-96
HAW 3.3-21 9.5-59 (8) 15.8-98 (29) 20.11-131 (35)
Goals: Hawthorn: Lance Franklin 9.2, Tim Boyle 3, Ben Dixon 3, Jarryd Roughead 2, Jordan Lewis, Luke Hodge, Thomas Murphy. Essendon: Jason Johnson 2, Andrew Welsh 2, Brent Stanton 2, Alwyn Davey 2, Courtney Johns 2, Andrew Lovett, Patrick Ryder, Scott Lucas, Mal Michael, Jason Winderlich.
Best: Hawthorn: Lance Franklin, Brad Sewell, Shane Crawford, Ben Dixon, Campbell Brown, Luke Hodge. Essendon: Jason Johnson, Mark McVeigh, Brent Stanton, Dustin Fletcher, Damien Peverill.
Umpires: Stephen McBurney, Matt Stevic, Stefan Grun.
Report:
Sam Mitchell
(Haw) was cited for making negligent contact with umpire Stefan Grun during Q2. An early plea would draw a $2400 fine. Hawthorn sought the adjudication of the Tribunal. The jury on Tuesday night found Mitchell guilty of the charge. despite the fact that umpire Grun could not recall the incident. Mitchell was fined $3200, the first offence fine.

 

West Coast notched its 9th straight win (six this year) when they overcame the determined Western Bulldogs by the close margin of 15 points on Saturday afternoon at Subiaco Oval – there was never more than three goals in it.

The match was close to cliffhanger territory with the difference at the breaks, 4pts, 3pts, 12pts and finally 15 points, Both skippers had great games with Chris Judd and Brad Johnson often opposed to each other in the course of the absorbing battle. West Coast's Matt Priddis was a surprise avenue towards goal with three majors to complement his 25 possessions, while Judd dominated the clearances with 34 touches.

Mark Duffield in his review for The Age noted: This was a game that pitted contrasting strengths. West Coast is the AFL's best contested-ball winner, the Bulldogs the worst. While the Eagles are no slouches with the way they move the ball, the Bulldogs are one of the league's most efficient ball-moving teams, running the ball from non-contest to non-contest on their way to goal. It was a case of smarts and speed versus strength and structure.

The AFL website report noted: As so often at Subiaco this year, the Eagles blasted from the blocks, with frontline pressure securing three set shots from kickable positions within seven minutes of the first bounce. However, all three resulted in behinds and Johnson was all too willing to show the Eagles the error of their way, soccering through his first to get their scoring under way.

Priddis, Quinten Lynch and Judd then kicked goals to give the Eagles the early lead, before Robert Murphy and Farren Ray pegged them back to within four points before the Eagles took a three-point lead into half time.

After a notable first half, Priddis' second started spectacularly, claiming two goals in quick succession to put their foot down. But with David Wirrpanda's miserable day continuing when Daniel Giansiracusa kicked his third, the last change margin of 12 looked good, but not quite good enough.

With extreme pressure exerted by both teams in the last quarter, space was at a premium until Jordan McMahon made his own with three bounces before kicking truly again to set up a possible shock. But with Darren Glass' outstanding season continuing, the Bulldogs could not find another goal as the Eagles held on.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 3
West Coast v Western Bulldogs
Saturday, May 5, 2007
Subiaco Oval, 4.10pm AEST, crowd: 40,668
Conditions: Good
Weather: 22C, sunshine; showers forecast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
WCE 3.5-23 (4) 6.7-43 (3) 9.12-66 (12) 10.17-77 (15)
WB 3.1-19 6.4-40 8.6-54 9.8-62
Goals: West Coast: Matt Priddis 3, Quinten Lynch 2, Mark LeCras 2, Chris Judd, Adam Hunter, Steven Armstrong. West.B'dogs: Daniel Giansiracusa 3, Brad Johnson 2, Jason Akermanis, Ryan Murphy, Farren Ray, Jordan McMahon.
Best: West Coast: Chris Judd, Matt Priddis, Darren Glass, Michael Braun, Rowan Jones, Adam Hunter, Quinten Lynch. West.B'dogs: Daniel Giansiracusa, Matthew Boyd, Daniel Harris, Brad Johnson, Daniel Cross, Scott West.
Umpires: Chris Donlon, Michael Vozzo, Dean Margett
s.

 

In the match played under a closed roof on Saturday night at Docklands the Kangaroos leapt from the blocks with a seven-goal first quarter. While Sydney made a crowd-pleasing trademark comeback the points went the way of the team that richly deserved them – the Kangas by 16 points and their third successive victory.

Jason Phelan reported for Sportal: The Swans trailed for most of the night, but when Michael O'Loughlin booted his second goal 20 minutes into the final quarter Sydney was just four points in arrears. However, the Kangaroos showed what they are made of with Matt Campbell snapping his third goal to give them breathing space and Shannon Grant sealed the match with his fourth.

Grant was the architect of the win with 22 touches and 10 marks to go with his goals that took him past 300 career goals. Daniel Wells gathered most possessions for the blue-and-white with 23. Nic Fosdike was clearly Sydney's best with 24 touches and five marks.

Martin Blake observed in The Age: For three quarters, the Swans' plight was exemplified by Barry Hall, who was well beaten by Michael Firrito, Sydney played Hall deeper than usual, giving him some space to work on his less-heralded opponent. But Firrito matched Hall for strength in marking contests, annoyed and cajoled him to the point where the man who lifted the 2005 premiership cup grew frustrated. It was a pivotal contest, for Sydney's fortunes so often rise and fall on Hall's output.

But Hall would not be denied all night. The Kangas began the final quarter with a five goal advantage and Hall barged and crashed and willed himself into the contest, kicking three goals to almost turn the game.

The Kangaroos had been marginally better prepared and a little harder all night. In a sense the Kangas out-Sydneyed the Swans with their approach, happy to play the low-possession game.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 4
Kangaroos v Sydney
Saturday (n), May 5, 2007
Docklands, 7.10pm AEST, Roof: closed; crowd: 27,045
Conditions: Good, slippery from humidity
Weather: 19C outside; fine
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
KAN 7.3-45 (34) 8.7-55 (30) 12.13-85 (30) 16.11-111 (16)
SYD 1.5-11 3.7-25 8.7-55 14.11-95
Goals: Kangaroos: Shannon Grant 4, Corey Jones 3, Matt Campbell 3, Drew Petrie 2, Aaron Edwards, Daniel Harris, Leigh Brown, Blake Grima. Sydney: Barry Hall 4, Michael O'Loughlin 2, Ben Mathews 2, Luke Ablett, Jared Crouch, Adam Schneider, Nick Malceski, Peter Everitt, Darren Jolly.
Best: Kangaroos: Shannon Grant, Daniel Wells, Adam Simpson, Corey Jones, Matt Campbell, Aaron Edwards, Daniel Harris. Sydney: Nic Fosdike, Ryan O'Keefe, Brett Kirk, Barry Hall, Adam Schneider, Luke Ablett, Darren Jolly.
Umpires: Damien Sully, Martin Ellis, Shane McInerney.

 

Collingwood were refreshed after a 10-day break since Anzac Day when they met Adelaide in fine conditions on Saturday night at Football Park. The Pies silenced a stunned crowd of almost 44,000 with a convincing 24-point win.

Ashley Porter reviewed the match for The Age: With both teams struck by injuries, it made it as much an absorbing battle of tactics between the coaches as it was a gripping contest between two ultimately very tired and sore teams, the win was well-earned.

Collingwood went into the game without Alan Didak (calf strain), who was replaced by Chris Egan. Others were slightly hurt, but continued admirably under duress, including Scott Burns (knee), Simon Prestigiacomo (strained ankle), who was off for more than a quarter, and James Clement, who appeared to strain an Achilles.

Adelaide went into the game with five key players in doubt – and it showed – including Tyson Edwards, who spent most of the third term in the rooms receiving treatment on a sore hamstring. Add those woes to the bruises from the heavy bumps and tackles, and both teams earned applause.

The Crows made one concerted surge either side of half time to reduce the Magpies' early break, but five unanswered goals to the visitors, including three to surprise pinch-hitter Chris Bryan, gave the tiring Adelaide too much to do in the final 30 minutes. Instrumental in Collingwood's success were defenders Rhyce and Heath Shaw, while Tarkyn Lockyer, Dane Swan and Ben Johnson put in committed four-quarter displays. The 228-game veteran Burns, Leon Davis and Travis Cloke were also important, as was Harry O'Brien.

Simon Goodwin in his 200th game, youngster Richard Douglas (two goals), Scott Thompson and Andrew McLeod fought gamely through their own fatigue for the Crows, while Ian Perrie (three goals) proved their sole dangerous forward.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 5
Adelaide v Collingwood
Saturday (n), May 5, 2007
Football Park, 7.40pm AEST, crowd: 43,915
Conditions: Good
Weather: 19C, fine
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
ADE 2.1-13 6.1-37 8.5-53 9.8-62
COL 3.5-23 (10) 5.8-38 (1) 10.15-75 (22) 11.20-86 (24)
Goals: Collingwood: Chris Bryan 3, Tarkyn Lockyer 2, Travis Cloke 2, Scott Pendlebury, Rhyce Shaw, Dale Thomas, Josh Fraser. Adelaide: Perrie 3, Douglas 2, Welsh, Vince, Thompson, Stevens
Best: Collingwood: Rhyce Shaw, Tarkyn Lockyer, Dale Swan, Scott Burns, Ben Johnson, Heath Shaw, Chris Bryan. Adelaide: Andrew McLeod, Scott Thompson, Simon Goodwin, Tyson Edwards, Chris Knights.
Umpires: Scott McLaren, Ray Chamberlain, Simon Meredith.

 

The Brisbane Lions continued their good start to the season with a strong performance against Fremantle on a fine and hot Sunday afternoon at the Gabba – reports had it low 30s in the middle. The Lions outlasted the Dockers who still have never won in Brisbane at seven attempts.

Andrew Stafford assessed the day for The Age: Ashley McGrath played a near-perfect small forward's game, kicking five goals for the Lions in a dynamic display, while Jonathan Brown, Chris Johnson, Justin Sherman and Luke Power all booted two.

At the other end, Matthew Pavlich and Chris Tarrant kicked three each for the visitors, but were hindered by limited supply.

Marc Fox noted for Sportal: In an exhausting contest in 33-degree heat, the home side led at every change but the Dockers will rue a profligate third-quarter display against a Lions side which temporarily lost Simon Black, McGrath and Charman through injury.

The Dockers were thrashed in the middle, where Charman and Beau McDonald battled heroically to contain the influence of Aaron Sandilands. They were assisted at ground level by Simon Black, and two younger names in Cheynee Stiller and Scott Harding. Stiller is in his second year of senior football. He was complimented with a tag, yet found the ball 23 times as he cruised around in a manner befitting a young Nigel Lappin – Lappin himself returned from a four week layoff with a solid game, compiling 26 possessions.

For the Dockers, the positives were few. One of the early premiership favourites now sits with a 2+4 win-loss record and has a small mountain to climb if it is to remain in top-four contention.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 6
Brisbane v Fremantle
Sunday, May 6, 2007
BCG (Gabba), 1.10pm AEST, crowd: 27,175
Conditions: Excellent
Weather: 29C, warm and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
BRI 5.5-35 (6) 9.10-64 (14) 12.15-87 (19) 17.18-120 (45)
FRE 4.5-29 7.8-50 9.14-68 10.15-75
Goals: Brisbane: Ashley McGrath 5.2, Jonathan Brown 2, Chris L Johnson 2, Luke Power 2, Justin Sherman 2, Colm Begley, Joel Patfull, Cheynee Stiller, Michael Rischitelli. Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich 3, Chris Tarrant 3, Robert Warnock, Des Headland, Peter Bell, Troy Cook.
Best: Brisbane: Simon Black, Luke Power, Jed Adcock, Ashley McGrath, Daniel Merrett. Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich, Heath Black, David Mundy, Chris Tarrant, Peter Bell.
Umpires: Mathew James, Matthew Nicholls, Stuart Wenn.
Reports:
l Chris Johnson (Bri) reported by umpire Stuart Wenn for an alleged headbutt on Shane Parker (Fre) during Q2. Following an MRP review the charge was withdrawn.
l Antoni Grover (Fre) reported by umpire Matthew Nicholls for attempting to trip Ashley McGrath (Bri) during Q3. The player accepted guilt and accepted the MRP penalty of a reprimand.

 

Port Adelaide finally broke the hoodoo and beat Melbourne at the MCG for the first time on Sunday afternoon in generally fine conditions, though the gloom descending late in the day – around about the time two controversial free kicks were handed to Port and denied the Demons their first win of the season.

Paul Gough explained in his report for Sportal: After Daniel Motlop had kicked a banana goal on the run to put Port in front at the 25-minute mark of the final term, the Demons immediately went forward where Aaron Davey goaled and appeared to have put his side back in front with two minutes remaining.

However the goal was disallowed for a pushing infringement against Melbourne skipper David Neitz on Port full-back Darryl Wakelin. While that decision appeared technical but correct, Melbourne fans were rightly furious when their last opportunity to win the game was taken from them by a dreadful deliberate out of bounds free kick against James McDonald with about 50 seconds remaining.

The ball was on the Demons half-back flank, but there was still time for Melbourne to get the ball forward and kick the goal they needed to win the game, when McDonald was penalised for handballing over the line deliberately.

On Monday, AFL umpires' boss Jeff Gieschen conceded the free kick against McDonald was incorrect.

Gough concludes defeat was harsh on the Demons, who produced their best performance of a disappointing season so far, but they also had themselves to blame as they threw away victory through poor kicking for goal.

While respective skippers Neitz and Warren Tredrea were both returning from injury, they each kicked two goals, but neither had much impact on a day when both teams did their best to lose as luck deserted Melbourne in the dying minutes.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 7
Melbourne v Port Adelaide
Sunday, May 6, 2007
MCG, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 16,266
Conditions: Good
Weather: 19C, generally fine; lights on in Q4
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
MEL 2.1-13 6.6-42 8.12-60 9.17-71
PA 3.4-22 (9) 7.7-49 (7) 9.11-65 (5) 10.16-76 (5)
Goals: Melbourne: David Neitz 2, Matthew Bate 2, Nathan Jones 2, Adem Yze,  Nathan D Brown, Matthew Warnock. Port: Danyle Pearce 3, Warren Tredrea 2, Daniel Motlop 2, Shaun Burgoyne, Krakouer, Ebert
Best: Melbourne: Nathan D Brown, Adem Yze, Nathan Jones, Simon Godfrey, Matthew Bate, Ricky Petterd, Nathan Carroll. Port: Chad Cornes, Kane Cornes, Danyle Pearce, Daniel Motlop, Nathan Lonie, Peter Burgoyne.
Umpires: Luke Farmer, Craig Hendrie, Shaun Ryan.
Reports:
l Colin Sylvia (Mel) accepted a reprimand and 93.75 demerit points from the MRP for bumping or making forceful contact from front-on towards Kane Cornes (Ade) in Q1.
l Aaron Davey (Mel) accepted a reprimand and 93.75 demerit points from the MRP for charging Matt Thomas (PA) in Q3.
l Travis Johnstone (Mel) accepted a $900 fine imposed by the MRP for abusive language at the end of the match toward umpire Craig Hendrie.

 

On Sunday night at Docklands, Geelong gave Richmond its biggest defeat of 1,989 League matches. A crowd of 34,584 witnessed the 157-point mauling as the Cats enjoyed a remarkable blitz of sustained scoring – 10.2 in Q1, 10.4 in Q2, 9.3 in Q3 and 6.3 in the final term.

Jason Phelan reported for Sportal: Geelong had winners all over the park, Gary Ablett leading the way with 32 touches, while Richmond's Nathan Foley (28 disposals) at least tried hard for his side.

Paul Chapman was everywhere with nine touches and three goals in the first quarter with Gary Ablett not far behind. Chapman went off with back soreness and only came on again briefly in the second when he added a fourth despite his discomfort.

The Tigers were 43 points behind before Matthew White booted their first goal, but the Geelong machine continued undeterred and led by 55 points at the first break. Richmond went into the ultra flood in the second quarter in a feeble effort to stop the bleeding, but it made little difference as Geelong piled on another 10 goals and restricted the Tigers to one when the Cats led by 107 points.

Geelong kept piling on the goals until three-quarter time when their score was 29.9-183, the highest score at that time of any previous VFL-AFL match. The Cats had 15 individual goalkickers, of which Chapman, Nathan Ablett, Tom Hawkins and Andrew Mackie all booted four, while Travis Varcoe, Gary Ablett and Cameron Ling all booted three.

The Cats showed some sign of mercy taking the foot off the pedal allowing Richmond in the last quarter to play their best football of the day.
2007 — ROUND 6 — GAME 8
Richmond v Geelong
Sunday (n), May 6, 2007
Docklands, 5.10pm AEST, Roof: closed, crowd: 34,584
Conditions: Good; 22C inside
Weather: 14C, showers forecast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
RCH 1.1-7 2.7-19 5.9-39 9.11-65
GEE 10.2-62 (55) 20.6-126 (107) 29.9-183 (144) 35.12-222 (157)
Goals: Geelong: Nathan Ablett 4, Paul Chapman 4, Andrew Mackie 4, Tom Hawkins 4, Cameron Ling 3, Travis Varcoe 3, Gary Ablett 3, Steve Johnson 2, Cameron Mooney 2, Jimmy Bartel, David Johnson, Corey Enright, Brad Ottens, Joel Selwood, Kane Tenace. Richmond: Cleve Hughes 3, Matthew Richardson 2, Shane Tuck 2, Matt White, Kayne Pettifer.
Best: Geelong: Gary Ablett, Darren Milburn, Andrew Mackie, Jimmy Bartel, Joel Corey, Nathan Ablett, Cameron Ling, Steve Johnson, Brad Ottens, Joel Selwood. Richmond: Nathan Foley, Andrew Raines, Shane Tuck, Cleve Hughes.

Umpires: Hayden Kennedy, Michael Avon, Kieron Nicholls.
Report:
Kayne Pettifer
(Rch) and Andrew Mackie (Gee) cited for wrestling in Q2. Both players accepted fines imposed by the MRP – Pettifer $1800 and Mackie $900.

 

 


 
2007 Ladder after Round 6
W L D F A % Total
1 WEST COAST 6 538 395 136.20 24
2 PORT ADELAIDE 5 1 562 476 118.07 20
3 BRISBANE 4 2 559 476 117.44 16
4 COLLINGWOOD 4 2 519 481 107.90 16
5 HAWTHORN 4 2 551 511 107.83 16
6 GEELONG 3 3 760 513 148.15 12
7 SYDNEY 3 3 505 447 112.98 12
8 ADELAIDE 3 3 451 428 105.37 12
9 Essendon 3 3 623 605 102.98 12
10 Kangaroos 3 3 369 555 102.52 12
11 St Kilda 3 3 495 507 97.63 12
12 West.B'dogs 3 3 555 589 94.23 12
13 Fremantle 2 4 557 613 90.86 8
14 Carlton 2 4 569 743 76.58 8
15 Melbourne 6 436 640 68.13 0
16 Richmond 6 501 771 64.98 0


 

FOR THE RECORD

COL HUTCHINSON's
Approaching Milestones
2007, Round 6, Fri-Sat-Sun, May 4-5-6
(subject to selection, injury or suspension)
CAREER MATCHES
200 – SIMON GOODWIN (Adelaide) 1997-2008
ü
150 – NICK DAVIS, 78 Syd 2003-07; 71 Col 1999-2002
ü
100 – RYAN HARGRAVE (West.B'dogs) 2002-07
ü
CONSECUTIVE MATCHES
   50 – KAYNE PETTIFER (Richmond) since 2005-R1
ü
   50 – SHANE TUCK (Richmond) since 2005-R1
ü
   50 – DARREN JOLLY (Sydney) since 2005-R8
ü
COACHES, CURRENT CLUB
  50 – ALASTAIR CLARKSON (Hawthorn) since 2005-R1
ü
  50 – TERRY WALLACE (Richmond) since 2005-R1; also 148 WB 1996-2002
ü
GOALKICKING
300 – SHANNON GRANT (Syd 1995-97, Kan '98-2007) = 297 gls, 260 gms
ü

<>

 

<>

2007, Round 6
ST KILDA 18.17-125 (Gehrig 6.3, Milne 3) best, Dal Santo, Gehrig, Harvey, CARLTON 11.16-82 (Fevola 6.2, Whitnall 3) best, Fevola, Scotland, Walker.
Friday night at Docklands: 45,513.

Reports:
Steven Baker (StK) cited with striking Marc Murphy (Car) during Q1. An early plea would draw a one-match suspension.
Steven Baker (StK) cited with rough conduct against Jordan Russell (Car) during Q4. An early plea would draw a one-match suspension.
St Kilda sought the adjudication of the Tribunal on both charges. On Tuesday the Tribunal found Baker guilty on both charges. He was however spared a third week of suspension by the ruling of Tribunal chairman David Jones. Instead of combining the points from both guilty verdicts, which would have given Baker a three-match suspension, the St Kilda was allowed to carry forward 155 demerit points towards his next appearance at the Tribunal, or effectively taking a one match suspended sentence.

HAWTHORN 20.11-131 (Franklin 9.2, Boyle 3, Dixon 3) best, Franklin, Sewell, Crawford, ESSENDON 15.6-96 (J.Johnson 2, Welsh 2, Stanton 2, Johns 2) best, J.Johnson, McVeigh, Stanton.
Saturday at MCG: 52,047.
Report:
Sam Mitchell
(Haw) was cited for making negligent contact with umpire Stefan Grun during Q2. An early plea would draw a $2400 fine. Hawthorn sought the adjudication of the Tribunal. The jury on Tuesday night found Mitchell guilty of the charge. despite the fact that umpire Grun could not recall the incident. Mitchell was fined $3200, the first offence fine.

WEST COAST 10.17-77 (Priddis 3, Lynch 2, LeCras 2) best, Judd, Priddis, Glass, WEST.B'DOGS 9.8-62 (Giansiracusa 3, Johnson 2) best, Giansiracusa, Boyd, Harris.
Saturday at Subiaco Oval: 40,668.

KANGAROOS 16.15-111 (Grant 4, Jones 3, Campbell 3) best, Grant, Wells, Simpson, SYDNEY 14.11-95 (Hall 4, O'Loughlin 2, Mathews 2) best, Fosdike, O'Keefe, Kirk.
Saturday night at Docklands: 27,045.

COLLINGWOOD 11.20-86 (Bryan 3, Lockyer 2, Cloke 2) best, R.Shaw, Lockyer, Swan, ADELAIDE 9.8-62 (Perrie 3, Douglas 2) best, McLeod, Thompson, Goodwin.
Saturday night at Football Park: 43,915.

BRISBANE 17.18-120 (McGrath 5.2) best, Black, Power, Adcock, FREMANTLE 10.15-75 (Pavlich 3, Tarrant 3) best, Pavlich, Black, Mundy.
Sunday at BCG: 27,925.

Reports:
l Chris Johnson (Bri) reported by umpire Stuart Wenn for an alleged headbutt on Shane Parker (Fre) during Q2. Following an MRP review the charge was withdrawn.
l Antoni Grover (Fre) reported by umpire Matthew Nicholls for attempting to trip Ashley McGrath (Bri) during Q3. The player accepted guilt and accepted the MRP penalty of a reprimand.

PORT ADELAIDE 10.16-76 (Pearce 3, Tredrea 2, Motlop 2) best, C.Cornes, K.Cornes, Pearce, MELBOURNE 9.17-71 (Neitz 2, Bate 2, Jones 2) best, Brown, Yze, Jones.
Sunday at MCG: 16,266.
Reports:
l Colin Sylvia (Mel) accepted a reprimand and 93.75 demerit points from the MRP for bumping or making forceful contact from front-on towards Kane Cornes (Ade) in Q1.
l Aaron Davey (Mel) accepted a reprimand and 93.75 demerit points from the MRP for charging Matt Thomas (PA) in Q3.
l Travis Johnstone (Mel) accepted a $900 fine imposed by the MRP for abusive language at the end of the match toward umpire Craig Hendrie.

GEELONG 35.12-222 (N.Ablett 4, Chapman 4, Mackie 4, Hawkins 4, Ling 3, Varcoe 3, G.Ablett 3) best, G.Ablett, Milburn, Mackie, RICHMOND 9.11-65 (Hughes 3, Richardson 2, Tuck 2) best, Foley, Raines, Tuck.
Sunday night at Docklands: 34,584.
Report:
Kayne Pettifer
(Rch) and Andrew Mackie (Gee) cited for wrestling in Q2. Both players accepted fines imposed by the MRP – Pettifer $1800 and Mackie $900.


uuuu

<>

 

*

Consecutive Matches
2007, Round 6

174 – Adam GOODES (Syd) from 1999-R22 – 2+22+23+22+24+24+26+25+6
128 Matthew PAVLICH (Fre) from 2001-R15 – 8+22+23+22+22+25+6
111 Brett KIRK (Syd) from 2002-R15 – 8+