Footystats Diary, footy's best kept secret, Match Review, 2006-R04


Masthead1.gif (6053 bytes)
Footy's best kept secret ...

2006, Match Review — Round 4


Ladder after Round 4
Stats Update of every round, 2006



2006, ROUND 4,
Fri-Sat-Sun-Mon-Tue, April 21-22-23-24-25

318,510 attend Anzac round of matches
Hawks' best start for five years; 3 out of 4
Bulldogs pip the Cats in 290th one-pointer
Richmond show sharper claws than Lions
Tired Crow outfit outlast the Dockers
Better last half lifts Eagles to down Kangas
Demons get their first win; Swans lose again
Port narrowly beat Saints in epic struggle
Exciting stuff as Pies beat Bombers by 17 points

THE STATS THAT MATTER ...
l Anzac observance ceremonies for fallen comrades preceded all matches of Round 4.

l 318,510 attended Round 4, taking 2006 premiership crowds to 1,121,697.

l Richmond, Adelaide, West Coast and Melbourne – four of the travelling sides won at interstate venues; the fifth away side St Kilda lost by four points.

l Undefeated on four wins, the Western Bulldogs and West Coast maintain their leadership ranking – they do not meet until Round 13 at Subiaco.

uuuu

MILESTONES OF ROUND 4 —
l
300th DAVID NEITZ (Melbourne), 269 premiership games, 26 pre-season, 2 State, 3 International ... 250th SAVERIO ROCCA, 94 Kan 2001-06, 156 Col 1992-2000 ... 100th DARREN GLASS (West Coast) 2000-06 ... 100th BRENT GUERRA, 4 Haw 2006, 31 StK 2004-05, 65 PA 2000-03 ... 100th RYAN LONIE (Collingwood) 2001-06 ... 50th DANIEL CROSS (West.B'dogs) 2002-06 ... 50th DYLAN McLAREN, 4 Car 2006, 46 Bri 2001-05 ... 50th BRENT STAKER (West Coast) 2003-06 ... BRAD JOHNSON (Western Bulldogs) wore the No.6 guernsey for the 249th time passing the record of JOHN DUGDALE (North Melb) 1955-1970 ... Brisbane's MICHAEL VOSS (Brisbane) played at the BCG (Gabba) for the 137th time passing the record of former teammate MARCUS ASHCROFT ...

Highest Score:

19.8-122, PORT ADEL v St Kilda
Biggest Margin: 32pts, HAWTHORN v Carlton
Best in Goals: 6.0, Josh MAHONEY (PA) v StK
Lowest Score: 9.5-59, FREMANTLE v Adelaide
Best Quarters: 1st 6.2-38 PA v StK
2nd 6.3-39 PA v StK
3rd 6.4-40 STK v PA
4th 6.6-42 BRI v Rch

Official AFL attendances for 2006, Round 4 —

45,102 Carlton v Hawthorn (Docklands)
45,922 West.B'dogs v Geelong (Docklands)
30,266 Brisbane v Richmond (BCG)
35,090 Fremantle v Adelaide (Subiaco)
9,541 Kangaroos v West Coast (Manuka)
29,167 Sydney v Melbourne (SCG)
32,188 Port Adelaide v St Kilda (Football Park)
91,234 Collingwood v Essendon (MCG)
318,510 Total for Round 4 — (2005: 295,363)
1,121,717 Progressive at R4 — (2005: 1,212,688)

FROM THE ROUND

CARLTON v HAWTHORN
l
the Hawks achieved its 50th victory over Carlton from the 152 contests played since 1925 ... Hawthorn with three wins from the first four matches are enjoying their best opening to a season since 2001 when the club won their first eight games ... no other new match records were noted ... 100th BRENT GUERRA, 4 Haw 2006, 31 StK 2004-05, 65 PA 2000-03 ... 50th DYLAN McLAREN, 4 Car 2006, 46 Bri 2001-05 ...

WEST.B'DOGS v GEELONG
l margins were tight at every change – 3, 4, 1 and 1 ranking this as another to the list of *Cliffhangers* (also see Bruce Kennedy below) ... the result was the 290th One-Pointer in VFL-AFL history and the fifth between the pair –

2006-R4-Dok West.B'dogs 14.14-98 v Geelong 14.13-97
1998-R19-PP West.B'dogs 13.18-96 v Geelong 14.13-97
1957-R12-WO Footscray 9.11-65 v Geelong 9.10-64
1932-R10-WO Footscray 7.15-57 v Geelong 8.8-56
1928-R10-WO Footscray 8.9-57 v Geelong 8.8-56

... Rod Nicholson observed in the Sunday Herald Sun, the lead changed 11 times, scores were level three times and the biggest margin was 13 points at the 25-minute mark of the final term ... 45,922 at Docklands was the biggest home-and-away crowd to see the Dogs and Cats play since 42,015 at the Western Oval on Saturday August 26, 1961 ... Paul Gough noted for Sportal: It is only the fourth time the Bulldogs have won the opening four games – the others being 1946 (when they won the first nine), 1961 and 1998 ... 50th DANIEL CROSS (West.B'dogs) 2002-06 ... Bulldog BRAD JOHNSON wore the No.6 guernsey for the 249th time passing the record of JOHN DUGDALE (North Melb) 1955-1970 ...

BRISBANE v RICHMOND
l the Tigers won their second successive game at the Gabba and overall have won five times in 13 visits ... no other new match records were noted in the 30th contest between the pair ... Brisbane's MICHAEL VOSS (Brisbane) played at the BCG (Gabba) for the 137th time passing the record of former teammate MARCUS ASHCROFT ...

FREMANTLE v ADELAIDE
l DIGBY BEACHAM noted in the The Sunday Times, Adelaide were playing their fourth match in 19 days and had travelled 11,500km in that period – R1 Ade-Melb v Collingwood at Docklands, R2 home to West Coast, R3 Ade-Gold Coast v Melbourne at Carrara, R4 Ade-Perth v Fremantle at Subi ... the Crows have beaten the Dockers six times from eight visits to Subiaco ... the match aggregate of 129 points in the smallest of 17 meetings between the pair at Footy Park and Subiaco since 137 points in 2004-R3 at Subi ... no other new match records were noted ...

KANGAROOS v WEST COAST
l the Eagles won their second game from three visits to Manuka – West Coast's other win in Canberra was at Bruce Stadium in 1995 when they beat Fitzroy ... no other new match records were noted ... 250th SAVERIO ROCCA, 94 Kan 2001-06, 156 Col 1992-2000 ... 100th DARREN GLASS (West Coast) 2000-06 ... 50th BRENT STAKER (West Coast) 2003-06 ...

SYDNEY v MELBOURNE
l the Demons won successive matches at the SCG for the first time since 1991-92 ... the 193rd meeting is a new *Cliffhanger* by our definition – margins in the quarters, 5-5-2-5 ... no other new match records were noted ... RUSSELL ROBERTSON reached 300 goals for the Demons in game 171 ... 300th DAVID NEITZ (Melbourne), 269 premiership games, 26 pre-season, 2 State, 3 International – he qualifies for AFL life membership ...

PORT ADELAIDE v ST KILDA
l Port defeated the Saints for the ninth successive time – the pair have met 14 times – St Kilda won the first five ... the match aggregate of 240 points nudges out the 239 of 2001-R19 at Docklands when Port won 19.11-125 to 16.18-114 ... the six-goals by JOSH MAHONEY is the biggest bag by a Port player against St Kilda – previous best was four goals by six players ... 6.4-40 is a new Q3 high for the Saints versus Port ... no other new match records were noted ...

COLLINGWOOD v ESSENDON
l in the 213th League meeting between the two since 1897 it was the 46th played at the MCG including 13 occasions on Anzac Day April 25 ... the fifth-highest MCG crowd for a home-and-away match attended –

99,346 1958-R10 Mel 12.12-84 v Col 10.13-73
94,825 1995-R4 Col 17.9-111, Ess 16.15-111
92,436 1977-R4 Rch 14.16-100 v Col 17.24-126
91,571 2000-R20(n) Car 12.11-83 v Ess 16.13-109
91,234 2006-R4 Col 15.16-106 v Ess 12.17-89

... 100th RYAN LONIE (Collingwood) 2001-06 ...

uuuu

Statistics for Footystats are enhanced by software from
Eric Sorensen's *Footy Works* and
Steve Norval's 2006 update of *Ruckman*

uuuu

The Stats that Matter
Cliffhangers; lowest maximum margin

l Bruce Kennedy notes that a check of records to hand show that weekend results produced for the first time two matches in one round with all margins at each quarter of five points or less – *Cliffhangers* ...

l Martin Windsor-Black observed the 32-point win by Hawthorn over Carlton is the "lowest maximum margin in a round" since Melbourne beat the Bulldogs by 26 points in Round 2 last year – which then was the lowest since Round 11, 1983 when Carlton beat Essendon by 25 points at Waverley in 1983.

l Eric Sorensen of *FootyWorks* fame noted that the 290th One-Pointer remains the most-repeated margin, with *five* points pressing hard with 282 results by that margin.

1pt–290, 2pts–280, 3pts–251, 4pts–243, 5pts–282, 6pts–279, 7pts–244, 8pts–244, 9pts–269.

Eric also reports that the score of 79 points has been kicked 363 times in the 12,869 League matches since 1897, with 83 points next on the list at 354 times.

uuuu

'Cliffhangers' – the tight ones ...

Statsman Bruce Kennedy noted the aggregate margins at the end of each quarter of the Bulldogs-Geelong match on Saturday at Docklands as just nine points – 3,4,1,1 = 9.

Bruce, using "4/9" as the benchmark drilled down in the records and came across six matches which were "tighter" –

    Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Tot
1956-R15-GO Hawthorn v South Melb 0 3 2 0 5
1927-R1-PP Carlton v South Melb 1 2 2 1 6
1924-R12-CO Geelong v Fitzroy 0 1 3 3 7
1929-R10-MCG Melbourne v Richmond 2 1 2 3 8
1914-R4-AP South Melb v Carlton 4 3 1 0 8
1902-R11-MCG Melbourne v Carlton 2 0 3 3 8

Recent matches which have a smaller aggregates are:

    Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Tot
2000-R4-(n)-SCG Sydney v Coll'wood 1 0 0 5 6
2003-R17(n)-BCG Brisbane v Port Adel 1 1 5 1 8

Recent matches which are equal with the WB-Gee game –

    Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Tot
1989-R19-P North Melb v Coll'wood 2 4 1 2 9
1992-R15-C Brisbane v Hawthorn 1 1 3 4 9
1996-R5-PP Carlton v West Coast 2 4 2 1 9
1998-R4-PP Carlton v Melbourne 4 2 1 2 9

Thank you to Bruce Kennedy.

uuuu



*

 


A 32 point win over Carlton on Friday night at Docklands gave Hawthorn their third win out of the first four matches and the best start to a season since 2001. TRENT CROAD with a polished performance gave one of his best matches for the Hawks with three first quarter goals and helped set up the victory.

Croad gave Lance Whitnall the run around in the first quarter but the big Blue fought back to be one of his side's best when shifted to half forward – despite a nasty cut to the head in the third term – and finished with three goals. While he was quieter after quarter-time, Croad finished the game with 22 possessions and 15 marks and was well supported by Shane Crawford with 33 touches.

Michael Stevens noted for the Herald Sun: Admittedly the win was over an undermanned Carlton but the Hawks were able to withstand everything the Blues threw at them and finished the game full of running. Without key forward marking options Brendan Fevola (suspended) and Jarrad Waite (quad strain), Carlton had to improvise to score goals and the end result of 9.14 was never going to be enough.

For the first three quarters, Carlton chased, harassed, flooded at every opportunity, and generally played above themselves to keep the game alive as a contest. Ostensibly their sole forward option was Whitnall, who found himself in attack after Croad had proved too slick and athletic.

After dominating the centre clearance so convincingly the previous week against Geelong, the Hawks edged clear, 13-11, against the Blues. Ruckmen Robert Campbell and Peter Everitt had 28 hit-outs between them to overwhelm Barnaby French (20), but French's work at the centre bounces was equally as effective as Everitt's. The contrast was the effectiveness of midfielders Luke Hodge, Crawford and Sam Mitchell, who were much more instrumental in producing scoring chances out of the middle.

Carlton refused to concede, but their challenge was ended in the final term when Mark Williams, Mitchell and Michael Osborne all booted their second goals, and continuing the Hawks' encouraging start to the season.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 1
Carlton v Hawthorn
Friday (n), April 21, 2006
Docklands, 7.40pm AEST, Roof closed, crowd: 45,102
Conditions: Generally good
Weather: 9C outside, 17C under the roof
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
CAR 2.4-16 4.6-30 6.13-49 9.14-68
HAW 5.2-32 (16) 6.4-40 (10) 10.6-66 (17) 15.10-100 (32)
Goals: Hawthorn: Trent Croad 5.3, Mark Williams 2, Sam Mitchell 2, Michael Osborne 2, Chance Bateman, Rick Ladson, Peter Everitt, Tim Clarke. Carlton: Lance Whitnall 3, Anthony Koutoufides 2, Nick Stevens 2, Brad Fisher, Eddie Betts.
Best: Hawthorn: Shane Crawford, Tim Clarke, Trent Croad, Luke Hodge, Campbell Brown, Brad Sewell. Carlton: Lance Whitnall, Heath Scotland, Nick Stevens, Andrew Walker, Ryan Houlihan, Bret Thornton.
Umpires: Darren Goldspink, Ray Chamberlain, Simon Meredith.
Report:
Trent Croad
(Haw) was cited for striking Jordan Russell (Car) during the second quarter. The assessment was reckless conduct, low impact, in play and high contact – equating to 125 points and a one-match ban. Croad escaped with an early plea of guilty, resulting in a reprimand and 93.75 points towards his future record.

 

In one of the most exciting contests of recent times the Western Bulldogs defeated Geelong by one point in a thrilling struggle on Saturday afternoon at Docklands where 45,922 fans were on hand – the biggest crowd for a Bulldogs-Cats home-and-away match. The lead changed 11 times, scores were level three times and the biggest margin throughout the day was 13 points at the 25-minute mark of the final term. The win retains top position on the ladder for the Bulldogs who have enjoyed their best start to a year since 1998.

Jon Ralph noted in the Sunday Herald Sun: The Cats had more kicks, handballs, marks, clearances, centre breaks and inside 50s which prompted Bulldog coach Rodney Eade to declare statistics were "the most overrated thing in football." Both sides played attacking, gripping, one-on-one football yet the Dogs found the class to prevail.

Rod Nicholson also for the Sunday Herald Sun wrote: The margins at the intervals were Geelong by three points, and then the Bulldogs by four points, one point and one point – you could not have asked for a more desperate and close contest. Even then the drama did not stop. Geelong refused to surrender. Goals to Corey Enright and Gary Ablett reduced the deficit to a point with only 98 seconds remaining.

And if heroics were needed in the crisis, the stout defence of Brian Harris with a mark and then a defensive punch out saved the day. Both clubs put on a magnificent display of courageous, tenacious football that sapped all their energies, but showed the character that suggests they will be around in September.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 2
Western Bulldogs v Geelong
Saturday, April 22, 2006
Docklands, 2.10pm AEST, Roof open, crowd: 45,922
Conditions: Generally good
Weather: 15C, cloudy; rain for five minutes in Q4
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
WB 3.5-23 8.9-57 (4) 10.11-71 (1) 14.14-98 (1)
GEE 4.2-26 (3) 8.5-53 10.10-70 14.13-97
Goals: West.B'dogs: Robert Murphy 3, Mitch Hahn 2, Brad Johnson 2, Adam Cooney 2, Nathan Eagleton 2, Rohan Smith, Daniel Giansiracusa, Matthew Robbins. Geelong: Gary Ablett 4, Cameron Mooney 2, Paul Chapman 2, Corey Enright 2, Brad Ottens, David Johnson, James Kelly, Jared Rooke.
Best: West.B'dogs: Brian Harris, Scott West, Jordan McMahon, Robert Murphy, Mitch Hahn, Lindsay Gilbee, Daniel Cross. Geelong: Jared Rooke, Gary Ablett, Cameron Ling, James Kelly, Brad Ottens, Paul Chapman, Jimmy Bartel.
Umpires: Stephen McBurney, Scott Jeffery, Michael Vozzo.

 

Richmond gained its first points of the season after it produced a stunning third quarter then held off the Brisbane Lions to win by 14 points on a balmy Saturday night at the Gabba.

In a game in which goals were at a premium the Tigers tore the contest open in the third quarter with six majors to the Lions' one. As Brisbane struggled to piece together an effective passage of play, Richmond took a 31-point advantage into three-quarter-time. It prompted Leigh Matthews to pour a verbal mouthful on his players at the last break. He verballed and physically pushed his players in an effort to inspire them.

Although the Lions bounced back strongly early in the final term – they opened the quarter with four in succession and reduced the deficit to eight points – when the inspirational Matthew Richardson answered with two in a row and Greg Stafford kicked truly, the Tigers were home. It was fitting that Richardson (four goals) and Stafford (three) help seal the match, as along with Troy Simmonds (23 disposals and 10 marks), Richmond's tall timber shone.

Also pivotal in the victory were midfielders Mark Coughlan, Shane Tuck and Greg Tivendale, while the Joel Bowden duel with Brisbane's Jonathan Brown was enthralling. Brown battled hard all night to be among the Lions' best – he was outstanding in the first term – while Luke Power was his side's most prominent ball-winner with 27 touches.

Sportal concluded their commentary on the match – Inaccuracy in front of goal marred both side in the first half and this was emphasised early in the second term, when 12 behinds and just two goals had been registered. But the contest was tight and this was also reflected on the scoreboard, when the Lions led by just two points, and the narrowest of margins at quarter and half-time respectively.

Yet when the Tigers upped the ante in the second half, the Tigers avoided losing their opening four rounds for the first time since 1991.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 3
Brisbane Lions v Richmond
Saturday (n), April 22, 2006
BCG (Gabba), 7.10pm AEST, crowd: 30,266
Conditions: Good
Weather: 20C, fine
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
BRI 1.6-12 (2) 4.9-33 (1) 5.10-40 11.16-82
RCH 1.4-10 4.8-32 10.11-71 (31) 14.12-96 (14)
Goals: Richmond: Matthew Richardson 4, Greg Stafford 3, Patrick Bowden, Daniel Jackson, Kane Johnson, Kayne Pettifer, Troy Simmonds, Richard Tambling, Shane Tuck. Brisbane: Daniel Bradshaw 2, Jonathan Brown 2, Luke Power 2, Jayden Attard, Rhan Hooper, Daniel Merrett, Matthew Moody, Justin Sherman.
Best: Richmond: Matthew Richardson, Troy Simmonds, Mark Coughlan, Shane Tuck, Greg Stafford, Greg Tivendale, Joel Bowden. Brisbane: Luke Power, Jonathan Brown, Jamie Charman, Justin Sherman.
Umpires: Chris Donlon, Brett Rosebury, Stuart Wenn.

 

Adelaide survived a tough travel schedule of 11,000km to record an 11 point victory over Fremantle on Saturday night at Subiaco Oval – it was their fourth match in 19 days. Led by brilliant small defender GRAHAM JOHNCOCK, the Crows took control in the first half and held on grimly as the Dockers launched a spirited second-half revival.

Digby Beacham
for The Sunday Times noted: Fremantle, which played dumb football in the opening two terms and paid the ultimate price, despite a resurgence in the third quarter which clawed it to within 12 points after goals to Graham Polak, Matthew Pavlich and Jeff Farmer and again in the last quarter when it was just nine points adrift.

The Dockers took wrong turns, executed badly under pressure, coughed up possession, ignored leading key forwards (notably Pavlich) far too often, refused to kick to a contest and chipped the footy around in a manner that had traits of the Round 1 debacle in Launceston.

Adelaide as it did just before three-quarter time against Collingwood in the opening weekend, tried to take the sting out of the game deep in the third quarter as the home team surged. The ploy was jeered by the Dockers' faithful, but it worked a teat, with the Crows starving the Dockers of possession before Brett Burton converted from outside 50m to extend his side's advantage to 19 points.

In the context of the game – an arm wrestle where goals were at a premium – it was a significant edge and while the Crows were slowing down by the final change, they had a 20-point buffer. It would have been considerably more but for poor kicking at goal – a complete contrast to their disposal in general play.

Johncock's poise out of defence, even when the pressure rose considerably in the last two terms, was telling, while fellow backmen Ben Rutten, Kris Massie and Ben Hart were important – as were Brent Reilly, midfielders Scott Thompson and Burton, tagger Robert Shirley and forwards Mark Ricciuto and Ian Perrie until he left the ground with a knee injury in the last quarter.

Fremantle's better performers were harder to pinpoint, although the commitment of Byron Schammer, Aaron Sandilands, Antoni Grover, Polak, Shaun McManus and Peter Bell couldn't be questioned.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 4
Fremantle v Adelaide
Saturday (n), April 22, 2006
Subiaco Oval, 7.40pm AEST, crowd: 35,090
Conditions: Good
Weather: 19C, fine
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
FRE 1.1-7 3.3-21 6.3-39 9.5-59
ADE 3.3-21 (14) 7.7-49 (28) 8.11-59 (20) 9.16-70 (11)
Goals: Adelaide: Rhett Biglands 2, Matthew Bode 2, Brett Burton 2, Brent Reilly, Mark Ricciuto, Simon Goodwin. Fremantle: Jeff Farmer 3, Graham Polak 3, Matthew Pavlich 2, Matthew Carr.
Best: Adelaide: Graham Johncock, Kris Massie, Brent Reilly, Ken McGregor, Scott Thompson, Rhett Biglands, Mark Ricciuto. Fremantle: Shaun McManus, Byron Schammer, Jeff Farmer, Graham Polak, Peter Bell, Heath Black, Matthew Pavlich.
Umpires:  - Shane McInerney, Dean Margetts, Kieron Nicholls.
Report: Brett Burton (Ade) for striking Steven Dodd (Fre) during the third quarter.
Reports:
l Matthew Carr (Fre) was cited for making negligent contact with umpire Kieron Nicholls during the third quarter. Faced with a $3200 fine for a first such offence, an early plea of guilty would gain a 25 per cent reduction to a $2400 fine. Carr chose to take his charge to the tribunal. The tribunal found Carr not guilty of the offence.
l Brett Burton (Ade) was charged with a Level Three offence for striking Steven Dodd (Fre) during the third quarter – assessed as intentional contact, low impact. in play and high contact. Following discovery of a prior offence from Round 13 last season carrying over 70.31 points, Burton was offered an early plea of guilty and 25 percent reduction to 221.48 points and a two-match suspension. Burton however chose to contest the classification of 'intentional' to 'reckless'. The tribunal found that Burton's conduct was intentional and suspended him for two matches.

 

On the back of successive defeats the Kangaroos played strongly and stayed with West Coast well into the last quarter in fine and sunny conditions on Sunday afternoon at Manuka Oval in Canberra. Ironically, a dysfunctional Eagles forward structure forced changes when starting defenders DAVID WIRRPANDA and ADAM HUNTER were switched to attack early in the second quarter which proved match-winning moves. West Coast gained control only in the final 15 minutes and its four-goal win joins them with the Bulldogs as the only two unbeaten sides after four rounds.

Greg Denham in The Australian noted: The Kangaroos came out fighting and led at the first two breaks, but squandered opportunities and should have been further in front. Coach Dean Laidley's negative tactics paid early dividends as he managed to close down key Eagles playmakers Daniel Kerr, Chad Fletcher and Andrew Embley.

Jason Phelan
reported for Sportal: The Eagles trailed the switched-on Roos, but clawed their way in front late in the third quarter and didn't look back. Chris Judd started slowly but finished with 21 quality disposals and a goal, while Hunter was the most dangerous forward on the ground with four goals.

Though the Kangas disappointingly dropped off in the closing stages, Leigh Brown and Brent Harvey were solid contributors all day while Corey Jones had a respectable afternoon.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 5
Kangaroos v West Coast
Sunday, April 23, 2006
Manuka Oval, 1.10pm AEST, crowd: 9,541
Conditions: Very good
Weather: 17C, fine and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
KAN 4.5-29 (10) 7.6-48 (7) 8.10-58 10.11-71
WCE 3.1-19 6.5-41 10.6-66 (8) 14.11-95 (24)
Goals: West Coast: Adam Hunter 4, David Wirrpanda 3, Brent Staker, Adam Selwood, Rowan Jones, Daniel Chick, Chris Judd, Andrew Embley, Dean Cox. Kangaroos: Leigh Harding 3, Corey Jones 2, Michael Firrito, Brent Harvey, Daniel Harris, Kasey Green, Saverio Rocca.
Best: West Coast: Chris Judd, Dean Cox, Adam Hunter, Michael Braun, David Wirrpanda, Adam Selwood, Andrew Embley. Kangaroos: Leigh Brown, Brent Harvey, Corey Jones, Michael Firrito, Jess Sinclair, Brady Rawlings.
Umpires: Hayden Kennedy, Justin Schmitt, Chris Kamolins.

 

Melbourne scored their first win of the season with a gutsy five-point victory over the struggling premiers Sydney on on a fine Sunday afternoon at the SCG. The Demons had to overcome a late Swans charge and a contentious umpiring decision but prevailed to win a heart-stopper from a goal by CAMERON BRUCE with 39 seconds left on the clock.

Jenny McAsey summed up for The Australian: A quick look at the scoreboard might suggest this was a thrilling game, in truth it was a tight slog between two struggling teams trying desperately not to lose, with all of the drama squeezed into a chaotic last term. Without key forward David Neitz who hobbled from the ground in the third quarter with a hip injury, they also got a freak tumbling goal from Adem Yze, a 55m bomb from tireless ruckman Jeff White, zip from Byron Pickett and speedster Aaron Davey and the finishing skills of Bruce, who broke a 91-all deadlock to kick the winning goal.

Sydney's Nick Malceski had a chance to level the scores with 24 seconds left but sprayed his shot on goal from 40 metres to the left.

In summary for The Age, Richard Hinds wrote: The Swans might lament the loss of sharp-shooter Nick Davis to a hamstring strain late in the third quarter and a tripping free that should have been paid to Jarrad McVeigh as he stormed towards goal in the final term. But, facing a tough match next weekend against a Geelong team keen to atone for a heartbreaking loss in last year's finals, their time would be better spent trying to work out how they failed to capitalise on Sunday's largesse than lamenting injustices.

The best clue came in the third quarter after Davis steered the ball through from a tight angle and incited his teammates into action with the wave of the first. Perhaps for the first time this season, a team that expected the ball to bounce its way took risks and broke lines. The result? Goals! The difference to last year? There were not enough of them.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 6
Sydney v Melbourne
Sunday, April 23, 2006
SCG, 1.10pm AEST, crowd: 29,167
Conditions: Good
Weather: 20C, fine and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
SYD 4.2-26 (5) 6.6-42 9.10-64 13.14-92
MEL 3.3-21 7.5-47 (5) 10.6-66 (2) 15.7-97 (5)
Goals: Melbourne: Adem Yze 3, Travis Johnson 2, Jeff White 2, Aaron Davey 2, Cameron Bruce 2, Brock McLean, David Neitz, Byron Pickett, Russell Robertson. Sydney: Barry Hall 3, Adam Schneider 2, Ted Richards, Ryan O'Keefe, Michael O'Loughlin, Amon Buchanan, Nick Davis, Nick Malceski, Luke Ablett, Jared McVeigh.
Best: Melbourne: Cameron Bruce, Byron Pickett, Aaron Davey, Matthew Whelan, James McDonald. Sydney: Amon Buchanan, Craig Bolton, Adam Schneider, Ben Mathews, Nick Malceski.
Umpires: Mathew James, Martin Ellis, Troy Pannell.

 

A crowd of 32,188 responded to a rare Monday night game at Football Park when Port and the Saints turned on a high-scoring thriller. The Power scored three goals in the first seven-and-a-half minutes and led by 12, 24 and 15 points at the three breaks before sealing a four-point victory.

Ashley Porter
reported in The Age: It was a superb contest until the final seconds – the Saints got to within five points on the cusp of time-on, and it was Josh Mahoney, with his sixth goal, that stemmed the tide. Cruelly Nick Riewoldt also had the chance to goal, but missed an easy set shot, and Port held on.

It was a fierce battle from the start. The firm term was the most keenly contested in Adelaide this season, and in the opening seven minutes fights broke out around the ground with the most obvious tussle occurring between Riewoldt and Matthew Bishop. But more importantly, the Power kicked away to lead three goals to nothing. Between breaths, the Saints responded with three goals, only to see Port kick another two with Mahoney increasing his tally to three, and returning captain Warren Tredrea (closely attended by Max Hudghton) kicking a goal from his first kick of the season.

Alan Shiell noted for Sportal: Playing with the desire that beat Sydney at the SCG by three goals, Port looked good enough in the first half to sew up the match in the third quarter. But St Kilda banged on four goals in the first seven minutes of the third term – from Troy Schwarze (two), Riewoldt and Luke Ball – and grabbed the lead for the first time when Aaron Fiora kicked a behind to make it 12.6 to 12.5.

Stuart Dew's second goal put Port in front again but Schwarze's third restored St Kilda's lead. Mahoney sank his fifth and Stephen Milne replied for the Saints before Peter Burgoyne and Dew goaled again – Port was 15 points clear at three-quarter time. Aaron Hamill promptly slashed it with two goals in the first ten minutes of the final quarter before it became a tense goal-for-goal finish with Dew, Xavier Clarke, Mahoney and Ball taking it in turns for six-pointers in an epic contest.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 7
Port Adelaide v St Kilda
Monday (n), April 24, 2006
Football Park, 7.40pm AEST, crowd: 32,188
Conditions: Very good
Weather: 15C, fine and clear
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
PA 6.2-38 (12) 12.5-77 (24) 17.6-108 (15) 19.8-122 (4)
STK 4.2-26 8.5-53 14.9-93 18.10-118
Goals: Port: Josh Mahoney 6.0, Stuart Dew 4, Peter Burgoyne 3, Warren Tredrea 2, Daniel Motlop, Michael Pettigrew, Nathan Lonie, Brett Ebert. St Kilda: Aaron Hamill 4, Nick Riewoldt 3, Troy Schwarze 3, Stephen Milne 2, Luke Ball 2, Brett Voss, Steven Baker, Andrew McQualter, Xavier Clarke.
Best: Port: Chad Cornes, Josh Mahoney, Brendon Lade, Peter Burgoyne, Peter Walsh, Nathan Lonie, Kane Cornes, Brad Symes. St Kilda: Lenny Hayes, Luke Ball, Sam Fisher, Aaron Hamill, Nick Dal Santo, Xavier Clarke, Robert Harvey, Troy Schwarze.
Umpires: Scott McLaren, Stefan Grun, Michael Avon.
Report:
Darryl Wakelin
(PA) was cited for striking Stephen Milne (StK) during the first quarter – assessed as a Level Three offence. Due to an existing five-year good record, Wakelin was offered a one-game suspension with an early plea. Wakelin accepted the MRP ruling of a one-match suspension.

 

The new-look MCG on Anzac Day braced itself accommodating its fifth biggest attendance for a home-and-away match – 91,234. The multitude were treated to another Collingwood-Essendon special on a near-perfect fine and sunny afternoon. After trailing for most of the first three quarters, the Magpies prevailed by 17 points as footy made a spectacular return to its spiritual home following the Commonwealth Games.

Collingwood's win was its first on Anzac Day since 2002 and only its second from the past eight clashes between these sides on the biggest day of the home and away calendar. Alan Didak's four second-half goals, including three in the final term, eased a lot of pain for Magpie supporters, who cheered on their biggest result since reaching the 2003 grand final.

Malcolm Conn reviewed the match for The Australian: After a slow start, Collingwood was forced to work harder than it should have for a victory – which form and personnel said should have always been the Magpies' – because potent forwards Anthony Rocca and Chris Tarrant managed just 1.7 between them. Both have already had big days out this season and will again, suggesting that even in modest form the Magpies are a dangerous unit.

Paul Gough noted for Sportal: Essendon was widely tipped to struggle without its leading goalkicker of the past nine years after Matthew Lloyd succumbed to a season-ending hamstring injury last week. Unfortunately for the gallant Bombers, it was the Magpies' superior firepower in attack which proved the difference in a memorable final quarter as goalsneak Didak booted three goals, to swing the game Collingwood's way.

The Pies went to the last change with a seven-point lead after having not hit the front for the first time until the 23 minute mark of the third term when Didak's first goal of the game gave them the lead. Didak then began the final term with a goal-square screamer over Henry Slattery to extend the lead to 13 points and when the Pies' Dale Thomas produced a magic moment minutes later with a goal on the run from 50 metres, the Pies were 19 points up and looked home.

But Essendon fought back through inspirational acting captain James Hird, who marked and goaled to cut the deficit to 13 points, before youngster Heath Shaw – who had been magnificent in defence all day – gifted Scott Lucas a goal when he gave away an unnecessary 50m penalty for failing to return the ball to him on the full.

Suddenly the margin was just six points with the quarter less than half over before Didak immediately steadied the Pies with a quick snap from the square to restore a two goal advantage before he fittingly sealed after a marking at the 27 minute mark. From the moment Didak gave the Pies the lead in the third quarter, Collingwood would not be headed again as the brave Bombers were only left to ponder what might have been had their captain and champion full-forward not been sitting in the grandstand injured.
2006 — ROUND 4 — GAME 8
Collingwood v Essendon
Tuesday, April 25, 2006
MCG, 2.40pm AEST, crowd: 91,234
Conditions: Very good
Weather: 18C, fine and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
COL 2.4-16 6.8-44 11.14-80 (7) 15.16-106 (17)
ESS 4.4-28 (12) 7.8-50 (6) 10.13-73 12.17-89
Goals: Collingwood: Alan Didak 4, Nathan Buckley 3, Dale Thomas 2, James Clement, Cameron Cloke, Brodie Holland, Paul Licuria, Ryan Lonie, Anthony Rocca. Essendon: David Hille 3, James Hird 2, Scott Lucas 2, Chris Heffernan, Andrew Lovett, Angus Monfries, Dean Rioli, Jason Winderlich.
Best: Collingwood: Ben Johnson, Heath Shaw, Dane Swan, Nathan Buckley, Alan Didak, Dale Thomas, Paul Licuria. Essendon: David Hille, James Hird, Nathan Lovett-Murray, Brett Stanton, Mark McVeigh, Dustin Fletcher.
Anzac Medal: Ben Johnson (Collingwood).
The Anzac Medal is awarded to the player who's conduct and play during the game,
best exemplifies the Anzac Spirit – skill, courage in adversity,
self sacrifice, teamwork and fair play.

Umpires: Derek Woodcock, Shaun Ryan, Brett Allen.
Report:
Brodie Holland
(Col) was cited for striking James Hird (Ess) during the fourth quarter. Due to his previous record an early plea would yield no reduction. Holland accepted the MRP ruling of a one-match suspension.



2006 Ladder after Round 4
W L D F A % Total
1 WEST.B'DOGS 4 506 332 152.4 16
2 WEST COAST 4 405 315 128.6 16
3 COLLINGWOOD 3 1 455 360 126.4 12
4 HAWTHORN 3 1 394 323 122.0 12
5 ADELAIDE 3 1 371 323 114.9 12
6 GEELONG 2 2 399 306 130.4 8
7 ST KILDA 2 2 396 370 107.0 8
8 FREMANTLE 2 2 357 344 103.8 8
9 Port Adelaide 2 2 394 436 90.4 8
10 Essendon 1 3 387 406 95.3 4
11 Carlton 1 3 321 354 90.7 4
12 Sydney 1 3 334 385 86.8 4
13 Melbourne 1 3 356 424 84.0 4
14 Brisbane 1 3 322 432 74.5 4
15 Kangaroos 1 3 344 473 72.7 4
16 Richmond 1 3 315 473 66.6 4



FOR THE RECORD

COL HUTCHINSON's
Approaching Milestones
2006, Round 4,
Fri-Sat-Sun-Mon-Tues, April 21-22-23-24-25
(subject to selection, injury or suspension)
CAREER MATCHES
300 – DAVID NEITZ (Melbourne)
ü
      268 premiership games, 26 pre-season, 2 State, 3 International
250 – SAVERIO ROCCA, 93 Kan 2001-06, 156 Col 1992-2000
ü
100 – DARREN GLASS (West Coast) 2000-06
ü
100 – BRENT GUERRA, 3 Haw 2006, 31 StK 2004-05, 65 PA 2000-03
ü
100 – RYAN LONIE (Collingwood) 2001-06
ü
  50 – DANIEL CROSS (West.B'dogs) 2002-06
ü
  50 – DYLAN McLAREN, 3 Car 2006, 46 Bri 2001-05
ü
  50 – BRENT STAKER (West Coast) 2003-06
ü
GUERNSEY NUMBERS, CAREER MATCHES RECORD
249 – BRAD JOHNSON (Western Bulldogs) wearing #6
     passing 248 match record of JOHN DUGDALE (North Melb) 1955-1970
ü
MATCHES AT A VENUE
137 – MICHAEL VOSS (Brisbane) at the BCG (Gabba)
ü
     passing 136 match record of MARCUS ASHCROFT
GOALKICKING
300 – RUSSELL ROBERTSON (Mel) 1997-2006 = 299 goals, 170 games
300 – ANTHONY ROCCA, Col, Syd, 1995-2006 = 298 goals, 187 games
250 – NATHAN THOMPSON, Kan, Haw, 1998-2006 = 245 goals, 145 games
200 – ADEM YZE (Mel) 1995-2006 = 196 goals, 236 games
150 – JOEL BOWDEN (Rch) 1996-2005 = 148 goals, 195 games
100 – GREG TIVENDALE (Rch) 1998-2006 = 99 goals, 147 games
100 – SCOTT WEST (WB) 1993-2006 = 99 goals, 279 games

<>

<>

2006, Round 4
HAWTHORN 15.10-100 (Croad 5.3, Mitchell 2, Osborne 2) best, Crawford, Clarke, Croad, CARLTON 9.14-68 (Whitnall 3, Koutoufides 2, Stevens 2) best, Whitnall, Scotland, Stevens.
Friday night at Docklands: 45,102.
Report:
Trent Croad
(Haw) was cited for striking Jordan Russell (Car) during the second quarter. The assessment was reckless conduct, low impact, in play and high contact – equating to 125 points and a one-match ban. Croad escaped with an early plea of guilty, resulting in a reprimand and 93.75 points towards his future record.

WEST.B'DOGS 14.14-98 (Murphy 3, Johnson 2, Cooney 2) best, Harris, West, McMahon, GEELONG 14.13-97 (G.Ablett 4, Mooney 2, Chapman 2, Enright 2) best, Rooke, Ablett, Ling.
Saturday at Docklands: 45,922.

RICHMOND 14.12-96 (Richardson 4, Stafford 3) best, Richardson, Simmonds, Coughlan, BRISBANE 11.16-82 (Bradshaw 2, Brown 2, Power 2) best, Power, Brown, Charman.
Saturday at BCG (Gabba): 30,266.

ADELAIDE 9.16-70 (Biglands 2, Bode 2, Burton 2) best, Johncock, Massie, Reilly, FREMANTLE 9.5-59 (Farmer 3, Polak 3) best, McManus, Schammer, Farmer.
Saturday night at Subiaco: 35,090.
Reports:
l Matthew Carr (Fre) was cited for making negligent contact with umpire Kieron Nicholls during the third quarter. Faced with a $3200 fine for a first such offence, an early plea of guilty would gain a 25 per cent reduction to a $2400 fine. Carr chose to take his charge to the tribunal. The tribunal found Carr not guilty of the offence.
l Brett Burton (Ade) was charged with a Level Three offence for striking Steven Dodd (Fre) during the third quarter – assessed as intentional contact, low impact. in play and high contact. Following discovery of a prior offence from Round 13 last season carrying over 70.31 points, Burton was offered an early plea of guilty and 25 percent reduction to 221.48 points and a two-match suspension. Burton however chose to contest the classification of 'intentional' to 'reckless'. The tribunal found that Burton's conduct was intentional and suspended him for two matches.

WEST COAST 14.11-95 (Hunter 4, Wirrpanda 3) best, Judd, Cox, Hunter, KANGAROOS 10.11-71 (Harding 3, C.Jones 2) best, Brown, Harvey, C.Jones.
Sunday at Manuka Oval: 9,541.

MELBOURNE 15.7-97 (Yze 3) best, Bruce, Pickett, Davey, SYDNEY 13.14-92 (Hall 3, Schneider 2) best, Buchan, C.Bolton, Schneider.
Sunday at SCG: 29,167.

PORT ADELAIDE 19.8-122 (Mahoney 6.0, P.Burgoyne 3) best, C.Cornes, Mahoney, Lade, ST KILDA 18.10-118 (Hamill 4, Riewoldt 3) best, Hayes, Ball, Fisher.
Monday night at Football Park: 32,188.
Report:
Darryl Wakelin
(PA) was cited for striking Stephen Milne (StK) during the first quarter – assessed as a Level Three offence. Due to an existing five-year good record, Wakelin was offered a one-game suspension with an early plea. Wakelin accepted the MRP ruling of a one-match suspension.

COLLINGWOOD 15.16-106 (Didak 4, Buckley 3, Thomas 2) best, Johnson, H.Shaw, Swan, ESSENDON 12.17-89 (Hille 3, Hird 2, Lucas 2) best, Hille, Hird, Lovett-Murray.
Anzac Medal: Ben Johnson (Collingwood).
Tuesday at MCG: 91,234.

Report:
Brodie Holland
(Col) was cited for striking James Hird (Ess) during the fourth quarter. Due to his previous record an early plea would yield no reduction. Holland accepted the MRP ruling of a one-match suspension.


uuuu

<>


*

Consecutive Matches
2006, Round 4

205 – Adem YZE (Mel) since 1997-R8 – 15+25+22+25+22+24+22+23+23+4
186 – Jared CROUCH (Syd) from debut, 1998-R7 – 18+23+22+23+22+24+24+26+4
147 – Adam GOODES (Syd) from 1999-R22 – 2+22+23+22+24+24+26+4
101 Matthew PAVLICH (Fre) from 2001-R15 – 8+22+23+22+22+4

u


In the Goals, 2006 Games Goals R4 Total
Score
Mark RICCIUTO (Adelaide) 4 15 1.6 15.12-102
Mark WILLIAMS (Hawthorn) 4 15 2.0 15.3-93
Brendan FEVOLA (Car) 3 14 susp 14.6-90
Barry Hall (Sydney) 4 13 3.1 13.6-84
Anthony ROCCA (Collingwood) 4 13 1.3 13.6-84
Matthew LLOYD (Essendon) 3 13 inj 13.3-81
Nick RIEWOLDT (St Kilda) 4 12 3.3 12.7-79
Robert MURPHY (WBdogs) 4 11 3.2 11.9-75
Alan DIDAK (Collingwood) 4 11 4.0 11.3-69
Brad JOHNSON (WBdogs) 4 10 2.2 10.7-67
Jeff FARMER (Fremantle) 4 10 3.3 10.5-65
Josh MAHONEY (Port Adel) 4 10 6.0 10.0-60
Gary ABLETT (Geelong) 4 9 4.2 9.8-62
Trent CROAD (Hawthorn) 4 9 5.3 9.8-62
Brett BURTON (Adelaide) 4 9 2.2 9.6-60
Daniel BRADSHAW (Brisbane) 4 9 2.1 9.4-58
Scott LUCAS (Essendon) 4 9 2.1