Footystats Diary, footy's best kept secret, Match Review, 2005-R21


Masthead1.gif (6053 bytes)
Footy's best kept secret ...

2005, Match Review — Round 21


Ladder after Round 21
Stats Update of every round, 2005



ROUND 21, Fri-Sat-Sun, August 19-20-21

Crows-Eagles in Subi battle for minor premiership
Eight clubs run for last four finals places
Last-kick Freo ends St Kilda's 7-win run
Geelong flog the Eagles by 76 points
Adelaide in record-breaking romp over Pies
Port ditch the Lions to stay alive
Melbourne all but eliminate the Bulldogs
Sydney sink Kangas and rise to third place
Bombers blitz Blues with new highest score
Last-gasp Tigers win with amazing comeback

THE STATS THAT MATTER ...
l Ladder leaders West Coast with 5.3-33 at Kardinia Park kicked the lowest score of the season ...

l Adelaide met Collingwood – the Crows with their ninth-straight win sent the Magpies to their seventh successive defeat ... Adelaide booted a new highest score and posted a new highest-winning margin against the Pies ...

l In *Travellin' 2005* Port Adelaide made the 100th journey and scored the 32nd win of the premiership season ...

l Melbourne's 3AW at the Essendon-Carlton match introduced KELLY UNDERWOOD to the commentary team, the first female caller of AFL football ...

l Only 37,481 attended the Essendon-Carlton match – the smallest to watch the pair at the MCG in 26 home-and-away fixtures since 1993.

uuuu

MILESTONES OF ROUND 21 —
l
NEALE DANIHER reached 300 VFL-AFL matches, 82 premiership games, Essendon 1979-81 & 89-90, 8 pre-season, 3 State – Melbourne coach since 1998, 184 premiership matches, 21 pre-season, 2 State ... 150th JASON JOHNSON (Essendon) 1997-2005 ... 150th BRAD SCOTT, 128 Bri 1997-2005, 22 Haw 1997 ... 150th MICHAEL WILSON (Port Adelaide) 1997-2005 ... 100th ROBERT MURPHY (Western Bulldogs) 2000-05 ... PAUL WILLIAMS 100th for Sydney (2001-05), also 189 Col 1991-2000 ... BARNABY FRENCH 50th for Carlton (2002-05), also 62 PA 1999-2002 ... BEN COUSINS captained West Coast for the 100th time, following in the footsteps of JOHN WORSFOLD, 138 matches, 1991-98 ... ADEM YZE (Mel) wore number 13 for a record 218th game passing the 217 times by ROD CARTER (SM-Sydney, 1980-90) and JOHN LAW (North Melb, 1978-89) ...

Highest Score:

28.14-182, ESSENDON v Carlton
Biggest Margin: 110pts, ADELAIDE v Coll'wood
Best in Goals: 7.2 – Matthew LLOYD (Ess) v Car
6.1 – Russell ROBERTSON (Mel) v WB
6.0 – Mark JOHNSON (Ess) v Car
5.5 – Trent HENTSCHEL (Ade) v Col
5.0 – Nick DAVIS (Syd) v Kan
5.1 – Ben DIXON (Haw) v Rch
Lowest Score: 5.3-33, WEST COAST v Geelong
Best Quarters: 1st 9.4-58 ESS v Car
2nd 9.2-56 ESS v Car
3rd 7.4-46 RCH v Haw
4th 6.6-42 RCH v Haw

Published crowds for 2005, Round 21 —

38,057 Fremantle v St Kilda
20,372 Geelong v West Coast
40,372 Adelaide v Collingwood
35,221 Brisbane v Port Adelaide
32,621 Melbourne v West.B'dogs
34,975 Sydney v Kangaroos
37,481 Essendon v Carlton
30,906 Richmond v Hawthorn
270,005 Total for Round 21 — (2004: 262,974)
5,702,541 Progressive at Round 20 – (2004: 5,341,295)
5,972,546 Progressive at Round 21 – (2004: 5,604,269)

FROM THE ROUND

FREMANTLE v ST KILDA
l
After five failures, the Dockers won their first game on the Friday night stage since 1999-R10 versus Melbourne at the MCG ... 5.2-32 was Freo's second best start against the Saints ... no other new match records were noted ...

Fremantle's JUSTIN LONGMUIR added his name to a unique list of players to goal after the final siren (or bell) to win the match ... Sydney's BARRY HALL did so earlier this year at the Gabba – 2005-R3(n)-BCG ...

GEELONG v WEST COAST
l
95 points in 1989-R2 at Kardinia Park remains the highest winning margin by the Cats over West Coast ... 5.3-33 equals the Eagles' lowest score of 35 meetings against Geelong and stands as its sixth lowest score of 444 AFL matches since 1987 ...

5.3-33 2005-R21-KP v Geelong 16.13-109
4.9-33

2002-R14-KP

v Geelong 8.17-65
4.7-31 1997-R14(n)-FP v Adelaide 16.10-106
3.12-30 2001-R10-PP v Carlton 21.23-149
3.11-29 1992-R18-P v St Kilda 15.5-95
3.5-23 1992-R23-WO v Footscray 7.11-53
1.12-18 1989-R15-WH v Essendon 25.10-160

... Our sharp-eyed statophile Bruce Kennedy noted it was the third time over the past 10 years where Geelong has kept West Coast scoreless at Kardinia Park – 1995-R13 (Q3), 2004-R14 (Q4) and 2005 (Q3) ... BEN COUSINS captained West Coast for the 100th time, following in the footsteps of JOHN WORSFOLD, 138 matches, 1991-98 ...

ADELAIDE v COLLINGWOOD
l Adelaide with 22.19-151 kicked a new highest score of 23 contests against Collingwood, replacing 22.15-147 of 2000-R17 at Footy Park ... the Magpies 5.11 failed to displace its lowest score of 5.9-39 versus Adelaide kicked in 1997-R21 at Footy Park ... the Crows registered its third-highest win of 344 AFL games ...

139pts 1993-R16(n)-FP Ade 26.15-171 v Rch 4.8-32
137pts

1997-R17(n)-FP

Ade 29.11-185 v Rch 7.6-48
110pts 1992-R20-MCG Rch 7.11-53 v Ade 24.19-163
110pts 2005-R21-FP Ade 22.19-151 v Col 5.11-41

... the Crows with their ninth-straight win sent the Magpies to their seventh successive defeat ... no other new match records were noted ...

BRISBANE v PORT ADELAIDE
l Brisbane with 7.9-51 registered its lowest score of 19 contests – previous lowest 7.11-53 in 2000-R19 at the Gabba ... no other new match records were noted ... 150th BRAD SCOTT, 127 Bri 1997-2005, 22 Haw 1997 ... 150th MICHAEL WILSON (Port Adelaide) 1997-2005 ...

MELBOURNE v WEST.B'DOGS
l the Demons posted their fourth successive win over the Bulldogs – best is seven on-the-trot, 1925-28 and 1934-37 ... no other new match records were noted ... NEALE DANIHER reached 300 VFL-AFL matches, 82 premiership games, Essendon 1979-81 & 89-90, 8 pre-season, 3 State – Melbourne coach since 1998, 183 premiership matches, 21 pre-season, 2 State ... 100th ROBERT MURPHY (Western Bulldogs) 2000-05 ... ADEM YZE (Mel) wore number 13 for a record 218th game passing the 217 times by ROD CARTER (SM-Sydney, 1980-90) and JOHN LAW (North Melb, 1978-89) ...

SYDNEY v KANGAROOS
l with 7.2-44, Sydney had its best opening quarter of the season ... NICK DAVIS (Syd) with five goals equalled a personal best – he kicked 5.3 in R22 at the MCG last year against Richmond ... LEIGH HARDING (Kan) reached 100 goals in game 68 ... no new match records were noted ... PAUL WILLIAMS 100th for Sydney (2001-05), also 189 Col 1991-2000 ...

ESSENDON v CARLTON
l the Bombers in the 222nd meeting kicked 28.14-182, a new highest score against Carlton, greater than 27.14-176 in 1985-R6 at Windy Hill ... Essendon in its 2165th League match kicked its second-highest half-time score of 18.6-114 – only 18.8-116 is greater, versus North Melbourne in 1985-R18 at Windy Hill – the League record at half-time is Brisbane 21.5-131 in 1999-R20 at the Gabba v Fremantle ... 9.4-58 in the first quarter and 9.2-56 in the second term are new best scores by the Dons against Carlton ... MATTHEW LLOYD (passing 750 goals in game 207) kicked 7.2, the best by a Don against Carlton for 20 years, since MARK HARVEY kicked 7.0 in 1985-R6 ... SCOTT CAMPOREALE (Car) reached 200 goals in game 232 ... 3AW's GRAEME BOND confirms Essendon kicked 10 unanswered goals across the first and second quarters, when the Blues led 3.2 to 0.1 – advancing from 0.1 to 10.4 ... 150th JASON JOHNSON (Essendon) 1997-2005 ... BARNABY FRENCH 50th for Carlton (2002-05), also 62 PA 1999-2002 ... Melbourne's 3AW introduced KELLY UNDERWOOD to the commentary team for the match, the first female caller of AFL football ...

RICHMOND v HAWTHORN
l Hawthorn twice lead the Tigers by 41 points, but failed by four points in the 142nd meeting of the pair ... Richmond historian Rhett Bartlett noted it was Richmond's first win in a Round 21 game since beating the Kangaroos in 2001 ... no new match records were noted ...

uuuu

Statistics for Footystats are enhanced by software from
Eric Sorensen's *Footy Works* and
Steve Norval's 2005 update of *Ruckman*

uuuu



*

 


Fremantle with a goal after the siren beat St Kilda by five points on a chilly Friday night at Subiaco Oval. The victory enhanced the finals hopes of the Dockers as they went to seventh place while the Saints slipped back to fourth on the ladder.

The match will also remembered not only for further injuries suffered by St Kilda to JUSTIN KOSCHITZKE, MATT MAGUIRE and LUKE PENNY but for the fact that Fremantle enjoyed five goals from free kicks and the investigation of comments overheard late on Friday night at Perth Airport as people were returning to the east on QF 648. Following a TV report, a thorough AFL inquiry exonerated all officiating field umpires of any breach of integrity —
also refer Diary week 485 and 486.

Sportal reported proceedings: After four quarters of finals-like football it took until the dying seconds of the match for the home side to emerge victors. Ruckman-forward Justin Longmuir marked brilliantly after Luke McPharlin ran Justin Peckett down with the ball and the big man converted from 25 metres. Matthew Pavlich was once again the shining light for Fremantle, kicking four goals while Paul Hasleby bounced back from last week's shocker. For the Saints veteran Robert Harvey put in a virtuoso performance in the midfield and was ably assisted by young gun Nick Dal Santo.

After a slow start in last week's derby disaster Fremantle was keen to get away well against the Saints and it did, managing four of the first five goals. The visitors kept in touch through Harvey's two majors and after a tight term the Dockers were up by a goal at the first break. St Kilda took charge in the second, winning the clearances despite Aaron Sandilands' ruck dominance. Harvey, Luke Ball and Dal Santo pumped the ball forward to the dangerous Fraser Gehrig as the Saints put on five goals to two for the quarter. At the main change the visitors has earned a 13-point break.

The third term saw the St Kilda bench become reminiscent of an emergency ward. In spite of their woes the visitors extended their advantage to 16 points at the turn for home after a tight quarter that yielded them two goals to the home side's one.

The final stanza was a classic, with fans on the edge of their seats as Fremantle held the Saints goalless and won the game by kicking four goals of its own.
2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 1
Fremantle v St Kilda
Friday (n), August 19, 2005
Subiaco Oval, 8.40pm AEST, crowd: 38,057
Conditions: Good
Weather: 11C, cool and clear, after a morning of 1.4C at 7am
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
FRE 5.2-32 (6) 7.2-44 8.6-54 12.8-80 (5)
STK 4.2-26 9.3-57 11.4-70 (16) 11.9-75
Goals: Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich 4, Luke McPharlin 4, Paul Medhurst, Brett Peake, Jeff Farmer, Justin Longmuir. St Kilda: Fraser Gehrig 4, Robert Harvey 3, Nick Dal Santo 2, Justin Peckett, Cain Ackland.
Best: Fremantle: Matthew Pavlich, Paul Hasleby, Justin Longmuir, Antoni Grover, Brett Peake, Luke McPharlin. St Kilda: Robert Harvey, Nick Dal Santo, Leigh Montagna, Fraser Gehrig, Luke Ball, Steven Baker.
Umpires (gold): Brett Allen, Matthew Head, Derek Woodcock.
Report:
l Brendon Goddard (StK) was charged with a Level One striking offence against Steven Dodd (Fre) during the first quarter. The incident was assessed as reckless conduct (two points), low impact (one point), in play (one point) and body contact (one point). This is a total of five activation points, which relates to a Level One offence, drawing 125 demerit points and a one-game suspension. He has no applicable good or bad record. Goddard accepted guilt with an early plea, a reprimand from the MRP and 93.75 points towards his future record.

 

Geelong gave their finals hopes a massive boost by smashing top of the table West Coast by 76 points on Saturday afternoon at Kardinia Park. The Cats broke a four-game losing streak that followed the 79-point win of premier Port Adelaide in Round 16.

Lyall Johnson
reported for The Age: In a game that was done and dusted by the long break, and deteriorated into a scrappy, mistake-riddled affair in the second half, the Eagles belied their premiership favourite status and put in their worst performance of the year. The Cats destroyed West Coast at its own game – winning the contests around the ground and being able to run with numbers – leaving the hapless Eagles to seemingly wonder what was going on. Not one Geelong player was a passenger. The Cats had 80 more kicks, split the difference with handballs but led the tackle count 65 to 46.

Jimmy Bartel led the way, and showed why the Cats were so eager to get his signature again. Normally reliable stopper Tyson Stenglein could do little more than just follow in Bartel's wake. Steve Johnson repaid the faith of his teammates with a best-on-ground performance. His hard running and skills were on full display, and he really is one of the most unsung players in the competition. It was a welcome return for skipper Steven King from a finger injury. King dominated the ruck, and was a good tall presence around the ground, but the show-stealer was Nathan Ablett, who gave the Cats the presence they have been craving in the forward line.

Nathan was used as Geelong's primary leading forward and had three goals by quarter-time. With his father Gary exploding out of his seat in the Hickey Stand with every touch, the 19-year-old could have had another, but for an unnecessary handball to Peter Riccardi just 15 metres out, who scored. Nathan might lack the freakish spring of his famous father, but he took a leaf out of his dad's book, crashing over the top of a pack to take a strong overhead grab, which resulted in his second major. By the end of the first he was on to his third defender and he finished the day with four goals as coach Mark Thompson decided to move him out of the goal square.

When a team smashes another by 76 points two weeks from the finals, it is usually a case of confirming what we already know. That the winner is superior, has momentum and deserves its place ahead of the other on the ladder. But, apart from a confidence boost, the return of Tom Harley and some encouraging individual efforts from key players, can Geelong get a true indication of where it is at from a match in which the opposition played so poorly? And why couldn't the Cats put the Eagles away even more convincingly?

Question marks hang over whether the Eagles can win a flag with their forward structure. With Phil Matera and Michael Gardiner out, the midfield does not have the confidence to go long to a contest. The Eagles' form on the road is also a worry – this was their fourth loss away from home.
2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 2
Geelong v West Coast
Saturday, August 20, 2005
Kardinia Park, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 20,372
Conditions: Good
Weather: 15C, cool, windy, mostly sunshine
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
GEE 5.4-34 (26) 10.7-67 (46) 12.12-84 (63) 16.13-109 (76)
WCE 1.2-8 3.3-21 3.3-21 5.3-33
Goals: Geelong: Nathan Ablett 4, Steve Johnson 3, Peter Riccardi 2, Kent Kingsley 2, Steven King, Kane Tenace, Andrew Mackie, Cameron Ling, Gary Ablett. West Coast: Brent Staker 2, Ben Cousins, Mark Seaby, Mark Nicoski.
Best: Geelong: Steve Johnson, Jimmy Bartel, Nathan Ablett, Steven King, Jared Rooke, Joel Corey, Matthew Scarlett, Cameron Mooney. West Coast: Michael Braun, Chad Fletcher, Mark Nicoski.
Umpires (red): Hayden Kennedy, Scott Jeffery, Shane McInerney.

 

Adelaide recorded its highest score and biggest winning margin against Collingwood with a crushing victory on Saturday afternoon at Football Park. The aimless Magpies were never in the game, handing the Crows their ninth straight win. Only wayward kicking in the first term – 4.9 – saved Collingwood from greater humiliation.

Alan Shiell
observed for afl.com.au: The Crows' running, play-on style, complemented by the constant use of handball, contrasted starkly with Collingwood's stop-start tactics. Rarely did the Magpies develop any fluency in their game. Tall forwards Trent Hentschel (five goals), Ken McGregor (three), Ian Perrie (three) and Scott Welsh (three) cashed in on Adelaide's dominance by sharing 14 of the 22 goals.

They were well serviced by wingmen Brett Burton and Martin Mattner and busy midfielders Scott Thompson, Mark Ricciuto, Tyson Edwards and Simon Goodwin, who were backed by the competition's meanest defence, in which Nathan Bock, Ben Hart, Ben Rutten, Andrew McLeod, Nathan Bassett and Graham Johncock took turns to shine – when McLeod wasn't having a run on the ball.

Ashley Porter noted in The Age: Adelaide's depth of quality players has never been deeper, and this was emphasised when, after losing ruckman Ben Hudson the previous week with a knee injury, Matthew Clarke came into the side for the first time this season. He was a valuable contributor against his younger and inexperienced opponents, including Guy Richards, who showed he might be a top player of the future.

Shane O'Bree, Brodie Holland and Paul Licuria were among those to amass the stats for the Magpies and provide meaningful opposition, as did Nathan Buckley when the ball got near him, but too many of their teammates played too much kick-and-hope football. This was Adelaide at its defensive and attacking best, and Collingwood at its lowest ebb. It was an opportunity for the lesser-light Magpies to shrug their inexperienced tag and strut their stuff, but sadly they weren't up to the task.
2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 3
Adelaide v Collingwood
Saturday, August 20, 2005
Football Park, 2.40pm AEST, crowd: 40,372
Conditions: Fair to good, soft in patches
Weather: 12C, cool and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
ADE 4.9-33 (20) 10.12-72 (56) 17.15-117 (80) 22.19-151 (110)
COL 2.1-13 2.4-16 5.7-37 5.11-41
Goals: Adelaide: Trent Hentschel 5.5, Ken McGregor 3, Ian Perrie 3, Scott Welsh 3, Mark Ricciuto 2, Scott Thompson 2, Robert Shirley, Nathan Bock, Tyson Edwards, Brett Burton. Collingwood: Tarkyn Lockyer, Jason Cloke, Blake Caracella, Heath Shaw, Matthew Lokan.
Best: Adelaide: Trent Hentschel, Brett Burton, Scott Thompson, Nathan Bock, Mark Ricciuto, Tyson Edwards. Collingwood: James Clement, Brodie Holland, Shane O'Bree, Ben Davies, Paul Licuria, Tarkyn Lockyer.

Umpires (red): Corin Rowe, Stefan Grun, Michael Avon.

 

Port Adelaide moved closer to defending its premiership with a five-goal win over Brisbane in fine and mild conditions on Saturday night at the Gabba. Port's high-possession, highly efficient football proved too much for the often wasteful Lions who threw everything at Port but couldn't produce enough fit players. Port are now half-a-game outside of the eight, while Brisbane slumped from 7th to 10th on the ladder.

Peter Blucher
reviewed the match for The Age: Port should have won by more. It had 26 scoring shots to 16, and 378 possessions to 263. It always looked the better and more efficient side, but it wasn't until late in the third quarter that it took control on the scoreboard. Brothers Chad (26 possessions) and Kane Cornes (25) joined Warren Tredrea and Shaun Burgoyne in a comprehensive demolition of a Brisbane side that had too many players who were not fit enough to play at maximum capacity. Jonathan Brown, resuming after a two-week lay-off with osteitis pubis, was a shadow of his match-winning best. He wasn't helped by poor delivery into the forward line, but he could barely run and didn't have the body strength to match his opponent. He had just four touches and, when coach Leigh Matthews mercifully took the big-hearted key forward from the ground 10 minutes from the end, it was almost a symbolic confirmation of the end of an era.

Jason Akermanis, carrying an adductor-hamstring problem for several weeks, didn't stretch out, and Simon Black, who missed last week with a calf worry, couldn't cover the ground as normal. For the second week in a row Michael Voss, who had 35 possessions, was magnificent. He played every minute of the game, but not even a superhuman effort from the skipper could get the Lions home. Port just had too many good players. The visitors had lost five of their previous six visits to the Gabba, but won two key midfield match-ups. Not for the first time, Kane Cornes had the better of Black, while Dominic Cassisi beat Akermanis.

Matthews, renowned for his quiet demeanour during his years in Brisbane, let fly with a Barassi-style outburst at quarter-time – finger-pointing and all. It worked, but only briefly. The Lions, 16 points down at the first change, kicked three goals in four minutes to grab the lead. But the Power, dynamite on the rebound and more precise in its delivery to the forwards, steadied and by half-time the visitors led by 16 points. Matthews threw Daniel Bradshaw and Chris Johnson forward in the third quarter, leaving Mal Michael – six days after a compound finger dislocation – to pick up Tredrea.

It could have been decisive at either end. Johnson had the Lions' first three shots at goal in the third term but kicked 1.2. Tredrea followed with three behinds in a row. Chad Cornes became the wildcard. Mark Williams threw him forward and, when he became the game's first multiple goal-kicker midway through the term, the lead was back to 16 points – again. Brisbane, which had kicked 12 goals in its last seven quarters of football, was going to have to find something special in the last. It was never going to happen.

2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 4
Brisbane Lions v Port Adelaide
Saturday (n), August 20, 2005
BCG (Gabba), 7.10pm AEST, crowd: 35,221
Conditions: Good
Weather: 20C, fine and mild
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
BRI 2.0-12 5.2-32 6.7-43 7.9-51
PA 4.4-28 (16) 7.6-48 (16) 9.12-66 (23) 11.15-81 (30)
Goals: Port: Chad Cornes 2, Warren Tredrea 2, Adam Kingsley, Josh Mahoney, Dean Brogan, Stuart Dew, Michael Pettigrew, Kane Cornes, Brett Montgomery. Brisbane: Justin Sherman, Michael Voss, Ash McGrath, Simon Black, Tim Notting, Chris Johnson, Josh Drummond.
Best: Port: Shaun Burgoyne, Chad Cornes, Josh Mahoney, Kane Cornes, Domenic Cassisi, Stuart Dew. Brisbane: Michael Voss, Josh Drummond, Jed Adcock, Luke Power, Tim Notting.
Umpires (gold): Mathew James, Matt Stevic, Darren Goldspink.

 

In a season of thrilling finishes (31 single-digit margins), none has been finer than Melbourne's effort on Saturday night at MCG when they swamped the Western Bulldogs in the final five minutes to secure a gutsy four-point win.

Mark Harding
for the Sunday Herald Sun reported: Jeff White was the Demon hero and, despite his wonderful four quarters, it is amazing that the best thing he did all night was to fall to the ground after the most minimal contact from Wayde Skipper at a boundary throw-in inside the final minute. He goaled – his second for the term – and for the second week in a row the Demons came back from the dead.

Karen Lyon noted for The Age: When Bulldogs forward Brad Johnson bobbed and weaved to kick his third goal at the 14-minute mark of the final quarter he extended his team's lead to 22 points. It appeared the Dogs were on their way to the finals. It didn't look a pivotal moment when, just seconds later, Adam Cooney ran into an open goal and shanked the kick for a behind. But it is a moment that will be combed over for months by the youngster.

As seems the rule in 2005, there was of course to be one more twist in what was already and absorbing match that had ebbed and flowed all night. The rush of four Melbourne goals started at the 20-minute mark, with a simple mark 15 metres from goal by ruckman Jeff White. When he calmly cut the lead to 15 points, the alarm bells didn't really start ringing for the Dogs. But things became uncomfortable when two minutes later Adem Yze – released out of defence and into the forward line only in the final quarter – marked an errant kick-in and kicked the second of his last-term goals to cut the lead to nine points. All of a sudden, the Demons had options in the forward line. It had not been that way earlier in the night, with Russell Robertson playing a lone hand. After Robertson's fourth goal midway through the second quarter, coach Rodney Eade was forced to switch Dale Morris on to Robertson and send Brian Harris to full-forward. Robertson would end the night with six goals and was clearly the most dangerous forward on the ground, but remarkably he did not kick a goal in the last quarter.

With five minutes left to play, Daniel Giansiracusa won a free kick in his forward pocket but he sprayed the shot that would have given the Dogs breathing space. Melbourne quickly transferred play to its end, where Ben Holland took a strong pack mark. He kicked the goal and reduced the margin to four points.

A rushed behind to the Demons cut the margin to three points, but the real drama came at the 30-minute mark, when White was awarded a free kick at a boundary throw-in. White held his nerve and drilled the goal from close to 50 metres, putting the Demons in front for the first time since the third quarter. For the second week in a row, Melbourne had won at the last gasp.

2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 5
Melbourne v Western Bulldogs
Saturday (n), August 20, 2005
MCG, 7.10pm AEST, crowd: 32,621
Conditions: Good
Weather: 14C, cool, possible showers
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
MEL 4.2-26 8.5-53 11.8-74 16.13-109 (4)
WB 7.2-44 (18) 9.6-60 (7) 13.7-85 (11) 16.9-105
Goals: Melbourne: Russell Robertson 6.1, Adem Yze 2, Jeff White 2, David Neitz, Ben Holland, Guy Rigoni, Brad Green, Steven Armstrong, Aaron Davey. West.B'dogs: Robert Murphy 3, Brad Johnson 3, Rohan Smith 2, Mitch Hahn 2, Chris Grant 2, Matthew Robbins, Farren Ray, Daniel Giansiracusa, Nathan Eagleton.
Best: Melbourne: Guy Rigoni, Russell Robertson, Nathan Brown, Jeff White, Travis Johnstone, Brad Green. West.B'dogs: Rohan Smith, Scott West, Robert Murphy, Ryan Griffen, Jordan McMahon, Adam Cooney, Daniel Cross.
Umpires (gold): Michael Vozzo, Justin Schmitt, Stephen McBurney.

 

Sydney's prospects for the finals brightened considerably when they comprehensively beat the Kangaroos in fine and sunny conditions at the SCG on Sunday afternoon. The Swans didn't disappoint the big hometown crowd of 35,975 as they rattled off their best first quarter of the season to lead by 37 points at the first break.

The Age noted: Mercurial Sydney sharpshooter Nick Davis looms at the Swans' X-factor for the finals, following his best-on-ground performance. The 25-year-old is one of the least predictable weapons in Sydney's potent forward line but was pivotal in his team's win when he booted five goals, including four in the first half.

Sydney's forward line was in devastating form contributing 12 of the goals – Davis (5), Barry Hall (3), Michael O'Loughlin (2) and Ryan O'Keefe (2) – while their midfielders racked up the possessions. The Swans were sensational in the opening term dominating with deft efficiency around the ground and not giving their opponents a sniff. Sydney had 15 inside-50s to nine in the first term but more importantly 14 disposals per goal to the Roos' 58 as they took an unassailable six-goal lead at the first change.

The forward line continued to fire in the second quarter but despite the margin they showed enormous desperation. Lewis Roberts-Thomson smothered Callum Urch twice in a minute, Luke Ablett stripped Glenn Archer of the ball leading to a goal, and Jude Bolton dived for a loose ball with no consideration for his head.

The Kangaroos tried to get some run back in the third quarter, but wayward kicking let both sides down as the Roos out-scored the Swans 3.4 to 2.5 to still trail by 43-points at the last change. Unlike the corresponding game last year – when the Roos came back from a 40-point three-quarter deficit – there were no heroics this time.
2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 6
Sydney v Kangaroos
Sunday, August 21, 2005
SCG, 1.10pm AEST, crowd: 34,975
Conditions: Good
Weather: 20C, fine and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
SYD 7.2-44 (37) 12.3-75 (48) 14.8-92 (43) 15.11-101 (37)
KAN 1.1-7 4.3-27 7.7-49 9.10-64
Goals: Sydney: Nick Davis 5.0, Barry Hall 3, Michael O'Loughlin 2, Ryan O'Keefe 2, Adam Goodes, Nic Fosdike, Adam Schneider. Kangaroos: Shannon Grant 4, Corey Jones 3, Troy Makepeace, Leigh Harding.
Best: Sydney: Nick Davis, Brett Kirk, Michael O'Loughlin, Leo Barry, Tadhg Kennelly, Barry Hall. Kangaroos: Shannon Grant, Adam Simpson, Corey Jones, Brady Rawlings.
Umpires (gold): Adam Davis, Scott McLaren, Shaun Ryan.
Reports:
l Ryan O'Keefe (Syd) for striking Jess Sinclair (Kan) was reviewed. The MRP said O'Keefe pushed his arm back to break contact with Sinclair after marking the ball. The contact was minimal and to the chest. No further action was required.
l Corey Jones (Kan) was charged with a first offence for abusive language towards emergency umpire Troy Pannell during the second quarter. A first offence for abusive language towards an umpire is a $1200 fine. Jones accepted guilt through an early plea which reduced the penalty by 25 per cent to a $900 fine.

 

Essendon at its rampant best kicked its highest score of 222 contests against Carlton since 1897 when they destroyed a sad-and-sorry Blues outfit by 99 points on an overcast Sunday afternoon at the MCG. Only 37,481 attended – the smallest to watch the pair in 26 home-and-away fixtures since 1993 when they started to play regularly at headquarters.
The Blues jumped out of the box with the first three goals to which the Bombers replied with 10 unanswered goals. At one point late in the first half Essendon had kicked 17 of the last 18 goals scored.

Jason Phelan reported for afl.com.au: Matthew Lloyd and Mark Johnson were the chief destroyers with seven and six goals respectively, with Johnson also gathering 26 possessions. James Hird was outstanding for the Bombers with 29 touches and three goals as was Scott Lucas with 27 disposals and a goal. Lance Whitnall was the best for Carlton with 10 marks and 22 possessions, while Heath Scotland also gathered 26 touches and took 11 marks. It didn't look like it was going to be the Dons' day as both Ricky Dyson and Kepler Bradley missed golden opportunities to register their side's first goal, but Jobe Watson sparked the amazing scoring avalanche when he goaled at the 12-minute mark – there would be 12 different goal-scorers by the end.

Stephen Rielly observed in The Age: It was no surprise that Essendon's record score against Carlton, 27.14, set by the great side of 1985, was later eclipsed by a goal. A further 10 goals to five in the second half saw Essendon's percentage improve by more than five per cent although the record winning margin over Carlton of 109 points did not topple, perhaps the only opportunity missed by the Dons.

Kevin Sheedy used the second half to experiment – the tall backs in the last term were Ted Richards, (who had earlier embarrassed Brendan Fevola), Nathan Lovett-Murray and Jobe Watson – but was only ensuring the spoils were shared and some of his younger players were able to take something meaningful from the match.
2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 7
Essendon v Carlton
Sunday, August 21, 2005
MCG, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 37,481
Conditions: Good
Weather: 15C, overcast, showers forecast, rain in Q4
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
ESS 9.4-58 (38) 18.6-114 (70) 23.10-148 (88) 28.14-182 (99)
CAR 3.2-20 6.8-44 8.12-60 11.17-83
Goals: Essendon: Matthew Lloyd 7.2, Mark Johnson 6.0, Ricky Dyson 3, James Hird 3, Jason Johnson 2, Andrew Lovett, Scott Lucas, Angus Monfries, Jay Nash, Brent Stanton, Paul Thomas, Jobe Watson. Carlton: Digby Morrell 3, Matthew Lappin 2, Jarrad Waite 2, Scott Camporeale, Andrew Carrazzo, Sam Fisher, Lance Whitnall.
Best: Essendon: Matthew Lloyd, Mark Johnson, James Hird, Jason Johnson, Scott Lucas, Richard Dyson. Carlton: Scott Camporeale, Lance Whitnall, Heath Scotland, Digby Morrell.
Umpires (gold): Chris Donlan, Jason Quigley, Dean Margetts.

 

Richmond staged a remarkable comeback to pinch victory from Hawthorn in the final minute under the closed roof at Docklands on Sunday afternoon. Twice during the match, the Hawks led by 41 points, as late the 20th minute of the third quarter. Richmond's thrilling victory appeared on the surface to be ammunition for the cynics, who believe "tanking" matches to earn the right to an end-of-season priority draft pick is rife.

Though Hawthorn kicked 13 goals in the first half, it's highest first-half score for more than three years, it wasn't enough, Sportal noted. Whilst the Tigers' finals hopes had all-but disappeared before this game, it was a display of courage which shows just how much last year's wooden spooners have improved this season. And it was a great way for former Hawk veteran Mark Graham to farewell his career while former skipper Wayne Campbell will cherish this win in what was his second last game.

However it was a moment of brilliance from the player who is the future of Richmond that proved the difference in a thrilling finish. The Tigers' number one draft pick Brett Deledio showed why he is one of the favourites for this year's Rising Star award when his devastating run down the wing in the final minute enabled the Tigers to get the ball forward for Kayne Pettifer to kick the winning goal.

It was one of three goals for Pettifer while Matthew Richardson kicked four and Ray Hall in one of his best game for the Tigers kicked three. The Hawks were well served by Peter Everitt while Ben Dixon and Harry Miller kicked nine goals between them and although the Hawks are still eligible for a priority draft pick after this result, there could be no doubt about their commitment on Sunday.
2005 — ROUND 21 — GAME 8
Richmond v Hawthorn
Sunday, August 21, 2005
Docklands, 2.10pm AEST, Roof: closed; crowd: 30,906
Conditions: tba
Weather: 15C, overcast, showers forecast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
RCH 3.2-20 7.7-49 14.11-95 20.17-137 (4)
HAW 6.2-38 (18) 13.2-80 (31) 17.5-107 (12) 21.7-133
Goals: Richmond: Matthew Richardson 4, Kayne Pettifer 3, Ray Hall 3, Greg Stafford 2, Richard Tambling 2, Troy Simmonds 2, Rory Hilton, Brett Deledio, Shane Tuck, Kane Johnson. Hawthorn: Ben Dixon 5.1, Harry Miller 4, Peter Everitt 2, Angelo Lekkas 2, Trent Croad 2, Lance Franklin 2, Luke Hodge, Tim Clarke, Clinton Young, Nick Ries.
Best: Richmond: Brett Deledio, Shane Tuck, Ray Hall, Kayne Pettifer, Joel Bowden, Matthew Richardson. Hawthorn: Peter Everitt, Luke Hodge, Richard Vandenberg, Shane Crawford, Harry Miller, Ben Dixon.
Umpires (red): Kieron Nicholls, Ray Chamberlain, Martin Ellis.


 


2005 Ladder after Round 21
W L D F A % Total
1 WEST COAST 17 4 2187 1742 125.5 68
2 ADELAIDE 16 5 1988 1443 137.8 64
3 SYDNEY 14 7 1845 1621 113.8 56
4 ST KILDA 13 8 2221 1759 126.3 52
5 KANGAROOS 12 9 1940 1986 97.7 48
6 GEELONG 11 10 2065 1838 112.4 44
7 FREMANTLE 11 10 1966 1918 102.5 44
8 MELBOURNE 11 10 2076 2181 95.2 44
9 Port Adelaide 10 10 1 1908 1991 95.8 42
10 Brisbane 10 11 2092 1978 105.8 40
11 West.B'dogs 10 11 2244 2251 99.7 40
12 Richmond 10 11 1954 2121 92.1 40
13 Essendon 8 13 2033 2207 92.1 32
14 Hawthorn 5 16 1829 2188 83.6 20
15 Collingwood 5 16 1784 2284 78.1 20
16 Carlton 4 16 1 1933 2557 75.6 18



FOR THE RECORD

Approaching Milestones
2005, Round 21, Fri-Sat-Sun, August 19-20-21
(subject to selection, injury or suspension)
PLAYER AND COACH (300 matches qualifies for AFL Life Membership) ü
300 – NEALE DANIHER, 82 premiership games, Essendon 1979-81 & 89-90
       8 pre-season, 3 State
Melbourne coach since 1998, 183 premiership matches, 21 pre-season, 2 State
PREMIERSHIP MATCHES
150 – JASON JOHNSON (Essendon) 1997-2005
ü
150 – BRAD SCOTT, 127 Bri 1997-2005, 22 Haw 1997
ü
150 – MICHAEL WILSON (Port Adelaide) 1997-2005
ü
100 – ROBERT MURPHY (Western Bulldogs) 2000-05
ü
MATCHES WITH CURRENT CLUB
100 – PAUL WILLIAMS (Sydney) 2001-05, also 189 Col 1991-2000
ü
  50 – BARNABY FRENCH (Carlton) 2002-05, also 62 PA 1999-2002
ü
AS CAPTAIN
100 – BEN COUSINS (West Coast) 2001-05
ü
Cousins is the second Eagle to captain the club to 100 games, following in the footsteps of JOHN WORSFOLD, 138 matches, 1991-98.
PREMIERSHIP MATCHES IN GUERNSEY
218 – ADEM YZE (Mel) has worn number 13 in 217 matches, the equal of ROD CARTER (SM-Sydney, 1980-90) and JOHN LAW (North Melb, 1978-89) 
ü
GOALKICKING
750 – MATTHEW LLOYD (Ess) 1995-2005 = 746 goals, 207 games
200 – PETER BELL (Fre, NMK) 1995-2005 = 199 goals, 227 games
200 – SCOTT CAMPOREALE (Car) 1995-2005 = 199 goals, 231 games
200 – STEPHEN MILNE (St Kilda) = 198 goals, 93 games
100 – NICK STEVENS (PA, Car) 1998-2004 = 99 goals, 167 games
100 – SIMON GOODWIN (Ade) 1997-2005 = 96 goals, 165 games
100 – LEIGH HARDING (Kan) 2001-05 = 99 goals, 67 games

original prepared by COL HUTCHINSON

<>

<>

2005, Round 21
FREMANTLE 12.8-80 (Pavlich 4, McPharlin 4) best, Pavlich, Hasleby, Longmuir, ST KILDA 11.9-75 (Gehrig 4, Harvey 3) best, Harvey, Dal Santo, Montagna.
Friday night at Subiaco: 38,057.
Report:
l Brendon Goddard (StK) was charged with a Level One striking offence against Steven Dodd (Fre) during the first quarter. The incident was assessed as reckless conduct (two points), low impact (one point), in play (one point) and body contact (one point). This is a total of five activation points, which relates to a Level One offence, drawing 125 demerit points and a one-game suspension. He has no applicable good or bad record. Goddard accepted guilt with an early plea, a reprimand from the MRP and 93.75 points towards his future record.

GEELONG 16.13-109 (N.Ablett 4, S.Johnson 3) best, S.Johnson, Bartel, N.Ablett, WEST COAST 5.3-33 (Staker 2) best, Braun, Fletcher, Nicoski.
Saturday at Kardinia Park: 20,372.

ADELAIDE 22.19-151 (Hentschel 5.5, McGregor 3, Perrie 3) best, Hentschel, Burton, Thompson, COLLINGWOOD 5.11-41 (5 x singles) best, Clement, Holland, O'Bree.
Saturday at Football Park: 40,372.

PORT ADELAIDE 11.15-81 (C.Cornes 2, Tredrea 2) best, S.Burgoyne, C.Cornes, Mahoney, BRISBANE 7.9-51 (7 x singles) best, Voss, Drummond, Adcock.
Saturday night at BCG: 35,221.

MELBOURNE 16.13-109 (Robertson 6.1, Yze 2, White 2) best, Rigoni, Robertson, Brown, WEST.B'DOGS 16.9-105 (R.Murphy 3, Johnson 3) best, Smith, West, R.Murphy.
Saturday night at MCG: 32,621.

SYDNEY 15.11-101 (Davis 5.0, Hall 3) best, Davis, Kirk, O'Loughlin, KANGAROOS 9.10-64 (Grant 4, Corey Jones 3) best, Grant, Simpson, Corey Jones.
Sunday at SCG: 34,975.
Reports:
l Ryan O'Keefe (Syd) for striking Jess Sinclair (Kan) was reviewed. The MRP said O'Keefe pushed his arm back to break contact with Sinclair after marking the ball. The contact was minimal and to the chest. No further action was required.
l Corey Jones (Kan) was charged with a first offence for abusive language towards emergency umpire Troy Pannell during the second quarter. A first offence for abusive language towards an umpire is a $1200 fine. Jones accepted guilt through an early plea which reduced the penalty by 25 per cent to a $900 fine.

ESSENDON 28.14-182 (Lloyd 7.2, M.Johnson 6.0) best Lloyd, M.Johnson, Hird, CARLTON 11.17-83 (Morrell 3) best, Camporeale, Whitnall, Scotland.
Sunday at MCG: 37,481.

RICHMOND 20.17-137 (Richardson 4, Pettifer 3, Hall 3) best, Deledio, Tuck, Hall, HAWTHORN 21.7-133 (Dixon 5.1, Miller 4) best, Everitt, Hodge, Vandenberg.
Sunday at Docklands: 30,906.


uuuu

<>


*

Consecutive Matches
2005, Round 21

199 – Adem YZE (Mel) since 1997-R8 – 15+25+22+25+22+24+22+23+21
177 – Jared CROUCH (Syd) from debut, 1998-R7 – 18+23+22+23+22+24+24+21
138 – Adam GOODES (Syd) from 1999-R22 – 2+22+23+22+24+24+21
105 Matthew SCARLETT (Gee) from 2001-R8 – 15+22+22+25+21

u


In the Goals, 2005 Games Goals R21 Total
Score
Fraser GEHRIG (St Kilda) 20 74 4.2 74.47-491
Barry HALL (Sydney) 21 69 3.1 69.38-452
Russell ROBERTSON (Melbourne) 21 65 6.1 65.27-417
Matthew RICHARDSON (Richmond) 21 63 4.4 63.45-423
Mark WILLIAMS (Hawthorn) 19 63 inj 63.35-413
Matthew PAVLICH (Fremantle) 21 61 4.1 61.25-391
Warren TREDREA (Port Adel) 21 59 2.4 59.42-396
Matthew LLOYD (Essendon) 19 58 7.2 58.29-377
Kent KINGSLEY (Geelong) 21 56 2.0 56.37-373
Scott LUCAS (Essendon) 21 51 1.1 51.23-329
Scott WELSH (Adelaide) 19 50 3.0 50.22-322
Brendan FEVOLA (Carlton) 19 49 0.2 49.25-319
Stephen MILNE (St Kilda) 21 49 0.0 49.20-314
Nathan THOMPSON (Kangaroos) 21 47 0.0 47.28-310
Michael O'LOUGHLIN (Sydney) 18 43 2.2 43.21-279
Daniel BRADSHAW (Brisbane) 18 40 0.1 40.20-260
David NEITZ (Melbourne) 17 39 1.0 39.23-257
Adem YZE (Melbourne) 21 39 2.0 39.32-266
Shannon GRANT (Kangaroos) 21 38 4.2 38.22-250
Phillip MATERA (West Coast) 17 38 inj 38.27-255
Brad JOHNSON (West.B'dogs) 21 37 3.0 37.20-242
Saverio ROCCA (Kangaroos) 18 36 0.3 36.27-243
Chris TARRANT (Coll'wood) 17 36 inj 36.27-243
Jarrad WAITE (Carlton) 20 36 2.1 36.23-239
Ashley McGRATH (Brisbane) 20 35 1.0 35.15-225
Nathan G BROWN (Richmond) 10 34 inj 34.19-223
Blake CARACELLA (Coll'wood) 20 34 1.0 34.19-223
Corey JONES (Kangaroos) 21 34 3.1 34.28-232
Jonathan BROWN (Brisbane) 13 33 inj 33.19-217
Jeff FARMER (Fremantle) 18 33 1.1 33.15-213
Luke McPHARLIN (Fremantle) 18 33 4.1 33.11-209
Ian PERRIE (Adelaide) 21