Footystats Diary, footy's best kept secret, Match Review, 2005-R17


Masthead1.gif (6053 bytes)
Footy's best kept secret ...

2005, Match Review — Round 17


Ladder after Round 17
Stats Update of every round, 2005



ROUND 17, Fri-Sat-Sun, July 22-23-24

St Kilda's biggest win over Pies since 1944
Saints give Collingwood another belting
Hawks get the points; Blues win the spoon
Fierce Bulldogs maul disappointing Cats
Brown the difference as Lions hold out Dons
Patchy Port just escape from plucky Tigers
Hard-running Sydney stop Eagles in mini-final
Adelaide deny Kangas in thriller at Docklands
Fremantle blow the Demons away

THE STATS THAT MATTER ...
l 73pts is St Kilda's biggest winning margin over the Magpies, replacing 68pts of 1944-R10 at the Junction Oval ...  21.17-143 is the third highest score by St Kilda versus Collingwood – 22.16-148 in 1982-R21 at Waverley remains the best ...

l Ladder leaders West Coast and fourth-placed Sydney drew 37,071 – the best SCG crowd since 2001-R4(n) when the Swans played Essendon ...

l Three of the eight matches of the round had 13 point margins ... top club West Coast ended with 9.13-67, the lowest score of Round 17 ...

uuuu

MILESTONES OF ROUND 17 —
l
150th CLINT BIZZELL, 74 Mel 2002-05, 75 Gee 1996-2001 ... 150 JOSH FRANCOU (Port Adelaide) 1997-2005 ... 150th BEN MATHEWS (Sydney) 1997-2005 ... 100th MATTHEW WHELAN (Melbourne) 2000-05 ... 50th QUINTEN LYNCH (West Coast) 2002-05 ... 50th MARTIN MATTNER (Adelaide) 2002-05 ... 50th MARK L WILLIAMS (Hawthorn) 2002-05 ... NICK DAVIS, 50th for Sydney (2003-05), also 71 Col 1999-2002 ... 200th by umpire MARTIN ELLIS, 1996-2005, 176 premiership games, 23 pre-season ...

Highest Score:

21.17-143, ST KILDA v Collingwood
Biggest Margin: 73pts, ST KILDA v Collingwood
Best in Goals: 6.1 – Scott WELSH (Ade) v Kan
5.2 – Justin KOSCHITZKE (StK) v C'wood
5.4 – Mark WILLIAMS (Haw) v Car
5.0 – Wayde SKIPPER (WB) v Gee
5.1 – Jonathan BROWN (Bri) v Ess
Lowest Score: 9.13-67, WEST COAST v Sydney
Best Quarters: 1st 6.4-40 WB v Gee
2nd 7.3-45 HAW v Car
3rd 7.3-45 WB v Gee
4th 6.4-40 KAN v Ade

Official AFL crowds for 2005, Round 17 —

45,576 St Kilda v Collingwood
31,459 Hawthorn v Carlton
29,351 West.B'dogs v Geelong
36,077 Brisbane v Essendon
27,455 Port Adelaide v Richmond
37,071 Sydney v West Coast
25,263 Kangaroos v Adelaide
31,028 Fremantle v Melbourne
263,280 Total for Round 17 — (2004: 266,272)
4,587,751 Progressive at Round 16 – (2004: 4,327,827)
4,849,531 Progressive at Round 17 – (2004: 4,594,009)

FROM THE ROUND

ST KILDA v COLLINGWOOD
l
... in the 199th contest between the pair the Saints beat the Pies for a third-straight game, the best run since five wins in 1996-98 ... 73pts is St Kilda's biggest victory over the Magpies, replacing 68pts of 1944-R10 at the Junction Oval ...   21.17-143 is the third highest score by St Kilda versus Collingwood – 22.16-148 in 1982-R21 at Waverley remains the best ... going into the match St Kilda added to the 22,222 goals kicked in their 2066 League matches since 1897 ... no other new match records were noted ...

HAWTHORN v CARLTON
l ... the Hawks with 7.3 produced their best second quarter against the Blues for 20 years, but 8.4 in 1985-R10 at Princes Park remains the top ... no other new match records were noted in the 151st meeting of which Hawthorn have won 49, the Blues 101 ... 50th MARK L WILLIAMS (Hawthorn) 2002-05 ...

WEST.B'DOGS v GEELONG
l ... no new match records were noted ... Geelong continued their W-L-W-L-W-L sequence over the past six games of the season ...

BRISBANE v ESSENDON
l ... the Bombers last won at the Gabba in their 2000 premiership year – Essendon's record at the BCG against Brisbane remains at three wins from 11 visits – special note: the Dons beat the Hawks at the Gabba in 1981 ... no other new match records were noted in the 29th meeting ... 200th by umpire MARTIN ELLIS, 1996-2005, 176 premiership games, 23 pre-season ...

PORT ADELAIDE v RICHMOND
l ... Port with 7.4 kicked their best opening quarter of 12 contests against Richmond, replacing the 6.3 of 2002-R12 at Football Park ... the final margin of 13pts was the tightest finish since two points in 1999-R11 at Football Park ... no other new match records were noted  ... 150th JOSH FRANCOU (Port Adelaide) 1997-2005 ...

SYDNEY v WEST COAST
l ... ladder leaders West Coast and fourth-placed Sydney drew 37,071 – the best SCG crowd since 2001-R4(n) when the Swans played Essendon ...for the sixth successive meeting the result went with the *home* side – West Coast last won in Sydney in 1999 ... no other new match records were noted ... 150th BEN MATHEWS (Sydney) 1997-2005 ... 50th QUINTEN LYNCH (West Coast) 2002-05 ... NICK DAVIS, 50th for Sydney (2003-05), also 71 Col 1999-2002 ...

KANGAROOS v ADELAIDE
l ... the Crows won their fifth straight game for the first time since 2002-R15 to 19 ... despite kicking 6.4-40, their best last quarter of the season, the Kangaroos failed to win by 13 points ... no other new match records were noted ... 50th MARTIN MATTNER (Adelaide) 2002-05 ...

FREMANTLE v MELBOURNE
l ... at the 17th meeting between the pair no new match records were noted ... 150th CLINT BIZZELL, 74 Mel 2002-05, 75 Gee 1996-2001 ...100th MATTHEW WHELAN (Melbourne) 2000-05 ...

uuuu

Statistics for Footystats are enhanced by software from
Eric Sorensen's *Footy Works* and
Steve Norval's 2005 update of *Ruckman*

uuuu

TAKE 2 – WIN ONE, LOSE ONE – BY HUGE MARGINS
Martin Windsor-Black follows up the trend which Bruce Kennedy picked up on last week in Tuesday's Diary (July 19th).

The win-loss sequence continues for Port and Geelong ...


Port Adelaide:
Rd 13 – won by 117 points – a reversal of 102 points on the previous round
Rd 14 – lost by 31 points – a reversal of 148 points
Rd 15 – won by 62 points – a reversal of 93 points
Rd 16 – lost by 79 points – a reversal of 141 points
Rd 17 – won by 13 points – a reversal of 92 points

Geelong:
Rd 13 – lost by 69 points – a reversal of 73 points
Rd 14 – won by 55 points – a reversal of 124 points
Rd 15 – lost by 54 points – a reversal of 109 points
Rd 16 – won by 79 points – a reversal of 133 points.

Rd 17 – lost by by 35 points – a reversal of 114 points

uuuu



*

 


By a margin of 73 points, St Kilda recorded their greatest win over Collingwood when they played under the closed roof at Docklands Stadium on Friday night. The Saints posted their fourth straight win and 10th for the season, lifting them to fourth place on the ladder.

However, the victory came at a price with defenders Max Hudghton and Xavier Clarke both injured during the second quarter. Bruce Matthews observed for the Herald Sun: St Kilda's acting captain Justin Koschitzke built on the solid form of the past three weeks with another polished leadership performance which helped set up a percentage-boosting victory against an inexperienced and wasteful Collingwood. Whether setting the Saints' onballers free at the centre bounce duels or drifting forward toward to take one-grab, contested marks, Kosi would again be in line for Brownlow votes from the thumping win.

Justin Phelan noted for Sportal: Stephen Milne was lively up forward and should have finished with more than his four goals, while Luke Ball and Lenny Hayes were important through the middle with 32 and 26 disposals respectively. As always, Magpie captain Nathan Buckley was prominent – finishing with 26 touches – and Leon Davis rebounded well from a trouble week with an eye-catching 21-possession, two-goal effort.

The Herald Sun concluded: St Kilda's ferocious tackling had a few of the more seasoned Magpies jumping sideways. And the Saints' slick finishing underlined the talent gulf between the combatants. Actually, there was nothing wrong with Collingwood's endeavour ... pity about the application. For instance, the Magpies ventured inside their forward 50 16 times for a solitary goal in the second term. The Saints took it within range 13 times to produce five goals.

After halftime was the only period which the Magpies looked equals, booting five of the first seven goals to trim the deficit to 22 points after 22 minutes. Pie coach Mick Malthouse would have been watching closely to see how his charges ran out of the game, and he would surely have been disappointed as the Saints bullied Collingwood into submission – outscoring the Pies six goals to two in the last quarter.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 1
St Kilda v Collingwood
Friday (n), July 22, 2005
Docklands, 7.40pm AEST, Roof: closed, crowd: 45,576
Conditions: Fair to good, dry in patches
Weather: 15C, showers forecast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
STK 4.4-28 (12) 9.8-62 (38) 15.14-104 (48) 21.17-143 (73)
COL 2.4-16 3.6-24 8.8-56 10.10-76
Goals: St Kilda: Justin Koschitzke 5.2, Stephen Milne 4, Brent Guerra 4, Fraser Gehrig 3, Nick Dal Santo, Raphael Clarke, Luke Ball, Brendon Goddard, Lenny Hayes. Collingwood: Chris Tarrant 2, Leon Davis 2, Tarkyn Lockyer, Nick Maxwell, Scott Burns, Ryan Lonie, Shane Woewodin, David Fanning.
Best: St Kilda: Justin Koschitzke, Luke Ball, Lenny Hayes, Stephen Milne, Andrew Thompson, Stephen Powell. Collingwood: Nathan Buckley, Leon Davis, Shane Woewodin, Shane Wakelin, Heath Shaw, Tarkyn Lockyer.
Umpires (gold): Stephen McBurney, Shaun Ryan, Derek Woodcock.

 

Hawthorn and Carlton staged the battle for the wooden spoon on Saturday afternoon at the MCG. The Hawks won the battle by 24 points to move six points clear and consign the bottom-placed Blues to their second wooden spoon in four years – it was Carlton's 11th successive defeat.

Jason Phelan
noted for Sportal: Both sides had to deal with late changes to their line-ups with the Hawks forced to bring in Harry Miller and Nick Ries for Shane Crawford (quad) and Michael Osborne (hamstring) while the Blues substituted Callum Chambers for Adrian Deluca (foot).

The brand of attacking football was entertaining to watch, and with 22 goals kicked between the sides in the first half, it was clear both teams had come to play. Both sides made costly errors that were indicative of their respective positions on the ladder, but it was a fast-paced affair that both teams employing high intensity throughout. Hawthorn small forward Mark Williams celebrated his 50th game in style with a five-goal performance, which also saw him regain top spot in the race for the Coleman Medal.

Luke Hodge and Danny Jacobs were important with 34 and 31 possessions respectively, while Peter Everitt continued to dominate with 20 hitouts – by far the most of any player. Brendan Fevola finally ended his drought, finding the goals for the first time in three weeks and finished with four, while Nick Stevens performed admirably in the midfield with 26 disposals. Goalsneak Eddie Betts made a mockery of the Hawks' defence at times, doing as he liked in the crumbing and finishing with 26 disposals.

Lyall Johnson in The Age summarised: It is easy to be critical, but amid the mire, there were some positives. Although the game reverted to its awful over-possession style after half-time, the biggest distinction of the first half was the Hawks updated game plan of attempting to move the ball through the corridor. It was encouraging to see players looking inboard for options rather than going sideways. However, in the second half, Hawthorn reverted to its "handball for handball's sake" habits that more than often than not brought things undone. By game's end, Hawthorn had clocked up 171 handballs to Carlton's 93.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 2
Hawthorn v Carlton
Saturday, July 23, 2005
MCG, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 31,459
Conditions: Good
Weather: 13C, cloudy, showers forecast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
HAW 5.3-33 (1) 12.6-78 (13) 15.7-97 (15) 19.13-127 (24)
CAR 5.2-32 10.5-65 12.10-82 15.13-103
Goals: Hawthorn: Mark Williams 5.4, Peter Everitt 2, Nathan Lonie 2, Lance Franklin 2, Trent Croad 2, Rick Ladson, Harry Miller, Simon Taylor, Joel Smith, Tim Clarke, Jordan Lewis. Carlton: Brendan Fevola 4, Eddie Betts 3, Nick Stevens 2, Jarrad Waite 2, Brad Fisher 2, Troy Longmuir, Matthew Lappin.
Best: Hawthorn: Luke Hodge, Danny Jacobs, Joel Smith, Peter Everitt, Mark Williams, Trent Croad. Carlton: Nick Stevens, Heath Scotland, Brendan Fevola, Lance Whitnall, Anthony Koutoufides, Andrew Carrazzo.
Umpires (red): Matthew Head, Stuart Wenn, Craig Hendrie.
Report:
Luke Brennan
(Haw) reported by umpire Matthew Head for charging Heath Scotland (Car) during the third quarter. The MRP withdrew the charge.

 

Both Geelong and the Western Bulldogs staged a remarkable turnaround of form from the previous week when they met at Docklands on Saturday afternoon. The Bulldogs sparkled, while the Cats were embarrassingly disappointing. The Dogs ended a three-match losing streak, while Geelong's recent 'loss-win-loss-win' trend continued for the seventh consecutive time.

Sportal's Paul Gough heralded the unveiling of a future champion, 18-year-old Ryan Griffen. Gough noted that the Dogs appear to have unearthed a player whom they can build their team around in years to come, as he produced a magnificent performance which would have left Bulldogs fans bursting with excitement over just how good he can become in future seasons.

Griffen's skill and poise off a half-back flank was one of the highlights of a terrific match in which the Bulldogs played some of the best football imaginable for two and-a-half quarters before then surviving a late fightback from the Cats, who had looked a shadow of the team widely tipped to be a premiership contender for most of the game.

Despite Geelong booting eight of the last 11 goals of the match, the Bulldogs set up the victory from the five-minute mark of the second term until the 20-minute mark of the third quarter, when they piled on 10 goals to two. The Bulldogs had several outstanding players – Wayde Skipper played his best match yet with five goals, while Nathan Eagleton (four goals and 28 touches) was outstanding. Midfielders Ryan Griffen, Lindsay Gilbee and Scott West notched up over 80 touches.

Geelong trailed by 68 points late in the third term before drawing within four goals midway through the last quarter, before the Bulldogs added the last two goals and ran away with a superb win.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 3
Western Bulldogs v Geelong
Saturday, July 23, 2005
Docklands, 2.10pm AEST, Roof: closed, crowd: 29,351
Conditions: Fair to good, dry in patches
Weather: 13C, showers forecast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
WB 6.4-40 (25) 10.9-69 (31) 17.12-114 (38) 20.13-133 (35)
GEE 2.3-15 5.8-38 11.10-76 14.14-98
Goals: West.B'dogs: Wayde Skipper 5.0, Nathan Eagleton 4, Rohan Smith 3, Daniel Giansiracusa 2, Matthew Robbins 2, Adam Cooney, Mitch Hahn, Brad Johnson, Robert Murphy. Geelong: Kent Kingsley 4, Gary Ablett 3, Jimmy Bartel 2, Paul Chapman, Joel Corey, Paul Koulouriotis, Darren Milburn, Cameron Mooney.
Best: West.B'dogs: Ryan Griffen, Nathan Eagleton, Lindsay Gilbee, Wayde Skipper, Robert Murphy, Scott West. Geelong: Kent Kingsley, Darren Milburn, Cameron Mooney, Jimmy Bartel, Gary Ablett
Umpires (gold): Chris Donlon, Hayden Kennedy, Justin Schmitt.

 

Despite a lazy third term, the Brisbane Lions survived a fourth quarter scare from Essendon to hang on and record a fourth straight home win on Saturday night before a near capacity crowd of 36,077 at the Gabba. The Lions, who were lacklustre led by 35 points before Essendon mounted a third-quarter comeback.

Peter Blucher
reported the match for The Age – Brisbane's Jonathan Brown, who almost single-handedly had beaten the Bombers with eight goals in round six, had been under a cloud all week with the early stages of osteitis pubis, gathered 15 possessions, nine marks and kicked five goals in the victory. He kicked two magnificent long goals from the boundary line to answer queries over his kicking.

Up by 28 points late in the second term the Lions looked to have it under control before the Bombers, inspired by Scott Lucas at centre half-forward, kicked four goals in eight minutes to pull within four points at the final change. Lucas then put the Bombers in front three minutes into the final term before the Lions found an unlikely hero in Anthony Corrie, who kicked three final-quarter goals. It was back out to 21 points but still Essendon wasn't finished as Corrie went from hero to villain, giving away a free kick and compounding his error with a 50-metre penalty that presented Matthew Lloyd with his only goal for the night.

Andrew Lovett booted his third for the Dons and then Andrew Welsh, dragged earlier, returned to kick a beauty from the boundary – it was back to two points with still 10 minutes to play. In the end Nigel Lappin, forever praised by Matthews for his courage to run when he is exhausted, kicked the clincher when he goaled from the pocket.

Josh Drummond, was best afield with a starring role in defence. He had 26 possessions and provided a mountain of run. Midfielders Simon Black, Michael Voss and Lappin. For the Bombers, Jason Johnson and Damien Peverill led the possession count with 23 and 22, but it was a player of the future, Brent Stanton, who really caught the eye – the speedy midfielder had 20 disposals and drove the ball inside 50 on six occasions.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 4
Brisbane Lions v Essendon
Saturday (n), July 23, 2005
BCG (Gabba), 7.10pm AEST, crowd: 36,077
Conditions: Good
Weather: 15C, clear
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
BRI 5.3-33 (20) 8.9-57 (24) 11.11-77 (4) 17.12-114 (13)
ESS 1.7-13 4.9-33 10.13-73 14.17-101
Goals: Brisbane: Jonathan Brown 5.1, Anthony Corrie 4, Ashley McGrath 2, Simon Black, Justin Sherman, Clark Keating, Tim Notting, Joel McDonald, Nigel Lappin. Essendon: Scott Lucas 4, Andrew Lovett 3, Ricky Dyson 2, Mark Bolton, Angus Monfries, Jason Johnson, Matthew Lloyd, Andrew Welsh.
Best: Brisbane: Jonathan Brown, Anthony Corrie, Josh Drummond, Michael Voss, Mal Michael, Nigel Lappin.  Essendon: Scott Lucas, Dustin Fletcher, Jason Johnson, Brent Stanton, Mark McVeigh, Damien Peverill.
Umpires (gold): Ray Chamberlain, Darren Morris, Martin Ellis.

 

Port Adelaide survived a brave fightback by Richmond to narrowly win by 13 points on Saturday night in wet conditions at Football Park. However, the defending premiers did little to quell concerns about its quality with a performance that was patchy at best. The Tigers dropped from the top eight for the first time since early April and yielded their place to Brisbane.

Anthony Barich for the Sunday Herald Sun observed: Port were fuelled by the industry of Adam Kingsley and Roger James in the centre square when the Power kicked seven goals in the first quarter – six in the first 15 minutes. Port grabbed the lead within the first minute when Kane Cornes's pass was converted by Brendon Lade. The home side's early dominance was underlined by goals to Josh Mahoney, Brett Ebert, Warren Tredrea, Lade again and Byron Pickett. But a rise in Richmond's work rate coincided with a customary drop in concentration from a patchy Port in the second quarter.

Sportal reported: Richmond looked out of the contest when Port established a 43-point buffer early in the second term, but the Tigers turned it around in the midfield. The new-found control saw Richmond pile on five of the next six goals to get within 18 points at half-time when heavy rain was falling. The Tigers' amazing comeback continued with the wet ball in the second half with Matthew Richardson and Troy Simmonds (replayed free kick) converting in the opening minutes. A long Stuart Dew major slowed the Tigers scoring spree but the visitors kept coming. Greg Tivendale goaled from 50 metres and when Brett Deledio made the most of a free kick from 40 metres the Tigers were in front by a point.

Alan Shiell noted: Richardson failed to score from a gettable shot within 50m, and Port responded with a goal on the run from Shaun Burgoyne, who had been pitched into the midfield after blanketing Andrew Krakouer at half-back. Richardson speared a good goal from deep in the pocket to leave Richmond two points behind, but goals to Mahoney and Michael Pettigrew either side of a Pickett behind put Port 15 points clear at the 20-minute mark. Then two rushed behinds were the only scores in the last 12 minutes of the match. While Port won the game, it appears that both teams will struggle to make the eight.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 5
Port Adelaide v Richmond
Saturday (n), July 23, 2005
Football Park, 7.40pm AEST, crowd: 27,455
Conditions: Good, but slippery later
Weather: 15C, heavy rain late Q2 into Q3
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
PA 7.4-46 (31) 10.6-66 (18) 11.8-74 14.12-96 (13)
RCH 2.3-15 7.6-48 11.9-75 (1) 12.11-83
Goals: Port: Josh Mahoney 4, Brendon Lade 2, Warren Tredrea 2, Brett Ebert, Byron Pickett, Damon White, Stuart Dew, Shaun Burgoyne, Michael Pettigrew. Richmond : Matthew Richardson 4, Brett Deledio 2, Shane Tuck, Chris Hyde, Wayne Campbell, Kayne Pettifer, Troy Simmonds, Greg Tivendale.
Best: Port: Kane Cornes, Adam Kingsley, Josh Mahoney, Shaun Burgoyne, Peter Burgoyne, Start Dew, Warren Tredrea. Richmond: Shane Tuck, Joel Bowden, Mark Coughlan, Matthew Richardson, Wayne Campbell, Chris Hyde.
Umpires (red): Michael Vozzo, Mathew James, Jason Quigley.
Report:
Peter Burgoyne (PA) reported by umpire Michael Vozzo for engaging in rough conduct on Shane Tuck (Rch) during in the third quarter. The MRP withdrew the charge.

 

Sydney ended West Coast's seven-match winning streak and enhanced its reputation with a 21-point win over the ladder-leaders in front of the biggest crowd at the SCG for four years on a fine and sunny Sunday afternoon – 37,071 attended.

Jenny McAsey
reviewed the match for The Australian: If there was a measure of respect last week (when they beat Melbourne), there must be unabashed admiration for Sydney after it beat West Coast in every department as it moved to third place and confirmed its reputation. West Coast, which has won this year in all corners of the country from its home in Perth, to Brisbane, Melbourne, Launceston and Adelaide, was overcome on the small confines of the SCG by a team that set out to apply pressure and force a contest at every opportunity. The Swans didn't tag or scrag the Eagles' midfield guns, captain Ben Cousins, Brownlow medallist Chris Judd and Daniel Kerr out of the game. Instead, as Sydney's latest captain Jude Bolton explained, the Swans learned the way Collingwood beat the Eagles in round nine, West Coast's only defeat before the Swans.

While mobile defender Craig Bolton was a surprise match-up for Judd, Jude Bolton ran with Kerr and Luke Ablett stuck with Cousins for most of the game. The midfield rotations were so frenzied. It also meant the gangly Lewis Roberts-Thomson, Sydney's rawest defender, was given the task of quelling brilliant Eagles' ruckman Dean Cox after he had booted four goals in the second quarter to give West Coast a seven-point half-time lead.

In attack, Sydney was too versatile, fielding a combination of brawn, speed and skill. Barry Hall kicked just two goals but bullocked opponents out of the way, while Michael O'Loughlin outclassed Brett Jones to kick three. Adam Schneider, on the outer for much of the season, proved his value with two inspiring smothers and two team-lifting goals in the second half as Sydney ran away with the game, kicking eight goals to the Eagles' three.

Tim Morrisey concluded in the Daily Telegraph: Sydney's premiership stocks climbed dramatically after pulling off a stunning upset against the side everyone has labelled the red-hot favourites. Despite the loss West Coast remain the benchmark and still the team to beat come September because their all-star midfield that has surpassed Brisbane's Fab Four as the best in the business.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 6
Sydney v West Coast
Sunday, July 24, 2005
SCG, 1.10pm AEST, crowd: 37,071
Conditions: Good
Weather: 20C, fine, clear skies and sunny
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
SYD 3.2-20 (9) 5.7-37 9.9-63 (10) 13.10-88 (21)
WCE 1.5-11 6.8-44 (7) 7.11-53 9.13-67
Goals: Sydney: Michael O'Loughlin 3, Adam Schneider 2, Barry Hall 2, Darren Jolly 2, Amon Buchanan, Luke Ablett, Jude Bolton, Nick Davis West Coast: Dean Cox 4, Quinten Lynch, Ben Cousins, Chad Fletcher, Brent Staker, Mark Seaby.
Best: Sydney: Amon Buchanan, Brett Kirk, Jude Bolton, Adam Schneider, Jared Crouch, Leo Barry. West Coast: David Wirrpunda, Dean Cox, Chad Fletcher, Chris Judd, Drew Banfield.
Umpires (white): Adam Davis, Scott McLaren, Shane McInerney.

 

Second-placed Adelaide remain in firm contention after surviving a ferocious last quarter comeback by the Kangaroos to win by 13 points on Sunday afternoon at Docklands. The Crows have now won eight of its past nine matches, and their fourth from five games at Docklands.

When Adelaide captain Mark Ricciuto kicked the second of his three goals nearly 13 minutes into the third term, the Crows had streamed out to a 49-point lead, as noted by Melissa Ryan in The Age: It had come on the back of a deadly ferocity at the contests – largely matched by the ever-spirited Kangaroos – and the precision in then delivering the ball forward, particularly to a rampant Scott Welsh, who showed up his old teammate Glenn Archer by kicking five goals on him in the first half.

The Kangaroos missed easy goal-scoring shots throughout – from set shots, hitting the post, or pushed out to wide angles because of Adelaide's blocking prowess – and had 10 scoring shots to four in the high-pressure final term as they pressed the Crows. Leigh Harding was the main offender with 1.4 for the day. It had been a pattern established early. The Roos dominated the opening 10 minutes of the second quarter for little scoreboard reward, with three missed shots before Shannon Grant kicked one of his four goals after David Hale swooped on the ball as if he was the size of Brent Harvey. But the Crows retaliated with six of the next eight goals.

Matt Burgan reported for Sportal: The Kangaroos deserve a heap of praise for their never-say-die spirit, booting six majors to three in the final term, and although they got back to within seven points after Sav Rocca kicked his second, Ken McGregor answered with the final goal of the match and the Crows held on for a win to savour. Welsh finished with six goals in an outstanding display, while Tyson Edwards – clearly one of the most underrated players in the competition – was damaging with three goals and 23 disposals.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 7
Kangaroos v Adelaide
Sunday, July 24, 2005
Docklands, 2.10pm AEST, Roof: closed, crowd: 25,263
Conditions: Fair to good, dry in patches
Weather: 16C, sunny morning, rain forecast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
KAN 4.2-26 7.5-47 10.9-69 16.13-109
ADE 6.2-38 (12) 12.5-77 (30) 16.7-103 (34) 19.8-122 (13)
Goals: Adelaide: Scott Welsh 6.1, Tyson Edwards 3, Mark Ricciuto 3, Ian Perrie 2, Robert Shirley, Nathan Van Berlo, Scott Thompson, Simon Goodwin, Ken McGregor. Kangaroos: Shannon Grant 4, Brent Harvey 2, Corey Jones 2, Nathan Thompson 2, Saverio Rocca 2, Michael Stevens, Eddie Sansbury, Leigh Harding, Brady Rawlings.
Best: Adelaide: Scott Welsh, Tyson Edwards, Brett Burton, Mark Ricciuto, Ian Perrie, Scott Thompson. Kangaroos: Brent Harvey, Shannon Grant, Jess Sinclair, Daniel Harris, Leigh Colbert, Drew Petrie.
Umpires (gold): Dean Margetts, Simon Meredith, Darren Goldspink.

 

Fremantle kept its finals hopes alive with a gritty 25-point win over Melbourne who suffered their fifth straight defeat and from second a month ago are now just clinging on to eighth place. The slippery conditions on Sunday afternoon contributed to a see-sawing contest with 31,028 attending Subiaco Oval under darkening skies.

Sportal reviewed the match: After three quarters of tight football, where the greatest lead for either side was 13 points, Fremantle turned it on in the final stanza to register its eighth win of the season, just one game out of the top eight. Heath Black was again the chief catalyst, setting up Fremantle's forward forays from across half back. Des Headland (three goals) and Paul Hasleby (two) were also prominent as the home side sparked in the second half.

Light rain fell in the first quarter with Melbourne starting brightly nabbing the first two goals. Fremantle replied through twin towers Matthew Pavlich and Luke McPharlin before the sides traded goals. The rain cleared in the second term but the contest continued to be fought in tight. The Dockers looked set to take charge but a sensational goal from Cameron Bruce and two to Aaron Davey saw Melbourne maintain its slight lead at the main break.

Mic Cullen noted: Headland grabbed seven touches and worked hard in the third term. Bruce snapped a stunner from the left pocket, Ryan Ferguson kicked a rare goal and McPharlin got a couple, but it was Hasleby's goal with a second to go that gave the hosts a one-goal lead as the team turned for home. Byron Schammer opened the scoring in the last, then Pavlich and Headland both added their third goals and Ryan Crowley flew for a mark and played on two metres out to make the margin five goals and the game was over.
2005 — ROUND 17 — GAME 8
Fremantle v Melbourne
Sunday, July 24, 2005
Subiaco Oval, 4.40pm AEST, crowd: 31,028
Conditions: Slippery, following rain – lights on Q3
Weather: 18C, overcast, rain in Q3
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
FRE 4.2-26 7.4-46 11.8-74 (6) 15.11-101 (25)
MEL 4.4-28 (2) 7.7-49 (3) 10.8-68 11.10-76
Goals: Fremantle: Luke McPharlin 4, Matthew Pavlich 3, Des Headland 3, Paul Hasleby 2, Josh Carr, Byron Schammer, Ryan Crowley. Melbourne: Aaron Davey 3, David Neitz 2, Ryan Ferguson 2, Adem Yze, Cameron Bruce, Brock McLean, Brad Green.
Best: Fremantle: Heath Black, Des Headland, Paul Hasleby, Luke McPharlin, Scott Thornton, Peter Bell. Melbourne: Brad Green, Travis Johnstone, Clint Bizzell, Cameron Bruce, Nathan Carroll, Ben Holland.
Umpires (white): Brett Allen, Michael Avon, Scott Jeffery.
Report:
Brad Green
(Mel) for rough play against Brett Peake (Fre) during the first quarter. The MRP withdrew the charge.


 


2005 Ladder after Round 17
W L D F A % Total
1 WEST COAST 15 2 1832 1364 134.3 60
2 ADELAIDE 12 5 1595 1228 129.9 48
3 SYDNEY 11 6 1455 1365 106.6 44
4 ST KILDA 10 7 1766 1451 121.7 40
5 GEELONG 10 7 1708 1502 113.7 40
6 KANGAROOS 10 7 1587 1583 100.3 40
7 BRISBANE 9 8 1757 1542 113.9 36
8 MELBOURNE 9 8 1733 1701 101.9 36
9 Richmond 9 8 1538 1635 94.1 36
10 Port Adelaide 8 8 1 1527 1643 92.9 34
11 Fremantle 8 9 1615 1564 103.3 32
12 West.B'dogs 7 10 1729 1815 95.3 28
13 Essendon 6 11 1542 1795 85.9 24
14 Collingwood 5 12 1466 1802 81.4 20
15 Hawthorn 4 13 1450 1729 83.9 16
16 Carlton 2 14 1 1471 2052 71.7 10



FOR THE RECORD

Approaching Milestones
2005, Round 17, Fri-Sat-Sun, July 22-23-24
(subject to selection, injury or suspension)
UMPIRE
200 – MARTIN ELLIS, 1996-2005
ü
    176 premiership games, 23 pre-season
PREMIERSHIP MATCHES
150 – CLINT BIZZELL, 74 Mel 2002-05, 75 Gee 1996-2001
ü
150 – JOSH FRANCOU (Port Adelaide) 1997-2005
ü
150 – BEN MATHEWS (Sydney) 1997-2005
ü
100 – MATTHEW WHELAN (Melbourne) 2000-05
ü
50 – QUINTEN LYNCH (West Coast) 2002-05
ü
  50 – MARTIN MATTNER (Adelaide) 2002-05
ü
  50 – MARK L WILLIAMS (Hawthorn) 2002-05
ü
MATCHES: WITH CURRENT CLUB
  50 – NICK DAVIS, 49 Sydney 2003-05, also 71 Col 1999-2002
ü
MATCHES: CONSECUTIVE CLUB PREMIERSHIP GAMES
  63 – WARREN TREDREA has played 62 consecutive matches for Port Adelaide since 2003-R5, equalling the record held by CHAD CORNES in the span from 2000-R18 to 2003-R8
ü
GUERNSEY NUMBERS: CAREER MATCH RECORD
106 – CAMERON LING (Geelong) has worn guernsey number 45 on 105 occasions, equalling the League record held by ANTHONY FRANCHINA (Carlton, 1997-2004)
ü
BROTHERS: CAREER GOALS
1000 – The brothers ROCCA have kicked 997 goals – SAVERIO (711) ANTHONY (286)
GOALKICKING
300 – DANIEL BRADSHAW (Bri) 1995-2005 = 296 goals, 153 games
200 – PETER BELL (Fre, NMK) 1995-2005 = 199 goals, 223 games
200 – SCOTT CAMPOREALE (Car) 1995-2005 = 198 goals, 227 games
150 – PAUL MEDHURST (Fre) 2002-05 = 149 goals, 81 games

original prepared by COL HUTCHINSON

<>

<>

2005, Round 17
ST KILDA 21.17-143 (Koschitzke 5.2, Milne 4, Guerra 4) best, Koschitzke, Ball, Hayes, COLLINGWOOD 10.10-70 (Tarrant 2, Davis 2) best, Buckley, Davis, Woewodin.
Friday night at Docklands: 45,576.

HAWTHORN 19.13-127 (Williams 5.4) best, Hodge, Jacobs, Smith, CARLTON 15.13-103 (Fevola 4, Betts 3) best, Stevens, Scotland, Fevola.
Saturday at MCG: 31,459.
Report:
Luke Brennan
(Haw) reported by umpire Matthew Head for charging Heath Scotland (Car) during the third quarter. The MRP withdrew the charge.

WEST.B'DOGS 20.13-133 (Skipper 5.0, Eagleton 4, Smith 3) best, Griffen, Eagleton, Gilbee, GEELONG 14.14-98 (Kingsley 4, Ablett 3, Bartel 2) best, Kingsley, Milburn, Mooney.
Saturday at Docklands: 29,351.

BRISBANE 17.12-114 (Brown 5.1, Corrie 4, McGrath 2) best, Brown, Corrie, Drummond, ESSENDON 14.17-101 (Lucas 4, Lovett 3, Dyson 2) best, Lucas, Fletcher, J.Johnson.
Saturday night at BCG (Gabba)L 36,007.

PORT ADELAIDE 14.12-96 (Mahoney 4, Lade 2, Tredrea 2) best, K.Cornes, Kingsley, Mahoney, RICHMOND 12.11-83 (Richardson 4, Deledio 2) best, Tuck, Bowden, Coughlan.
Report:
Peter Burgoyne (PA) reported by umpire Michael Vozzo for engaging in rough conduct on Shane Tuck (Rch) during in the third quarter. The MRP withdrew the charge.
Saturday night at Football Park: 27,455.

SYDNEY 13.10-88 (O'Loughlin 3, Schnieder 2, Hall, Jolly 2) best, Buchanan, Kirk, J.Bolton, WEST COAST 9.13-67 (Cox 4) best, Wirrpunda, Cox, Fletcher.
Sunday at SCG: 37,071.

ADELAIDE 19.8-122 (Welsh 6.1, Edwards 3, Ricciuto 3) best, Welsh, Edwards, Burton, KANGAROOS 16.13-109 (Grant 4, Harvey 2) best, Harvey, Grant, Sinclair.
Sunday at Docklands: 25,263.

FREMANTLE 15.11-101 (McPharlin 4, Pavlich 3, Headland 3) best, Black, Headland, Hasleby, MELBOURNE 11.10-76 (Davey 3, Neitz 2, Ferguson 2) best, Green, Johnstone, Bizzell.
Sunday at Subiaco: 31,028.

Report:
Brad Green
(Mel) for rough play against Brett Peake (Fre) during the first quarter. The MRP withdrew the charge.


uuuu

<>


*

Consecutive Matches
2005, Round 17

194 – Adem YZE (Mel) since 1997-R8 – 15+25+22+25+22+24+22+23+17
172 – Jared CROUCH (Syd) from debut, 1998-R7 – 18+23+22+23+22+24+24+17
133 – Greg TIVENDALE (Rch) from 1999-R19 – 4+22+25+22+22+22+17
132 – Adam GOODES (Syd) from 1999-R22 – 2+22+23+22+24+24+17
101 Matthew SCARLETT (Gee) from 2001-R8 – 15+22+22+25+17

u


In the Goals, 2005 Games Goals R17 Total
Score
Mark WILLIAMS (Hawthorn) 17 61 5.4 61.30-296
Fraser GEHRIG (St Kilda) 16 57 3.3 57.39-381
Barry HALL (Sydney) 17 53 2.1 53.34-352
Matthew RICHARDSON (Richmond) 17 51 4.1 51.36-342
Warren TREDREA (Port Adel) 17 49 2.2 49.35-329
Kent KINGSLEY (Geelong) 17 46 4.0 46.31-307
Russell ROBERTSON (Melbourne) 17 46 0.2 46.21-297
Stephen MILNE (St Kilda) 17 45 4.4 45.14-284
Matthew PAVLICH (Fremantle) 17 45 3.1 45.19-289
Nathan THOMPSON (Kangaroos) 17 43 2.1 43.24-282
Brendan FEVOLA (Carlton) 15 41 4.1 41.22-268
Matthew LLOYD (Essendon) 15 41 1.3 41.24-270
Scott LUCAS (Essendon) 17 41 4.2 41.17-263
Scott WELSH (Adelaide) 15 41 6.1 41.17-263
David NEITZ (Melbourne) 14 38 2.1 38.20-248
Daniel BRADSHAW (Brisbane) 14 34 0.0 34.14-218
Nathan G BROWN (Richmond) 10 34 inj 34.19-223
Phillip MATERA (West Coast) 15 34 0.1 34.21-225
Michael O'LOUGHLIN (Sydney) 14 34 3.2 34.17-221
Jonathan BROWN (Brisbane) 12 33 5.1 33.17-215
Chris TARRANT (Coll'wood) 16 33 2.1 33.26-224
Adem YZE (Melbourne) 17 33 1.0 33.29-227
Blake CARACELLA (Coll'wood) 17 31 0.0 31.18-204
Shannon GRANT (Kangaroos) 17 30 4.1 30.19-199
Jeff FARMER (Fremantle) 15 29 inj 29.12-186
Saverio ROCCA (Kangaroos) 14 28 2.0 28.19-187
Paul CHAPMAN (Geelong) 16 27 1.0 27.14-176
Quinten LYNCH (West Coast) 17 26 1.1 26.15-171
Ashley McGRATH (Brisbane) 16 26 2.1 26.14-170
Jason AKERMANIS (Brisbane) 17 25 0.2 25.21-171
Aaron DAVEY (Melbourne) 17 25 3.1 25.21-171
Ian PERRIE (Adelaide) 17 25 2.1 25.24-174
Jarrad WAITE (Carlton) 16 25 2.1 25.21-171
Brad GREEN (Melbourne) 17 24 1.0 24.11-155
Brad JOHNSON (West.B'dogs) 17 24 1.0 24.18-162
Luke McPHARLIN (Fremantle) 14 24 4.2 24.10-154
Robert MURPHY (West.B'dogs) 17 24 1.1 24.15-159
*


EVERY ROUND, EVERY GAME OF SEASON 2005

MATCH REVIEW ARCHIVE
Round One, Round Two, Round Three, Round Four,
Round Five, Round Six, Round Seven, Round Eight,
Round Nine, Round 10Round 11, Round 12, Round 13,
Round 14, Round 15, Round 16,


CLUB-BY-CLUB PERFORMANCE, SEASON 2005
REGULARLY UPDATED
Adelaide, Brisbane, Carlton, Collingwood, Essendon, Fremantle, Geelong, Hawthorn,
Kangaroos, Melbourne, Port Adelaide, Richmond, St Kilda, Sydney, West Coast, Western Bulldogs
also
Consecutive Wins and Losses at all venues



Travellin' 2005
1 R1(n)-BCG St Kilda v Bri Lost 0/1
2 R1(n)-S Port Adel v Fre Lost 0/2</