Footystats Diary, footy's best kept secret, Match Review, 2005-R12


Masthead1.gif (6053 bytes)
Footy's best kept secret ...

2005, Match Review — Round 12


Ladder after Round 12



ROUND 12, Fri-Sat-Sun-Mon, June 10-11-12-13

Bombers stretch Eagles to the limit
St Kilda thrash one dimensional Hawks
Brisbane batter the Blues by 10 goals
Hard-fought result to Port over Bulldogs
Freo slide away to hard-working Swans
Cats goalless for a half still hold out Crows

Richmond fold under Kanga pressure
Demons take Queen's Birthday honours

THE STATS THAT MATTER ...
l Port Adelaide played its 200th AFL match ...

uuuu

MILESTONES OF ROUND 12 —
l
300th career game by GLENN ARCHER (North Melb-Kangaroos) 1992-2005, 263 premiership games, 34 pre-season, 3 State ... 150th PAUL LICURIA, 140 Col 1999-2005, 10 Syd 1997-98 ... 100th JONATHAN BROWN (Brisbane) 2000-05 ... 100th BRADY RAWLINGS (Kangaroos) 1999-2005 ... 50th SCOTT THOMPSON, 11 Ade 2005, 39 Mel 2001-04 ... JAMES CLEMENT 100th for Collingwood, also 84 Fre 1996-2000 ...  50th by umpire SHAUN RYAN (2003-05) ... 50th by umpire DEAN MARGETTS (2004-05) ...

Highest Score:

21.14-140, BRISBANE v Carlton
Biggest Margin: 58pts, BRISBANE v Carlton
Best in Goals: 6.6 – Fraser GEHRIG (StK) v Haw
5.1 – Nathan THOMPSON (Kan) v Rch
5.2 – Adem YZE (Mel) v Col
Lowest Score: 8.6-54, HAWTHORN v St Kilda
Best Quarters: 1st 5.3-33 SYD v Fre
GEE v Ade
2nd 7.1-43 BRI v Car
3rd 8.5-53 PA v WB
4th 7.2-44 MEL v Col

Official AFL crowds for 2005, Round 12 —

38,558 West Coast v Essendon
33,905 Hawthorn v St Kilda
37,880 Carlton v Brisbane
27,079 Port Adelaide v West.B'dogs
24,933 Sydney v Fremantle
23,506 Geelong v Adelaide
40,444 Kangaroos v Richmond
65,347 Melbourne v Collingwood
291,652 Total for Round 12 — (2004: 288,489)
3,203,356 Progressive at Round 11 – (2004: 2,975,943)
3,495,008 Progressive at Round 12 – (2004: 3,264,432)

FROM THE ROUND

WEST COAST v ESSENDON
l
no new match records were noted in the 34th contest between the pair ... ANDREW EMBLEY (WCE) reached 100 goals in game 102 ... 50th by umpire DEAN MARGETTS (2004-05) ...

HAWTHORN v ST KILDA
l the Saints posted its first trio of wins over the Hawks since 1991-92 .. no new match records were noted ...

CARLTON v BRISBANE
l the Lions won their fourth successive match against the Blues ... the Lions kicked the identical score of 21.14-140 as they did against the Blues last year at the Gabba ... TIM NOTTING (Bri) reached 100 goals in game 123 ... 100th JONATHAN BROWN (Brisbane) 2000-05 ... 50th by umpire SHAUN RYAN (2003-05) ...

PORT ADELAIDE v WEST.B'DOGS
l Port Adelaide played its 200th AFL match ... Port won their eighth successive match against the Bulldogs – last time the Dogs won, 2000-R3 at Docklands ... the Power with 8.5-53 notched a new high third quarter score versus the Doggies .. no other new match records were noted ...

SYDNEY v FREMANTLE
l the Dockers failed for the sixth time at the SCG – Freo's two wins in Sydney were in 1995-R21 and 1996-R2 ... 6.5-41 was Sydney's best third quarter of 16 contests against Fremantle ... no other new match records were noted ...

GEELONG v ADELAIDE
l the Cats were goalless in two quarters to the northern end of Kardinia Park – 2nd term 0.0-0, last quarter 0.3-3, yet still won the match by four points ... no other new match records were noted ... 50th SCOTT THOMPSON, 11 Ade 2005, 39 Mel 2001-04 ...

KANGAROOS v RICHMOND
l the Kangas won their fourth-straight against the Tigers – Richmond last beat the Roos in 2001-R21 at the MCG ... 7.2-44 was the best third term by the Kangas this year ... no other new match records were noted ... 300th career game by GLENN ARCHER (North Melb-Kangaroos) 1992-2005, 263 premiership games, 34 pre-season, 3 State ... 100th BRADY RAWLINGS (Kangaroos) 1999-2005 ...

l Richmond historian Rhett Bartlett noted the Tigers kicked 20 behinds or more against the Kangaroos for the 16th time – the following five head the list in the 142 matches played between the pair since 1925 –

1969-R3-MCG 13.28-106 v 16.15-111
1947-R1-PR 18.27-135 v 15.14-104
1938-R1-PR 19.26-140 v 9.9-63
1949-R14-PR 8.24-72 v 17.11-113
1981-R14-MCG 21.23-149 v 15.16-106

MELBOURNE v COLLINGWOOD
l
no new match records were noted in the 217th meeting ... ALAN DIDAK (Col) passed 100 goals in game 75 ... 150th PAUL LICURIA, 140 Col 1999-2005, 10 Syd 1997-98 ... JAMES CLEMENT 100th for Collingwood, also 84 Fre 1996-2000 ... 

uuuu

Statistics for Footystats are enhanced by software from
Eric Sorensen's *Footy Works* and
Steve Norval's 2005 update of *Ruckman*

uuuu


RICHMOND: HISTORY TELLS US ...
l June is the month when most Tiger supporters hold their breath ... the record book tells us the middle of the season and beyond has not been kind over the past four years —

RICHMOND – Ladder Performance

Season

R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 R8 R9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22

2000

8 11 12 12 11 11 11 8 7 6 3 3 4 3 3 7 7 8 7 7 9 9

2001

4 8 7 5 4 4 4 5 7 5 5 5 3 6 6 6 5 5 5 5 4 4

2002

3 9 7 12 12 13 13 11 11 13 13 13 14 14 14 15 15 15 14 14 14 14

2003

11 9 6 4 2 5 3 3 5 7 9 9 10 11 11 12 12 12 12 12 12 13

2004

5 11 11 14 16 13 11 9 10 11 13 14 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 16 16

2005

13 12 6 5 7 7 4 3 3 4 5 5                    

RICHMOND – W-L-D performance

Season

R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R6 R7 R8 R9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22

2000

W L L L W W L W W W W W L W L L L L W W L L

2001

W L W W W W L L L W W W W L L W W W L W W W

2002

W L W L L L W W L L L L L L L L L W W W L L

2003

L W W W W L W W L L L L L L L L W L L L L L

2004

W L L L L W W W L L L L L L L L L L L L L L

2005

L W W W L W W W W L L L                    

uuuu

Bruce Kennedy
THERE'S ALWAYS A PARALLEL ...

Our Canberra statophile Bruce Kennedy noted the parallel with scores from the R12 match between Geelong and Adelaide at Kardinia Park and two, in consecutive weeks, from almost 50 years ago.

In the Geelong-Adelaide match the scores were –

Gee 5.3 5.3 9.4 9.7-61
Ade 2.1 4.6 7.6 8.9-57

And all the more so, that the Cats goaled in two brief bursts (according to the 3AW crosses to Gary Brice, Geelong scored five in the 14 minutes at the end of the first term, and four in nine minutes at the end of the third).

There are parallels, in fact in consecutive rounds (R6 and R7) in 1958, playing at home, North Melbourne won both its matches in an almost identical manner to that in which Geelong kept Adelaide at bay.

R6, 1958, Arden Street
NM 5.7 5.7 9.10 9.10-64
Ess 0.0 4.7 5.8 7.13-55

R7, 1958, Arden Street
NM 4.5 4.5 9.8 9.8-62
Col 1.2 3.5 4.8 7.17-59

In all of the above matches, the home sides kicked first with the wind, were goalless against the wind (scoreless in the Kangaroo matches), booted nine goals for the game, and won by narrow margins.

Uncanny comparisons, don't you think?

uuuu



*

*


A crowd of 38,558 watched an absorbing match in heavy rain at Subiaco Oval on Friday night. Essendon, 14th on the ladder, took the game right up to the ladder leaders and only the dying stages did the class of West Coast pull away.

The commitment of James Hird, Scott Lucas and Mark Johnson for the visitors could not be faulted while the willingness of Daniel Kerr, Ben Cousins and David Wirrpunda to put their bodies on the line was crucial in the homeside's victory.

Sportal reported the rain began in the first term, stifling West Coast's running game, and Essendon relished the dour conditions to outscore its more fancied rival three goals to two and open up a surprise eight-point break at the first change. The Bombers' lead went out to 19 points early in the second term after their committed attack on the football was rewarded with two quick goals, and it looked as though Sheedy's men would go in at half-time with the lead.

West Coast had other ideas though, working its way back in the contest with the last four majors of the half. At the main change the margin was five points in favour of the hosts.

The Eagles extended their advantage with the first goal of the third but if they thought Essendon would throw in the towel they were mistaken. Led supberly by Hird, the visitors continued to fight and wrested back the lead midway through the third quarter before a late goal to Quinten Lynch saw the hosts turn for home in front by eight.

John Worsfold's men looked to be pulling away when they led by 15 points, only for the Bombers to reclaim the lead, but West Coast secured victory with a six-goal-to-four effort in a see-sawing final effort.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 1
West Coast v Essendon
Friday (n), June 10, 2005
Subiaco Oval, 8.40pm AEST, crowd: 38,558
Conditions: Wet and slippery
Weather: 15C, rain (heavy at times), windy
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
WCE 2.1-13 7.5-47 (5) 9.10-64 (8) 15.16-106 (24)
ESS 3.3-21 (8) 6.6-42 8.8-56 12.10-82
Goals: West Coast: Phillip Matera 4, Quinten Lynch 3, Andrew Embley 2, Brent Staker 2, Adam Selwood 2, Ben Cousins, Ashley Hansen.
Essendon: Scott Lucas 3, Matthew Lloyd 3, Mark Johnson 2, Nathan Lovett-Murray, Justin Murphy, David Hille, Mark Bolton.
Best: West Coast: Daniel Kerr, Ben Cousins, Dean Cox, David Wirrpunda, Chris Judd, Michael Braun. Essendon: Scott Lucas, Mark Johnson, James Hird, Kepler Bradley, David Hille, Justin Murphy.
Umpires (orange): Michael Vozzo, Dean Margetts, Derek Woodcock.
Reports:
l Ashley Hansen (WCE) and Kepler Bradley (Ess) cited for wrestling each other during the first quarter. The MRP offered both players fines of $900. Hansen and Bradley accepted guilt and the fines imposed by the MRP.
l Aaron Edwards (WCE) was reported by umpire MICHAEL VOZZO for charging MATTHEW LLOYD (Ess) during the third quarter. The MRP deemed Edwards has no case to answer as he was committed to the contest and contact was inevitable.

 

St Kilda went into the match against Hawthorn on Saturday afternoon with four defeats in the past five games and desperately needing a win to shore up its precarious grip in the top eight – 33,905 watched on at the MCG in mostly sunny conditions after morning rain.

While Hawthorn's two midfielders Sam Mitchell and Shane Crawford shared 65 disposals, most went sideways or backwards and their game plan continues to be questioned. The Hawks persevered with their high-risk style of play, while the Saints had both their forwards and defenders on song to add to the scoreboard pressure, with Fraser Gehrig kicking six goals and half-back Matt Maguire three.

Rohan Connolly reported in The Age: Once again, Alastair Clarkson's side simply could not get value from its time in possession. The black hole into which most of Hawthorn's good work fell was never illustrated better than at the start of the third term. The Hawks, 27 points down but still some sort of chance, used up eight or nine possessions and about a minute travelling from one half-back flank to the other.

Paul Gough noted for Sportal: The Hawks' over-reliance on brilliant small forward Mark Williams was brutally exposed by the Saints defence as the the tiny (180cm) goalsneak – who before this game was on track to become the first small forward to win the AFL goalkicking for 30 years – was held to just one goal by Max Hudghton, and that came in the final minute of the match.

The third quarter saw an interesting move by the Saints, with Nick Riewoldt showing his versatility by lining up against Peter Everitt in the ruck. With Riewoldt otherwise occupied, Allan Murray stepped up at centre half-forward in his first game of 2005 by adding two goals. St Kilda wasn't sensational, and had plenty to spare at the end. Hawthorn in contrast, looked ready to drop, its efforts having completely sapped its energy, and once again for no tangible reward.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 2
Hawthorn v St Kilda
Saturday, June 11, 2005
MCG, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 33,905
Conditions: Good, following substantial rain
Weather: Morning rain, turning to sunshine
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
HAW 1.3-9 4.4-28 5.4-34 8.6-54
STK 5.2-32 (23) 8.6-54 (26) 13.8-86 (52) 15.10-100 (46)
Goals: St Kilda: Fraser Gehrig 6.6, Matt Maguire 3, Allan Murray 2, Steven Baker, Nick Riewoldt, Aaron Fiora, Justin Peckett. Hawthorn: Ben Dixon 2, Lance Franklin, Peter Everitt, Rick Ladson, Luke Hodge, Luke Brennan, Mark Williams.
Best: St Kilda: Matt Maguire, Fraser Gehrig, Max Hudghton, Raphael Clarke, Lenny Hayes, Robert Harvey. Hawthorn: Sam Mitchell, Shane Crawford, Chance Bateman, Harry Miller.
Umpires (white): Matthew Head, Justin Schmitt, Chris Kamolins.
Report:
John Barker
(Haw) was cited for striking Brendon Goddard (StK). The MRP assessed the incident as reckless conduct (two points), medium impact (two points), in play (one point) and high contact (two points, equating to a Level Three offence, drawing 325 demerit points. Barker has no applicable good or bad record. An early plea would reduce the penalty by 25 per cent to 243.75 points and a two-game suspension. Barker accepted guilt and the imposition of a two-match suspension.

 

The Brisbane Lions notched successive wins for the first time this year when they comfortably defeated Carlton under the closed roof at Docklands on Saturday night – 37,800 attended. The Lions kicked their highest score and best margin of the season as they downed the Blues by 58 points.

The Blues started brilliantly, but were hopelessly outclassed. Jonathan Brown was best-on-ground in his 100th AFL match, with 22 possessions, nine marks and four goals in an impressive effort across the ground. Scott Spits noted for Sportal: Brown did not start the match in the centre square on Anthony Koutoufides as expected, although the Brisbane match-winner did venture there on occasions. Nonetheless, his influence was profound.

After trailing early in the match, the Lions hit the front in time-on during the first quarter, and never looked back. Promoted rookie Josh Drummond was again excellent in just his fifth match. Tim Notting (27 disposals and two goals) and Luke Power (21 touches and two goals) were also outstanding, while youngsters Anthony Corrie and Jed Adcock also shone.

In the third quarter, the Lions were notching goals at regular intervals, with Carlton failing to carry the ball with any meaning. Lance Whitnall's influence was negated while Corrie and Notting started to stamp their impact on the game. Although the Blues punched away in the last term with Matthew Lappin and Jarrad Waite slotting goals in the first four minutes, Brisbane put an exclamation mark on the big victory, kicking the last four goals of the game – including two to Daniel Merrett. It completed eight days of success for the Lions, which started with the win over Fremantle at Subiaco.

Carlton's best were Koutoufides, Lappin Whitnall and Andrew Walker.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 3
Carlton v Brisbane Lions
Saturday (n), June 11, 2005
Docklands, 7.10pm AEST, Roof closed; crowd: 37,880
Conditions: Good
Weather: 15C, cool and cloudy
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
CAR 3.3-21 8.4-52 10.7-67 12.10-82
BRI 4.5-29 (8) 11.6-72 (20) 17.11-113 (46) 21.14-140 (58)
Goals: Brisbane: Jonathan Brown 4, Anthony Corrie 3, Ashley McGrath 2, Daniel Merrett 2, Tim Notting 2, Luke Power 2, Jason Akermanis, Simon Black, Daniel Bradshaw, Josh Drummond, Clark Keating, Michael Voss. Carlton: Lance Whitnall 4, Brendan Fevola 2, Justin Davies, Ryan Houlihan, Matthew Lappin, Heath Scotland, Jarrad Waite, Andrew Walker.
Best: Brisbane: Jonathan Brown, Josh Drummond, Tim Notting, Luke Power, Daniel Bradshaw, Mal Michael. Carlton: Anthony Koutoufides, Matthew Lappin, Lance Whitnall, Andrew Walker.
Umpires (gold): Adam Davis, Shaun Ryan, Pannell.
Reports:
l Trent Sporn (Car) was reported by field umpire Shaun Ryan for charging Daniel Merrett (Bri) during the third quarter. The MRP withdrew this charge as it was deemed Sporn was committed to the contest and the contact was inevitable.
l The incident where Justin Davies (Car) clashed with Jason Akermanis (Bri) was viewed, that the contact was minimal and made with an open hand in an attempt to hit the ball. It was ruled Davies had no case to answer.
l Carlton captain Anthony Koutoufides' collision with umpire Adam Davis during the fourth quarter was deemed accidental and the result of Michael Voss (Bri) pushing him into Davis' path. The MRP decided no action be taken against Voss but warned all players that a repeat of this conduct may result in a charge being laid against the player who causes the contact.

 

Port celebrated its 200th AFL game with a hard-fought 15 point victory over the Western Bulldogs in cool and clear conditions at Football Park on Saturday night. Port's back-to-back wins for the first time this season could not have come at a better time.

Jon Ralph
noted for the Sunday Herald Sun: The Dogs followed their relentless running game plan to the letter, dominating the midfield in the first half with a pint-sized group of forwards making the most of the plentiful supply. But in one 30-minute stretch, a half of hard work was obsolete as a marauding Port slammed on eight goals to three.

Port Adelaide stars Chad and Kane Cornes and Byron Pickett led the assault as the Bulldogs watched a 19-point lead evaporate into a deficit of the same margin at three-quarter time. Even then the Dogs would not lie down – Rohan Smith's two goals kept the Dogs within breathing distance as the game turned into a shootout. When Adam Cooney goaled at the 28-minute mark of the last term, the Dogs were still within nine points. But not even the Bulldogs' surge could make up for that single-term lapse.

One damning statistic spoke volumes of the Bulldogs' lack of talented tall players – the team had only two contested marks from 120 minutes of football. Time and again the Dogs' midfield dominance was cut off at the pass by Port's defensive rocks in Chad Cornes and Brett Montgomery and returned with interest. Even the most inventive Rodney Eade-led side cannot survive without forwards of the calibre of injured pair Chris Grant and Luke Darcy. For an entire half the Bulldogs were superb, then Port blitzed the Dogs and hung on for dear life to get over the line.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 4
Port Adelaide v Western Bulldogs
Saturday (n), June 11, 2005
Football Park, 7.40pm AEST, crowd: 27,079
Conditions: Good, following a rainy week
Weather: 16C, cool and clear
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
PA 3.3-21 4.6-30 12.11-83 (19) 17.16-118 (15)
WB 4.2-26 (5) 6.7-43 (13) 9.10-64 15.13-103
Goals: Port: Byron Pickett 4, Josh Francou 3, Warren Tredrea 2, Brendon Lade, Gavin Wanganeen, Kane Cornes, Chad Cornes, Josh Mahoney, Brett Ebert, Peter Walsh, Domenic Cassisi. West.B'dogs: Ryan Hargrave 3, Adam Cooney 3, Matthew Robbins 2, Robert Murphy 2, Rohan Smith 2, Farren Ray, Nathan Eagleton, Cameron Faulkner.
Best: Port: Josh Francou, Chad Cornes, Byron Pickett, Peter Walsh, Kade Cornes, Brendon Lade. West.B'dogs: Scott West, Adam Cooney, Nathan Eagleton, Jordan McMahon, Daniel Cross, Lindsay Gilbee.
Umpires (gold): Brett Allen, Ray Chamberlain, Simon Meredith.

 

Sydney maintained its form surge by clinically dismantling an injury-depleted Fremantle under blue skies on Sunday afternoon at the SCG, in front of 24,933 fans. The Swans led at every quarter to record their fifth victory in their last six games and at the mid-year break sit equally at third place with Adelaide, Richmond and the Kangaroos on 7+5.

Amon Buchanan
was terrific with 24 possessions and veteran Paul Williams made an impressive return from a broken collarbone with a game-high 25 of his own. The Swans dominated play in the first term, with Jarrad McVeigh as a pinch-hitting forward kicking two goals and setting up another and Williams sending the ball inside 50m four times and kicking three majors.

Fremantle stayed in touch with a late six-pointer to Justin Longmuir to only trail by 13 points at quarter-time and a goal from Peter Bell had them within seven, but a Nick Davis goal from 40 metres on the run and another Ben Mathews major kept the Dockers at bay. A Sydney turnover in the backline proved costly as Jeff Farmer hit straight back and went into halftime with a 14-point advantage courtesy of an inaccurate 2.6 from Freo in the second term. A six-goal to three third quarter opened up the game for Sydney, with Barry Hall booting three of them and Davis a 60-metre bomb. Buchanan and Williams provided great run and service to their forwards as the margin blew out to six goals.

Michael O'Loughlin ended any chance of a revival with two goals in two minutes to start the last quarter before Freo hit back with a couple to prevent their poor percentage suffering an even bigger hammering. Hall made it two wins from his two matches as stand-in captain. The Dockers dropped three places to 12th after their fourth decisive loss in five games by margins of 35 or more points.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 5
Sydney v Fremantle
Sunday, June 12, 2005
SCG, 1.10pm AEST, crowd: 24,933
Conditions: Good and firm
Weather: 19C, fine, clear blue skies
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
SYD 5.3-33 (13) 8.4-52 (14) 14.9-93 (35) 16.13-109 (38)
FRE 3.2-20 5.8-38 8.10-58 10.11-71
Goals: Sydney: Michael O'Loughlin 4, Barry Hall 4, Jarrad McVeigh 2, Nick Davis 2, Adam Goodes, Ben Mathews, Jason Saddington, Amon Buchanan. Fremantle: Jeff Farmer 2, Dylan Smith, Paul Hasleby, Justin Longmuir, Peter Bell, Paul Medhurst, Daniel Gilmore, Matthew Pavlich, Ryan Murphy.
Best: Sydney: Amon Buchanan, Paul Williams, Craig Bolton, Barry Hall, Tadhg Kennelly, Leo Barry. Fremantle: Dylan Smith, Daniel Gilmore, Peter Bell, Jeff Farmer, Shane Parker.
Umpires (gold): Matt Stevic, Corin Rowe, Martin Ellis.

 

It's a bizarre day when the best offensive team in the competition is kept to just 61 points, yet still wins, and the best defensive side keeps the best offensive side to 61 points, and loses. Yet that was the case at Kardinia Park on Sunday when the Cats – the best offensive team at the start of of round 12 – managed only three behinds in two quarters of football into a stiff northerly breeze and then kicked their entire score in two brief spurts the other way, five unanswered goals in 15 minutes in the first term then four straight in under 10 minutes late in the third – LYALL JOHNSON, The Age.

Despite failing to kick a goal in the second and finals quarters, Geelong won the match over Adelaide by four points, 9.7 to 8.9. Matt Burgan reported for Sportal: All-Australian full-back Matthew Scarlett was best-on-ground, as he clearly had the better of Adelaide full-forward Scott Welsh. Scarlett finished with the incredible statistics of 30 possessions and 14 marks for someone playing in a key defensive post. Welsh had just three disposals and kicked just one behind.

Cameron Ling (37 disposals) and Paul Chapman (26 touches, 10 marks) were also among Geelong's best, while acting captain Brenton Sanderson – his first match of the year after calf and ankle problems – was an important contributor when needed most. In-form Adelaide midfielders Scott Thompson and Simon Goodwin were brilliant performers, while the ever-improving Ben Hudson was significant in the ruck. The vastly-underrated Nathan Bassett was creative and courageous in defence, while Hayden Skipworth was also a fine player with two goals.

In what was a frustrating low-scoring affair riddled with handballs (Adelaide had 187, to 169 kicks) and poor-decision making by both sides, the Crows kicked one goal in the last quarter, as the Cats were held goalless – but even that wasn't enough for Adelaide to get the points.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 6
Geelong v Adelaide
Sunday, June 12, 2005
Kardinia Park, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 23,506
Conditions: Good
Weather: 18C, fine and clear
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
GEE 5.3-33 (20) 5.3-33 9.4-58 (10) 9.7-61 (4)
ADE 2.1-13 4.6-30 7.6-48 8.9-57
Goals: Geelong: Peter Riccardi 2, Henry Playfair 2, Brad Ottens, Darren Milburn, Paul Chapman, Cameron Ling, Brenton Sanderson. Adelaide: Scott Thompson 3, Hayden Skipworth 2, Brett Burton, Ken McGregor, Ian Perrie.
Best: Geelong: Matthew Scarlett, Cameron Ling, Paul Chapman, Joshua Hunt, Darren Milburn, Brenton Sanderson. Adelaide: Scott Thompson, Simon Goodwin, Nathan Bassett, Hayden Skipworth, Ben Hudson.
Umpires (gold): Hayden Kennedy, Scott McLaren, Scott Jeffery.

 

Two contenders in the battle for top eight positions met under the open roof at Docklands Stadium on Sunday afternoon – the Kangaroos with six answered goals in 12 minutes of the third quarter were able to survive an inaccurate last term surge from the Tigers to take out a 29-point victory. With both on 7+5, the Roos appear more capable than Richmond of maintaining that sort of win-loss ratio in the second half of the season.

Len Johnson
noted in The Age: The irrepressible Kangaroos' surge (in the third term) was typical of the way the side played all day. Leigh Brown ran hard for the third time off Matthew Richardson, and it was third time lucky. Richo could not run all the way with his opponent and Brown marked and goaled from 30 metres out. Then Greg Tivendale played the ball off half-back into the centre-square. Instead of putting it into the path of a running player, he chose a high-risk target in the form of lumbering ruckman Trent Knobel. Turnover, Daniel Wells gained possession, took two bounces around the wing and showed Tivendale how to centre a ball, clipping it precisely into the path of Nathan Thompson for another mark and goal.

Again the ball flowed into the forward line and now Tivendale, over-anxious to atone for his earlier error, perhaps, tackled Wells legally but then rode him into the ground. Free kick: goal. Daniel Harris added another. Thompson led to a mark and kicked his fifth and third-gamer Brent LeCras banged one long for his first goal in AFL football. From seven points up and in control, the Tigers had gone to 31 points down – and on the way out.

It was a wasteful game for the Tigers. There was plenty of hard work, precious little return. Kane Johnson battled hard in and around the packs. Shane Tuck and Mark Coughlan made solid contributions. Richardson and Andrew Krakouer won a fair share of the ball but kicked two goals each from seven and six shots respectively.

For the Kangaroos, none were better than Leigh Colbert who controlled the central corridor. Thompson led and marked strongly for his five goals and Brent Harvey worked tirelessly up and down the ground, leading a midfield that outnumbered and outmuscled their opponents.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 7
Kangaroos v Richmond
Sunday, June 12, 2005
Docklands, 2.10pm AEST; Roof: open; crowd: 40,444
Conditions: Good
Weather: 19C, fine and clear
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
KAN 4.1-25 (7) 7.4-46 (6) 14.6-90 (30) 17.7-107 (29)
RCH 2.6-18 5.10-40 8.12-60 10.20-80
Goals: Kangaroos: Nathan Thompson 5.1, Leigh Harding 3, Daniel Harris 2, Shannon Grant 2, Daniel Wells, Glenn Archer, Leigh Brown, Corey Jones, Brent LeCras. Richmond: Matthew Richardson 2, Andrew Krakouer 2, Chris Newman 2, Kayne Pettifer, Greg Tivendale, Shane Tuck, Danny Meyer.
Best: Kangaroos: Brent Harvey, Daniel Harris, Shannon Grant, Leigh Brown, Glenn Archer, Leigh Harding, Leigh Colbert. Richmond: Kane Johnson, Mark Coughlan, Shane Tuck, Joel Bowden, Mark Chaffey, Brett Deledio.
Umpires (red): Stefan Grun, Kieron Nicholls, Darren Goldspink.

 

Melbourne retained second place on the ladder with a powerful 45-point win over Collingwood in the traditional Queen's Birthday clash at the MCG on an overcast Monday afternoon – 65,347 attended, second only to the Anzac Day crowd.

A superb 13-goal-to-four second half powered the Demons to victory. Melbourne has now won four matches on the trot and ended Collingwood's giant-killing three-game winning streak. Sportal reported on the match: After an even first half in which the lead changed hands several times, the Demons turned the game their way for good in the third term with six goals to two – with four of the majors coming from the boot of the mercurial Adem Yze.

With best afield Travis Johnstone (27 touches), Cameron Bruce and Aaron Davey providing great drive through the midfield, the Demons were irrepressible in the second half and in David Neitz, Russell Robertson and of course, Yze, they always had enough avenues to kick a winning score. And the Demons defence was at its miserly best against an attack that has been in top form in recent weeks. Jarad Rivers had the better of rising star Travis Cloke, Alistair Nicholson thrashed Chris Tarrant and Matthew Whelan finished all over Alan Didak, after the Magpie goalsneak's bright start with two goals in the first term.

Jake Niall noted in The Age: The sheer volume of Melbourne's class in the midfield and forward of centre was beyond the control of Mick Malthouse, who had little choice but to throw the likes of Ryan Lonie (Miller), Chad Morrison (Johnstone) and Shane Woewodin (Bruce) into the flames, no amount of shuffles could cover the talent gap. By the last quarter, once it was clear that Melbourne was beyond Collingwood's plucky reach, the Demons were allowed to give full expression to their talent and began to slot some improbable goals – a Bruce snap across the body from 48 metres, a 70-metre goal from Bruce that somehow cleared a pack 20 metres from goal, a pair of acute angle shots on the run from Robertson and Brock McLean.

With fewer fires on the horizon, the Demons were untroubled in extinguishing Collingwood's flames and probably, its season.
2005 — ROUND 12— GAME 8
Melbourne v Collingwood
Monday, June 13, 2005
MCG, 2.10pm AEST, crowd: 65,347
Conditions: Good, lights on from start of match
Weather: 17C, overcast
  1/4 time 1/2 time 3/4 time Final
MEL 3.6-24 (1) 4.11-35 10.13-73 (16) 17.15-117 (45)
COL 3.5-23 6.8-44 (9) 8.9-57 10.12-72
Goals: Melbourne: Adem Yze 5.2, David Neitz 3, Russell Robertson 3, Travis Johnstone 2, Cameron Bruce 2, Brock McLean, Colin Sylvia. Collingwood: Alan Didak 3, Chris Tarrant 2, Blake Caracella 2, Julian Rowe, Ryan Lonie, Shane O'Bree.
Best: Melbourne: Travis Johnstone, Adem Yze, Clint Bizzell, Aaron Davey, Matthew Whelan, Alistair Nicholson. Collingwood: Scott Burns, Tarkyn Lockyer, James Clement, Paul Licuria, Julian Rowe.
Umpires (gold): Stephen McBurney, Stuart Wenn, Shane McInerney.
Report:
Nathan D Brown
(Mel) was cited for making negligent contact with umpire Shane McInerney during the first quarter. Brown was offered a $2400 fine with an early plea. A first offence for making negligent contact with an umpire is a $3200 fine. Brown has no applicable good or bad record. An early plea would reduce the penalty by 25 per cent to a $2400 fine. Brown took the early plea and accepted guilt and the $2400 fine.


 


2005 Ladder after Round 12
W L D F A % Total
1 WEST COAST 11 1 1309 939 139.4 44
2 MELBOURNE 9 3 1322 1088 121.5 36
3 GEELONG 8 4 1273 1043 122.1 32
4 ADELAIDE 7 5 1060 866 122.4 28
5 RICHMOND 7 5 1179 1151 102.4 28
6 SYDNEY 7 5 997 1008 98.9 28
7 KANGAROOS 7 5 1078 1162 92.8 28
8 ST KILDA 6 6 1144 1054 108.5 24
9 Port Adelaide 5 6 1 988 1186 83.3 22
10 Brisbane 5 7 1140 1136 100.4 20
11 West.B'dogs 5 7 1255 1277 98.3 20
12 Fremantle 5 7 1085 1119 97.0 20
13 Collingwood 4 8 1058 1247 84.8 16
14 Essendon 4 8 1039 1252 83.0 16
15 Hawthorn 3 9 1058 1138